Box 2 of 2 · left with us by a colleague
The Relic Hunters
Hitler, Himmler and the search for sacred and powerful objects
Two boxes. Typed findings in front, my notes in the margins. Read the crimes folder first; it is the only part that needs no imagination. The rest is objects and paperwork: a lance with a museum number, a crown that spent decades at Fort Knox, an Ark that only ever turned up on film. Where the paper runs out, I say so. Where the legend starts, I say that too.
Folio 01
Himmler’s ancestral-heritage office
The Ahnenerbe (“ancestral heritage”), in full the Studiengesellschaft für Geistesurgeschichte “Deutsches Ahnenerbe”, was founded in Berlin on 1 July 1935 by the SS chief Heinrich Himmler, the Nazi ideologist Richard Walther Darré and the German-Dutch lecturer Herman Wirth, according to Yad Vashem’s Shoah Resource Center. Its stated job was to study Germany’s spiritual and historical heritage in support of Wirth’s “Germandom” ideas, but from the start it strayed into subjects with little scientific basis, such as supposed ancient Germanic letters and symbols. Himmler took charge of it in 1937.
At its height in 1939 it filled a Berlin villa and employed about 200 scholars, scientists and support staff, the Vancouver journalist Heather Pringle found in her 2006 history The Master Plan; Wolfram Sievers ran it as managing director. Her publisher sums up its real use plainly: findings meant to show ancient Aryan conquests were used to persuade SS men that they were entitled to kill Jews and others, and to guide Himmler’s plans to breed what he saw as a racially purer Europe.
How much of this reached the wider regime is still argued. Nicholas Goodrick-Clarke’s The Occult Roots of Nazism (1985) traced völkisch occult ideas from sects in the late Habsburg empire into Himmler’s SS; the historian Richard J. Evans reads him as finding that such ideas circulated mainly in the upper SS, encouraged by Himmler. Michael Kater, author of a German history of the Ahnenerbe (2006 edition), observed that its house journal Germanien was written mostly by the lower ranks while its leading scholars kept their distance.
Folio 02
Field trips with a thesis
In 1936 Wirth toured Scandinavia making plaster casts of Bronze Age rock carvings. A study by Mattias Legnér of Uppsala University, published in Antiquity and reported by IFLScience, counts 221 casts, most from Bohuslän on Sweden’s west coast, meant for an open-air museum in Germany that would present the carvings as an Aryan “holy scripture”; it was never built. ScienceNorway counts differently: 31 casts in Norway in August 1936, 59 in Sweden and 16 in Denmark, with 52 surviving today in a small museum in Austria. At Tanum, Wirth was criticized for damaging carvings and refused permission to make more.
For the Ahnenerbe, the historian Franz Altheim and the photographer Erika Trautmann worked on the rock art of Val Camonica in northern Italy; like other 1930s scholars they dated all of it to the Iron Age, which later research shows was wrong. On 30 June 1938 the pair asked the Ahnenerbe to fund a trip to the Roman Empire’s eastern frontier, framing it as a racial struggle between northern peoples and the Semitic East. The money came within two weeks. They reached Hatra, in Iraq, in October 1938, and Altheim’s confidential report of 14 January 1939 dwelt more on the political leanings of the people they met than on archaeology, Marco Moriggi found in the German federal archives.
Other projects reached further. Tenho Pimiä has studied Ahnenerbe-linked folk-culture research in Karelia from the mid-1930s, around the Finnish nobleman Yrjö von Grönhagen, asking whether it was serious scholarship or ideological decoration. Edmund Kiss, a follower of Hörbiger’s “World Ice Theory” who had visited Tiwanaku in Bolivia in 1928, asked the Ahnenerbe by 1939 to fund a return expedition; Sievers costed it at about 100,000 Reichsmarks, and after delays it was cancelled in 1941.
Folio 03
Tibet, 1938–39
Five Germans led by the zoologist Ernst Schäfer sailed from Genoa on 20 April 1938 and reached Calcutta on 13 May: Schäfer, the anthropologist Bruno Beger, the geophysicist Karl Wienert, the botanist and cameraman Ernst Krause and the technical chief Edmund Geer. All were SS men; Krause and Wienert were made members when they joined. Tibet first refused them, then in November 1938 invited them, and on 19 January 1939 they entered Lhasa, the first Germans to do so, staying about two months.
What they were for is still disputed. The Tibet historian Isrun Engelhardt argued that the expedition had no occult purpose, that its aim was a full scientific record of the country, that its members rejected the World Ice Theory, and that the Ahnenerbe did not in the end sponsor it: most of its 112,111 Reichsmarks came from a business advertising council, the Nazi party publisher Eher Verlag, the German research foundation, the Foreign Office and private donors. Others, among them the anthropologist Édouard Conte, have argued that it served racial theory. Beger measured 376 Tibetans, made casts of the heads, faces, hands and ears of 17 more, and took the prints of 350.
Accounts of the return differ: one study says the team left Tibet in August 1939 and was met by Himmler at Berlin’s Tempelhof airport; Engelhardt describes a hasty departure before the war began. A Kanjur, the Tibetan Buddhist canon, given to the team in Lhasa is held today in the Bavarian State Library. Engelhardt notes that Schäfer, sometimes called a “Nazi Indiana Jones”, never searched for the Ark or the Grail. A meteorite statue nicknamed the “Iron Man” is often said to have come back with the team; the Buddhist scholar Achim Bayer argues it is only decades old.
Folio 04
The crimes in the files
From 1942 the Ahnenerbe sponsored experiments on concentration camp prisoners, among them Sigmund Rascher’s freezing and high-altitude experiments at Dachau, as Yad Vashem’s records show. These were crimes, not science, carried out on people who had no say.
The anatomist August Hirt, head of the anatomy institute at the Reich University of Strasbourg, wanted a collection of Jewish skeletons. Eighty-six Jews selected at Auschwitz were deported in the summer of 1943 to the Natzweiler-Struthof camp in Alsace and murdered in a gas chamber equipped for the purpose. Bruno Beger took part in choosing them; one study says he had proposed a skull collection to Sievers in December 1941. Remains of victims were still held at a forensic institute in Strasbourg until July 2015, when the historian Raphael Toledano found them; they were buried on 6 September 2015.
Wolfram Sievers was tried at Nuremberg in the Doctors’ Trial, charged over the skeleton collection and over experiments on prisoners, sentenced to death on 20 August 1947 and hanged on 2 June 1948. The indictment said 112 Jews were killed for the collection; Beger’s court settled on 86, and one study says 115 were deported. Beger was arrested in 1960, tried from 27 October 1970 and convicted on 6 April 1971 as an accomplice to the murder of 86 Jews; he was sentenced to three years and released at once for time served. His two co-defendants were not convicted.
Folio 05
What Hitler believed, and who made the rest up
What Himmler did is documented; what Hitler believed is argued over. In a September 1938 speech Hitler called National Socialism a cool, reality-based doctrine and said “subversion by occult searchers for the Beyond must not be tolerated”, Richard J. Evans notes. Most leading Nazis treated esoteric ideas with disdain, Evans writes, with Himmler the exception. Goebbels ordered vague mythical notions kept out of the press in 1935, Martin Bormann condemned soothsayers and palm-readers in a circular of 7 May 1941, and after Rudolf Hess’s flight to Britain Hitler approved a crackdown on occultists.
Eric Kurlander’s Hitler’s Monsters (Yale, 2017) argues that supernatural thinking ran wide at the top of the regime. Evans, reviewing it in the London Review of Books on 2 August 2018, called the central argument flawed and faulted its use of Hermann Rauschning’s Hitler Speaks, which he considers largely invented; Kurlander replied in the letters page that August.
The occult Reich of popular legend was mostly built after the war. Louis Pauwels and Jacques Bergier’s Le Matin des magiciens (1960; in English 1964) spun earlier fiction into a bestseller. Stéphane François traces to it the idea that the Thule Society secretly ran Nazism, which he treats as a myth; Evans describes Thule as a small far-right group that schooled Hess, Hans Frank and Alfred Rosenberg, and Engelhardt notes that Hitler never attended a Thule meeting. “Vril” comes from Edward Bulwer-Lytton’s 1871 novel The Coming Race; the only evidence for a “Vril Society” is a 1947 essay by Willy Ley.
Folio 06
The Holy Lance: what the Treasury says
The Holy Lance in Vienna’s Imperial Treasury (inventory WS XIII 19) is a Carolingian winged lance of the 8th century, 50.7 centimetres long and 968 grams, the Kunsthistorisches Museum says. An iron pin set into an opening in its blade was soon taken for one of the nails of the Crucifixion; in the museum’s words, “pious wishful thinking soon turned the central pin into one of the nails.” Over the centuries it was called the lance of Constantine and of Saint Maurice, and by the 13th century the lance of Longinus, the soldier who pierced Christ’s side.
Emperor Henry III added a silver sleeve in the second half of the 11th century, its inscription saying it confirmed the nail and lance of the Lord; Charles IV (who reigned 1346–1378) added a gold one reading LANCEA ET CLAVVS DOMINI and won a church feast in honour of the Lance and the Nail. The story itself goes back to the Gospel of John. Pilgrims in Jerusalem were venerating a spear by the 6th century, and other claimants survive in the Vatican, Poland and Armenia.
In 2003 the British metallurgist Robert Feather examined the Vienna lance with X-ray diffraction and fluorescence, TIME reported in June that year. He dated its main body to the 7th century at the earliest and found the pin “consistent” in length and shape with a 1st-century Roman nail, while saying the iron around it cannot be dated and the link to the Crucifixion is speculation that cannot be ruled out. The museum’s own date, the 8th century, sits about a century later.
Folio 07
Vienna to Nuremberg and back, 1938–1946
Emperor Sigismund gave Nuremberg the right to keep the imperial regalia forever in 1424. In 1796, with Napoleon’s army coming, they left for Regensburg and then, secretly, Vienna. In 1938 Hitler had them brought from Vienna to Nuremberg, where they were shown in St Catherine’s Church, the city’s museums record; Himmler ordered them kept in copper containers. Sidney Kirkpatrick’s Hitler’s Holy Relics (2010) argues that Hitler prized them as symbols of a medieval German empire.
In the war the treasures went into the Historic Art Bunker, cut 24 metres into the rock under Nuremberg’s Castle Hill, and American soldiers found the regalia there in 1945. Five pieces, the crown, two swords, the sceptre and the orb, were missing. Lt Walter Horn, a German-born art historian serving as a US Army art-intelligence officer, was sent to Nuremberg on 20 July 1945 to find them. After many interrogations, including of an assistant to the city’s mayor, he recovered them on 7 August 1945 from a hidden room in an underground bunker. Officials had apparently hidden them as a rallying symbol for a future Nazi resistance; HistoryNet places the hiding place behind a wall in the Paniersplatz air-raid shelter, about 80 feet (some 24 metres) down.
The regalia went back to the Hofburg in Vienna on 4 and 5 January 1946. Accounts differ on details: Kirkus’s summary of Kirkpatrick’s book has Horn on the trail in early 1945 and names the Lance as the prize, while the National Archives has him assigned in July, and the Monuments Men and Women Foundation lists the five missing pieces without the Lance.
Folio 08
How the Spear got its “destiny”
The legend that matters to this file is a modern one: a frequently quoted account holds that whoever claims the Spear and solves its secrets holds the world’s destiny, as TIME put it in 2003. Its best-known telling is Trevor Ravenscroft’s The Spear of Destiny (1972; often dated 1973). Ravenscroft claimed that the young Hitler was steeped in the occult in Vienna, that he drew power from ritual and the Spear, and that he seized it from the Hofburg on the day Germany marched into Austria. His source, he said, was Walter Johannes Stein.
Kevin McClure, writing in Magonia in 2006, set out the problems. Stein’s own writings, including a 1936 autobiography, never mention Hitler or the Spear; Stein died in 1957, and Ravenscroft probably never met him. The tale traces back to a 1960 Sunday Dispatch feature by Max Caulfield. In a 1980 copyright case, Ravenscroft said his book drew on “a psychic medium”. The writer Ken Anderson called its history unreliable.
What the record does show is narrower. Hitler did have the Lance moved to Nuremberg with the rest of the regalia in 1938, and it came back. No document in the sources gathered for this file shows him attributing powers to it. Engelhardt lists Ravenscroft among the later writers who added inventions to the Nazi-occult story.
Folio 09
Otto Rahn and the Grail
Otto Rahn, born on 18 February 1904, travelled to the Pyrenees in 1931 convinced that the Cathars, the medieval heretics crushed in the Albigensian Crusade, were linked to the Holy Grail, and that the keys to the mystery lay beneath Montségur, the last Cathar fortress to fall. His Kreuzzug gegen den Gral (Crusade Against the Grail) came out in the early 1930s (1934 in some lists, 1933 in others). In 1933 Himmler telegraphed him about his work.
Rahn joined Himmler’s staff and became a full SS member in March 1936. Luzifers Hofgesind (Lucifer’s Court) followed in 1937. He was given guard duty at the Dachau concentration camp, offered his resignation in February 1939, and Himmler accepted it. On 13 March 1939 local children found his body in a ravine near Söll, in Tyrol. His death was privately ruled a suicide; Himmler told the SS it was a mountaineering accident. Claims that he faked his death have never been substantiated.
No Grail appears anywhere in the record. Kirsten John-Stucke of the Wewelsburg district museum writes that an analogy between Wewelsburg’s round hall and the Grail castle of Wagner’s Parsifal may be drawn, but that no written source confirms it, and she criticizes television documentaries whose Indiana Jones-style narrators hunt Grail or Lance hiding places there and verify nothing.
Folio 10
Himmler’s stage sets: Wewelsburg, Quedlinburg, the Externsteine
Himmler rented Wewelsburg castle in Westphalia from June 1934 for a planned SS school. From 1939 prisoners from a concentration camp set up in Wewelsburg for the purpose were used to rebuild it, and at least 1,285 of them died. In the North Tower they dug a domed crypt and built a round hall with twelve columns and a sun-wheel inlay in the floor; no written records explain the design. Plans made during the war put the castle at the centre of a vast complex, a “centre of the world”. Himmler visited at least 25 times, and it was blown up as American troops arrived in April 1945.
Most of its legend came later, John-Stucke writes: from the memoirs of the SS intelligence chief Walter Schellenberg and a book based on the recollections of Himmler’s adjutant Karl Wolff, which cast it as an SS cloister with a Round Table. No SS rituals there can be verified. Since the 1990s the far right has called the floor inlay a “black sun”; the museum now covers it with bean bags.
At Quedlinburg on 2 July 1936 Himmler marked a thousand years since the death of King Henry I, and the king’s burial shaft turned out to be empty. Bones “found” in 1937 were reburied with ceremony; when the sarcophagus was opened on 25 February 1948 it held a woman’s skeleton. At the Externsteine rocks, Himmler became president of a foundation in 1933 and Julius Andree dug in 1934–35; later analysis found no archaeological evidence of use between the end of the Upper Paleolithic and the Carolingian period.
Folio 11
The Ark of the Covenant: a hunt that happened on screen
Of all the objects in this file, the Ark has the thinnest Nazi paper trail. Raiders of the Lost Ark opened on 12 June 1981, with a story credited to George Lucas and Philip Kaufman. According to the American Film Institute’s catalogue, the two spent three weeks on Lucas’s archaeologist-adventurer idea in 1975, and Kaufman combined it with the legend of the lost Ark of the Covenant; the AFI entry credits Ravenscroft’s book for that legend, though Ravenscroft wrote about the Spear.
On the record: in the sources gathered for this file, which include Yad Vashem’s summary of the Ahnenerbe’s work, histories of its expeditions, its own travel reports as quoted from the German federal archives, and the Nuremberg trial records, no Ark project appears. Engelhardt notes that Schäfer, compared by some writers to a “Nazi Indiana Jones”, never searched for the Ark or the Grail. Evans mentions the Ark only by way of the film.
The idea has kept going on television. John-Stucke describes documentaries that send a presenter in leather jacket and hat after secret relic hiding places at Wewelsburg, only to find that nothing can be verified. A real Ahnenerbe file on the Ark would change this entry; none has surfaced.
Folio 12
The real treasure hunt: loot, salt mines and the Monuments Men
The relic hunt that really happened was organized theft. On 3 May 1945 Lt James Rorimer reached Neuschwanstein castle, a repository of the Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR), the Nazi looting agency, and found its records of 203 private collections from France, the Rothschilds’ among them, and catalogue cards for 21,903 confiscations. Rose Valland, who had tracked the Germans’ handling of art in Paris, had given him a list of the caches.
The Altaussee salt mine in Austria held looted art from 1943 to 1945; eight unexploded bombs, disguised as crates of marble, were brought into its tunnels, and miners saved the art. The Ghent Altarpiece had reached Altaussee from Neuschwanstein in 1944; it was flown back to Brussels on 21 August 1945. Michelangelo’s Madonna and Child, taken from Bruges on 8 September 1944, followed. Veit Stoss’s altarpiece, evacuated from Kraków in 1939, was found by an SS unit, taken to Berlin and in March 1940 to Nuremberg; it reached Poland again on 30 April 1946 aboard a 27-car train.
Hungary’s Holy Crown was moved west by its guards in 1944–45 and buried in a barrel at Mattsee, Austria, on the night of 26 April 1945. The US 86th Infantry Division recovered it on 4 May 1945, and it spent decades at Fort Knox until Cyrus Vance handed it to Antal Apró in Budapest on 6 January 1978. Hundreds of thousands of looted cultural objects are still missing, the Monuments Men and Women Foundation says.
Chronology
8th century
A lance is made
The Imperial Treasury dates the Holy Lance to the Carolingian 8th century; a 2003 study put its main body no earlier than the 7th.
1346–1378
A gold sleeve
Charles IV adds a gold sleeve inscribed LANCEA ET CLAVVS DOMINI and wins a church feast for the Lance and the Nail.
1424
Nuremberg’s keeping
Emperor Sigismund grants Nuremberg the right to keep the imperial regalia forever.
1796
Away from Napoleon
With French armies approaching, the regalia leave Nuremberg for Regensburg and then Vienna.
1871
A novel invents Vril
Edward Bulwer-Lytton’s The Coming Race imagines a force called Vril; the only evidence for a later “Vril Society” is a 1947 essay.
1933
Himmler takes an interest
Himmler telegraphs Otto Rahn about his Grail theories and becomes president of an Externsteine foundation.
June 1934
Wewelsburg rented
Himmler begins renting Wewelsburg castle for a planned SS school.
1934–1935
Digging at the Externsteine
Julius Andree excavates the rocks; later analysis finds no evidence of use between the Upper Paleolithic and the Carolingian period.
1 July 1935
The Ahnenerbe is founded
Himmler, Richard Walther Darré and Herman Wirth found the society in Berlin.
2 July 1936
An empty royal grave
Himmler marks 1,000 years since King Henry I’s death at Quedlinburg; the king’s burial shaft is empty.
August 1936
Casting the rocks
Wirth’s team makes plaster casts of rock carvings in Norway, part of a Scandinavian tour that also takes in Bohuslän in Sweden.
1937
Himmler in charge
Himmler takes control of the Ahnenerbe; Rahn publishes Luzifers Hofgesind.
1938
The regalia go to Nuremberg
On Hitler’s order the imperial regalia, the Holy Lance among them, leave Vienna for Nuremberg.
20 April 1938
Sailing for Tibet
Ernst Schäfer’s five-man team leaves Genoa for India.
September 1938
Hitler on occultists
In a speech Hitler calls National Socialism a reality-based doctrine and rejects “occult searchers for the Beyond”.
October 1938
Altheim at Hatra
Franz Altheim and Erika Trautmann reach Hatra, in Iraq, on an Ahnenerbe-funded trip.
19 January 1939
Lhasa
Schäfer’s team enters Lhasa, the first Germans to do so, and stays about two months.
13 March 1939
Rahn found dead
Otto Rahn’s body is found near Söll, in Tyrol, weeks after he left the SS.
1942
Experiments on prisoners
The Ahnenerbe begins sponsoring experiments on concentration camp prisoners, including Rascher’s at Dachau.
Summer 1943
The 86
Eighty-six Jews selected at Auschwitz are murdered at Natzweiler-Struthof for August Hirt’s skeleton collection.
7 August 1945
Behind the wall
Lt Walter Horn recovers the missing crown, swords, sceptre and orb from a hidden room in a Nuremberg bunker.
4–5 January 1946
Back to Vienna
The imperial regalia, the Holy Lance included, return to the Hofburg.
2 June 1948
Sievers hanged
Wolfram Sievers, sentenced to death at the Nuremberg Doctors’ Trial on 20 August 1947, is executed.
1960
The magicians
Pauwels and Bergier publish Le Matin des magiciens, the bestseller behind much of the Nazi-occult legend.
6 April 1971
Beger convicted
Bruno Beger is convicted as an accomplice to the murder of 86 Jews and sentenced to three years.
1972
The Spear of Destiny
Trevor Ravenscroft’s book launches the idea that Hitler drew occult power from the Holy Lance.
6 January 1978
A crown goes home
Cyrus Vance returns Hungary’s Holy Crown in Budapest after decades at Fort Knox.
12 June 1981
Raiders of the Lost Ark
The film puts the Nazis on the trail of the Ark of the Covenant.
Exhibits
Each tag: what’s said to be there, what’s actually on the record, and where that stands today.
-
Exhibit A
The Holy Lance
Imperial Treasury, Hofburg, Vienna (inv. WS XIII 19)
Said: Hitler seized the Lance after Austria was annexed and took it to Nuremberg.
On record: Moved with the imperial regalia to Nuremberg in 1938, kept in the city’s art bunker, returned to the Hofburg on 4–5 January 1946. Dated to the 8th century by the museum; the 2003 tests put its main body no earlier than the 7th.
-
Exhibit B
Imperial Crown, sceptre, orb and two swords
Imperial Treasury, Hofburg, Vienna
Said: Nuremberg officials hid them in 1945 as a rallying symbol for a Nazi resistance.
On record: Missing when the Americans opened the art bunker; recovered by Lt Walter Horn on 7 August 1945 from a hidden room in an underground bunker. The resistance motive is the investigators’ reading (“apparently”).
-
Exhibit C
Holy Crown of Hungary
Budapest (shown in the Parliament since 1 January 2000)
Said: Lost to the Nazis or the Soviets at the end of the war.
On record: Buried in a barrel at Mattsee, Austria, by its guards on 26 April 1945; recovered by the US 86th Infantry Division on 4 May 1945; kept at Fort Knox; returned on 6 January 1978.
-
Exhibit D
The Ghent Altarpiece
Ghent, Belgium (returned 1945)
Said: Hidden by the Nazis in a salt mine that was rigged to be blown up.
On record: Moved from Neuschwanstein to Altaussee in 1944; flown back to Brussels on 21 August 1945 and shown to the press on 3 September 1945.
-
Exhibit E
Michelangelo’s Madonna and Child
Bruges, Belgium
Said: Taken from Bruges in the last weeks of the occupation.
On record: Taken by the Germans on 8 September 1944 and moved to Altaussee; packed for return in late July 1945.
-
Exhibit F
Veit Stoss altarpiece
Kraków, Poland
Said: Stolen by the SS and hidden under Nuremberg.
On record: Evacuated to Sandomierz in 1939, found by an SS unit, sent to Berlin in October 1939 and to Nuremberg in March 1940; back in Poland on 30 April 1946.
-
Exhibit G
Wirth’s rock-art casts
52 in a small museum in Austria; one in Trondheim, Norway
Said: Proof of an Aryan “holy scripture” carved in Scandinavian rock.
On record: Casts made in 1936 for an open-air museum that was never built; counts differ (221 in one study; 31, 59 and 16 by country in another).
-
Exhibit H
The Lhasa Kanjur
Bavarian State Library, Munich
Said: A secret gift from Tibet to Hitler.
On record: A set of the Tibetan Buddhist canon given to Schäfer’s team in Lhasa; Engelhardt finds no support for the “gift for Hitler” story.
-
Exhibit I
The “Iron Man” statue
Private hands
Said: An ancient Tibetan figure carved from a meteorite and brought back by the 1938–39 expedition.
On record: Meteorite material is accepted; the Buddhist scholar Achim Bayer argues it is only decades old, perhaps made for the Nazi memorabilia market.
-
Exhibit J
“King Henry I’s” bones
Quedlinburg (removed from the crypt)
Said: The SS found and reburied King Henry I in 1937.
On record: When the sarcophagus was opened on 25 February 1948 it held a woman’s skeleton; the remains were reburied elsewhere.
-
Exhibit K
The Holy Grail
Nowhere on record
Said: The Cathars guarded it and it lay beneath Montségur, as Otto Rahn believed; or Himmler kept it at Wewelsburg.
On record: Rahn’s books and Himmler’s interest are documented; no object is. No written source links Wewelsburg’s round hall to the Grail.
-
Exhibit L
The Ark of the Covenant
Nowhere on record
Said: Nazi archaeologists hunted it.
On record: No Ahnenerbe Ark project appears in the sources gathered here; the story enters popular culture with Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981).
What’s said, what’s on file
| What’s said | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| Whoever holds the Spear of Destiny rules the world, and Hitler’s fortunes rose and fell with it. | The “destiny” story traces to a 1960 Sunday Dispatch feature and Trevor Ravenscroft’s 1972 book, whose named source never mentioned Hitler or the Spear in his own writings; in court Ravenscroft said he had used a psychic medium. |
| Hitler was an occult initiate steered by mystics. | In September 1938 Hitler publicly rejected “occult searchers for the Beyond”, and the regime curbed fortune-tellers and occultists, notably in 1941. Himmler was the exception, Richard J. Evans argues; Eric Kurlander argues the supernatural ran deeper. |
| The Nazis searched for the Ark of the Covenant. | No Ark project appears in the Ahnenerbe material gathered for this file. The idea took hold with Raiders of the Lost Ark in 1981. |
| The Thule Society was the hidden power behind Nazism. | Thule was a small far-right group that schooled Hess, Frank and Rosenberg; Hitler never attended a meeting, Engelhardt notes. The “secret centre” idea was popularized in 1960 by Pauwels and Bergier; Stéphane François treats it as a myth. |
| A Vril Society tapped a secret energy for the Reich. | Vril comes from an 1871 novel. The only evidence for a “Vril Society” is a 1947 essay by Willy Ley, Isrun Engelhardt found. |
| Wewelsburg was the SS Grail castle, where Himmler’s twelve knights held secret rites. | No written records explain the round hall’s design and no SS rituals there can be verified, the Wewelsburg museum’s Kirsten John-Stucke writes; the Round Table story grew from post-war memoirs. |
| The Tibet expedition went looking for hidden masters and Aryan origins in the occult. | Engelhardt found no occult purpose: the aim was a scientific record of Tibet, though its anthropologist ran a racial survey. The occult framing came from French writers and later authors. |
Still open
- Most of the Ahnenerbe’s own archive was burned at the end of the war, one study notes; what survives is in the German federal archives (series NS 21). What went into the fire is not known.
- How many people were brought to Natzweiler for the Strasbourg collection? The Nuremberg indictment said 112, Beger’s court settled on 86 murdered, and one study says 115 were deported. Remains of victims sat in a Strasbourg institute until July 2015.
- Otto Rahn’s death on 13 March 1939 was privately ruled a suicide while Himmler told the SS it was a mountaineering accident; the sources do not reconcile the two versions.
- Five pieces of the imperial regalia stayed hidden from the Americans until 7 August 1945. Who ordered it rests on interrogations, and accounts differ on the dates and on whether the Holy Lance was ever among the missing.
- When Wewelsburg was blown up in April 1945, camp prisoners had hidden much of its art and the castle was then looted; the museum’s account does not say where it all went.
- Was the “Iron Man” statue ever in Tibet? Its meteorite material is accepted, its 1938 provenance is unproven, and Achim Bayer argues it may be a post-war piece made for collectors.
- Where is King Henry I? The SS found his burial shaft empty in 1936, and the bones it reburied in 1937 turned out in 1948 to be a woman’s.
- Hundreds of thousands of cultural objects looted in the war are still missing, the Monuments Men and Women Foundation says.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified They admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?
Declassified, as far as the paperwork goes. Himmler’s Ahnenerbe, its expeditions and its crimes are on the record, and so is the Holy Lance’s round trip from Vienna to Nuremberg and back; the Spear’s world-ruling power, a Nazi hunt for the Ark and the Vril Society rate Tinfoil on everything surfaced so far. An Ahnenerbe file on the Ark or the Grail turning up among the papers that survived the burning would reopen those drawers.
Sources
Numbered as the folios cite them. Links open in a new tab.
- Die Heilige Lanze (The Holy Lance), inv. WS XIII 19 Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, Imperial Treasury
- Piercing an Ancient Tale (8 June 2003) TIME
- Historians to appear in History Channel documentary on the Holy Lance University of Notre Dame, College of Arts and Letters
- Beneath 24 Meters of Rock: the art works (Historic Art Bunker permanent exhibition) Museen der Stadt Nürnberg
- The Secret Art Bunker of Nuremberg HistoryNet
- Walter Horn Monuments Men and Women Foundation
- A Monuments Man Investigator: Walter Horn (30 January 2014) US National Archives, The Text Message blog
- Review: Hitler’s Holy Relics by Sidney D. Kirkpatrick (2010) Kirkus Reviews
- Making Hitler Magic: Unravelling the Spear of Destiny Hoax, by Kevin McClure (Magonia 92, June 2006) Magonia
- Nuts about the Occult (review of Eric Kurlander, Hitler’s Monsters), by Richard J. Evans, vol. 40 no. 15, 2 August 2018 London Review of Books
- Ahnenerbe (Shoah Resource Center entry) Yad Vashem, International School for Holocaust Studies
- The Medical Case (NMT 1, U.S.A. v. Karl Brandt et al.) Harvard Law School, Nuremberg Trials Project
- Le nom des 86 (documentary on the victims of the Strasbourg skeleton collection) dora films
- Remains of Nazi professor’s victims buried in France (7 September 2015) The Local France
- Bruno Beger Wikipedia
- German Expedition to Tibet (1938–1939), by Charlie Caron (Asia Focus, January 2021) IRIS, Asia Programme
- Nazis of Tibet: A Twentieth Century Myth, by Isrun Engelhardt (in Images of Tibet in the 19th and 20th Centuries, EFEO, 2008) info-buddhism.com (reprint)
- Bad Science Serves Bad Ideas (review of Heather Pringle, The Master Plan), by Stan Persky, 8 August 2006 The Tyee
- The Master Plan: Himmler’s Scholars and the Holocaust, by Heather Pringle Hachette Book Group
- The Occult Roots of Nazism, by Nicholas Goodrick-Clarke NYU Press
- Nazi Occultism: Between the SS and Esotericism, by Stéphane François (2023) Routledge
- Auf der Suche nach Hatra: Franz Altheims Forschungsreise im Nahen Osten, by Marco Moriggi (Kervan 25/2, 2021) Kervan, University of Turin
- German Folk Culture Research in Karelia in the 1930s, by Tenho Pimiä (Ethnologia Fennica 31, 2004) Ethnologia Fennica
- Norway’s most famous rock carving may have been preserved by a Nazi researcher, by Bård Amundsen (10 June 2024) ScienceNorway
- Nazi archaeologists tried to prove that Swedish rock art was the holy scripture of a fictional race, by Benjamin Taub IFLScience
- A che punto è lo studio dell’arte rupestre della Valcamonica, by A. E. Fossati and R. De Marinis (Preistoria Alpina, 2012) Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore (PubliCatt)
- Edmund Kiss Wikipedia
- Otto Rahn Wikipedia
- Wewelsburg Castle: an attraction pole of dark tourism, by Kirsten John-Stucke (IC Memo, 5 July 2016) ICOM International Committee of Memorial Museums
- How the SS Hunted for the Skeleton of a King from the Dark Ages, by Zita Ballinger Fletcher HistoryNet (Military History)
- Externsteine Wikipedia
- Returning the Holy Crown established a strong tie between Hungary and the United States Government of Hungary, Ministry of Defence (archived site)
- The return of the Holy Crown Hungary Foundation
- The Monuments Men in August 1945: The Belgian Treasures (15 October 2015) US National Archives, The Text Message blog
- In the footsteps of history inside Altaussee salt mine Salzwelten (Altaussee salt mine)
- Karol Estreicher: The Polish Monuments Man (9 January 2014) US National Archives, The Text Message blog
- The Monuments Men in May 1945: Buxheim and Neuschwanstein (1 September 2015) US National Archives, The Text Message blog
- Monuments Men and Women Foundation (home page) Monuments Men and Women Foundation
- Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981): catalogue entry and history AFI Catalog of Feature Films
- Nazi Iron Man Buddha?, by Samir S. Patel (January/February 2013) Archaeology magazine
About these boxes. The colleague who left them is part of the motel, like the man in room 33: his notes in the margins are ours. The research is real. Every folio lists its sources, and where the sources disagree, the file says so. The case is never closed: if you have something that belongs in this box, send a tip.
← Back to the room (the boxes) Box 1 of 2 → All the case files