Amelia Earhart’s disappearance: crash and sink, the Nikumaroro bones and other theories
Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan vanished over the Pacific on July 2, 1937; a crash at sea, a castaway death on Nikumaroro and Japanese capture all have backers, but no plane.
What’s claimed
Amelia Earhart and her navigator, Fred Noonan, disappeared on July 2, 1937, while trying to reach tiny Howland Island in the central Pacific on Earhart’s attempt to fly around the world in a Lockheed Electra 10-E. Three main explanations have competed ever since. The crash-and-sink theory says they ran out of fuel near Howland and went into the sea. The Nikumaroro hypothesis, championed by The International Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery (TIGHAR), says they landed on the reef of Nikumaroro, then called Gardner Island, and died there as castaways. A third holds that Japanese forces captured them in the Marshall Islands.
What’s on the record
The flight battled overcast skies, faulty radio transmissions and a dwindling fuel supply, and lost contact with the US Coast Guard cutter Itasca, which was waiting at Howland. Navy and Coast Guard ships and planes searched about 250,000 square miles of ocean. The Navy concluded that the pair ran out of fuel, crashed and drowned. Navy planes flew over Gardner Island on July 9, 1937, and saw no sign of them or the plane, though they reported signs of recent habitation on an island uninhabited since 1892.
In 1940, 13 bones were found on Nikumaroro. The doctor who measured them at the time judged them male, and the bones were later lost. In a 2018 paper in the journal Forensic Anthropology, Richard Jantz of the University of Tennessee re-examined the measurements, called the earlier methods inadequate, and found Earhart more similar to the bones than 99 per cent of a large reference sample. TIGHAR also cites artifacts, possible shoe fragments and post-loss radio signals.
The capture theory got a burst of attention in 2017, when a History Channel special presented an undated National Archives photo of Jaluit Harbour said to show Earhart and Noonan. A Japanese blogger, Kota Yamano, then found the same photo in a book in Japan’s national library dated 1935, two years before they vanished.
What doesn’t add up
The physical searches keep coming up empty. In January 2024, Deep Sea Vision, a South Carolina company founded by Tony Romeo, released a sonar image of a plane-shaped object about 16,000 feet down, less than 100 miles from Howland. After a second expedition that year, higher-resolution images showed it was a rock formation. On Nikumaroro, a 2017 search with forensic dogs signalled possible human remains at a suspected campsite, but excavation found nothing.
The newest lead is the "Taraia Object," a shape in a Nikumaroro lagoon spotted in satellite images. Richard Pettigrew of the Archaeological Legacy Institute argues it is the Electra’s fuselage; the man who first flagged it, Michael Ashmore, now labels his own theory debunked, and TIGHAR’s Richard Gillespie thought it looked like a tree and its root ball. A Purdue-backed expedition planned for November 2025 was postponed for permits and cyclone season. As of early October 2026, National Geographic reported a 17-person team due to reach the island on October 13.
Still open
The 13 bones found on Nikumaroro in 1940 were later lost, so the 2018 analysis could work only from the old measurements; nobody can test the bones themselves. The Electra has never been found. The Taraia Object in the lagoon has so far been argued over from satellite images, and as of early October 2026 a 17-person team was due on the island on October 13. Wreckage, or the lost bones, would settle much of this.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. Each theory rests on real but partial evidence: fuel and radio logs, bones measured once and lost, scattered artifacts. The 2017 capture photo turned up in a 1935 book, the 2024 sonar “plane” proved to be rock, and no wreckage has been found so far.
Sources
- Document Amelia Earhart and the Nikumaroro Bones: A 1941 Analysis versus Modern Quantitative Techniques · Forensic Anthropology (University of Florida Press) · March 22, 2018
- Source What Happened to Amelia Earhart? · HISTORY
- News Japanese Blogger Points Out Timeline Flaw In Supposed Earhart Photo · NPR · July 10, 2017
- News He thought he’d found Amelia Earhart’s plane. It was a pile of rocks · Los Angeles Times · Nov. 7, 2024
- Document Expedition to search for Amelia Earhart’s plane postponed to 2026 · Purdue University · Oct. 26, 2025
- News A New Expedition to Find Amelia Earhart’s Plane · National Geographic · Oct. 1, 2026
More: the case files, every source behind every story.