Anastasia Romanov and Anna Anderson: the 1918 executions and what the DNA showed
Anna Anderson claimed for decades to be Grand Duchess Anastasia, the tsar’s daughter said to have escaped the 1918 executions; DNA from two graves and from her own tissue says no.
What’s claimed
The Anastasia legend holds that Grand Duchess Anastasia Nikolaevna of Russia, the youngest daughter of Tsar Nicholas II, survived when the Bolsheviks shot the Romanov family in 1918, and lived on in exile. The best-known claimant was Anna Anderson, who surfaced in Berlin in 1920 and spent the rest of her life saying she was the lost grand duchess. The legend fed on a real gap: for most of the 20th century, the remains of two of the Romanov children had never been found.
What’s on the record
In the early hours of July 17, 1918, the royal family and their staff were led to the cellar of the Ipatiev House in Yekaterinburg, where they were being held, and executed: Nicholas, Alexandra, their five children and four staff, according to a 2009 genetic study in the journal PLOS ONE. In the late 1970s a local geologist, Alexander Avdonin, located the mass grave, but the remains were officially recovered only in 1991, after the fall of the Soviet Union. The grave held nine skeletons. Alexei, the heir, and one of his sisters were missing, and Russian and American experts disagreed over whether the missing girl was Maria or Anastasia. DNA analysis published in Nature Genetics in 1994 identified the remains as the Romanov family. They were buried in a St. Petersburg cathedral in 1998, and the Russian Orthodox Church canonized the family in 2000.
In the summer of 2007, amateur archaeologists found bone fragments about 70 metres from the first grave, and an official excavation recovered 44 bone fragments and teeth. In April 2008 Eduard Rossel, governor of the Sverdlovsk region, announced that a US laboratory had confirmed they belonged to Alexei and a sister. “We have now found the entire family,” he said, The Associated Press reported. The peer-reviewed study followed in March 2009, reporting what its authors called virtually irrefutable evidence that the two were the missing children, although DNA alone could not say which sister.
Anna Anderson’s story was challenged early. She first came to attention after a suicide attempt in a Berlin canal in 1920, when she was taken to a mental hospital as an unknown woman. In 1927 a private investigation hired by Ernest Louis, Grand Duke of Hesse, identified her as Franziska Schanzkowska, a Polish factory worker. She moved to the United States in 1968, married Jack Manahan, and died in Charlottesville, Virginia, on February 12, 1984. Mitochondrial DNA was later tested from a 1979 sample of her intestinal tissue and from her hair. The results, published in Nature Genetics in January 1995, matched neither the Romanov remains nor living relatives of the family, but did match Karl Maucher, a relative of Franziska Schanzkowska.
What doesn’t add up
The DNA closes both doors. With the 2007 grave, every member of the family is accounted for, and the 2009 study concluded that no one survived the execution. Anderson’s DNA pointed to the Schanzkowska family, not the Romanovs, and most scientists and historians accept that she and Franziska Schanzkowska were the same person; the PLOS ONE authors describe her as a woman who convinced many people she was Anastasia until DNA testing exposed her. The one lingering note of doubt has come from the Russian Orthodox Church, which, as the AP reported in 2008, continued to question whether the remains were the family’s.
Still open
The science here is about as settled as DNA gets, but not every question is. DNA alone could not say whether the sister in the 2007 grave was Maria or Anastasia, and experts had already disagreed over the missing girl from the first grave. The Russian Orthodox Church, the AP reported in 2008, still questioned whether the remains were the family’s. How Anna Anderson convinced so many people for so long is a story the lab results don’t tell.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. DNA from two graves accounts for all seven members of the family, and the 2009 study concluded that no one survived the execution. Anna Anderson’s own tissue and hair matched a relative of Franziska Schanzkowska, not the Romanovs.
Sources
-
Document
Mystery Solved: The Identification of the Two Missing Romanov Children Using DNA Analysis
· PLOS ONE · March 10, 2009
“we have virtually irrefutable evidence that the two individuals recovered from the 2007 grave are the two missing children” - News DNA Confirms Remains Of Czar’s Children · CBS News (The Associated Press) · April 29, 2008
- Document Identification of the remains of the Romanov family by DNA analysis · Nature Genetics · Jan. 31, 1994
- Document Establishing the identity of Anna Anderson Manahan · Nature Genetics · Jan. 8, 1995
- Source Anna Anderson · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.