Vanishings & strange deaths

Ambrose Small: the Toronto theatre millionaire who vanished on December 2, 1919

A day after taking a $1 million cheque for his theatre chain, Ambrose Small left his office at Toronto’s Grand Opera House and was never seen again; no body was ever found.

UnconfirmedThin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Published Oct. 17, 2026Last checked Oct. 11, 2026

What’s claimed

Ambrose Small, a Toronto theatre owner, became a millionaire on December 1, 1919, and disappeared the next evening. More than a century later, the case is still argued over. The popular theories are that he was murdered and his body burned in the Grand Opera House furnace or dumped in the Rosedale ravine, that his wife was involved, or that he simply walked away from his life.

What’s on the record

The Dictionary of Canadian Biography traces Small’s rise from usher and bartender at the Grand Opera House on Adelaide Street to its owner in 1903, and then to the head of a circuit of 34 theatres. Known as a reckless gambler with a fondness for chorus girls, he married Theresa Kormann, from a brewing family, in 1902. In late November 1919, the couple sold their chain to Trans-Canada Theatres Limited for $1.7 million, and on December 1 they received $1 million on account.

What happened the next day is pieced together from witnesses. In an excerpt from her book The Missing Millionaire, published in the Toronto Star, Katie Daubs describes Small getting a shave around 1 p.m., having lunch with his lawyer and Theresa, and walking his wife to an orphans’ home, promising to be home for dinner. His lawyer, Edward Flock, saw him at the Grand at 5 p.m. and left at 5:30. That is the last confirmed sighting. Accounts differ on who deposited the $1 million cheque: the dictionary says Theresa did, Daubs writes that Ambrose put it in his personal account. Either way, the money sat untouched.

Theresa did not go to the police at once. She feared a scandal, the dictionary notes, and said she believed her husband was “in the hands of a designing woman.” In January 1920, after a preliminary police inquiry, Theresa posted rewards and an international hunt began. Small’s former secretary, John Doughty, had also vanished on December 2; he was later found in the United States and convicted of stealing bonds from Small’s safe deposit box, but no evidence tied him to the disappearance, and charges of kidnapping were never pressed against anyone. Small was declared dead in 1923. His sisters contested his will without success, and Theresa received an estate valued at about $1.09 million. She died in 1935, leaving much of it to the Catholic Church.

What doesn’t add up

Small had every reason to stay: he had just made the deal of his life and took none of the money. That points many people toward murder, but every murder story rests on second-hand accounts. Daubs recounts that a school caretaker flooding a skating rink above the Rosedale ravine that night saw four men drag something heavy from a car toward the dump. A caretaker at Small’s theatre in London, Ont., claimed Theresa and a lover had burned the body there, a story the dictionary records without endorsing. In 1936, a letter signed only “Reuter” confessed to the crime and named both the ravine and the Grand Opera House furnace. That year an Ontario Provincial Police inspector, Edward Hammond, reviewed the files and concluded Small was murdered in a plot in which his wife was the prime mover. Theresa had died the year before, nobody was charged, and the case was closed in 1960. No body, bone or ransom note has ever been found.

Still open

Nobody knows whether Ambrose Small was killed, ran away or met some other end. No body, bone or ransom note has ever been found, and no one was ever charged. In 1936 an OPP inspector concluded his wife was the prime mover in a murder plot, but she had died the year before, and the case was closed in 1960. The “Reuter” confession was never verified, and even who deposited the $1 million cheque differs between accounts.

Where it stands (for now)

Unconfirmed. Small’s disappearance is fully documented, and murder is the most widely held explanation, but it rests on hearsay and an unverified confession. Nothing found so far shows whether he was killed, ran away or met some other end.

Sources

  1. Document SMALL, AMBROSE JOSEPH · Dictionary of Canadian Biography
  2. News He was a scoundrel with a jealous wife and a troubled mistress. He made the deal of a lifetime — then vanished · Toronto Star · Sept. 5, 2019
  3. Source Disappearance of Ambrose Small · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip