How we rate

A rating is where a case stands today, not the last word. Some theories turned out to be true, some have real kernels of truth, and some are pure fun. Every story carries one of these five ratings, and when new papers come out, the rating moves. No file here is ever closed.

Declassified They admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Redacted Real facts underneath, and the theory fits them, but pieces are still blacked out.

Under Review Serious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Unconfirmed Thin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Tinfoil For fun. Nothing solid has surfaced, and the official answer is no. The hat stays on the hook, just in case.

Ratings are our editorial judgment, based on the sources listed with each story as of the day we last checked them.