The Antarctic ‘ice wall’ and The Final Experiment: flat-earthers see the 24-hour sun
Flat-earth lore says Antarctica is an ice wall ringing the world; in December 2024 flat-earth YouTubers flew there, watched the sun stay up all day, and one said he had been wrong.
What’s claimed
In the flat-earth picture of the world, usually drawn on an azimuthal equidistant map with the North Pole at the centre, Antarctica is not a continent at the bottom of a globe but an ice wall running around the rim of a flat disc, holding in the oceans. The idea comes with a prediction: because the south is a ring rather than a pole, the sun should never stay up for 24 hours there in the southern summer, as it does in the Arctic. Many believers add that ordinary people are kept away so they cannot go and look.
What’s on the record
In December 2024 a Colorado pastor, Will Duffy, organized a trip he called The Final Experiment to settle one testable point: does the sun circle the sky for 24 hours in Antarctica in December? Gizmodo reported that both sides accepted the question as a fair test. Among those who went were the flat-earth YouTubers Jeran Campanella, known online as Jeranism, and Austin Whitsitt, along with people who accept that the Earth is round. From 14 to 17 December the group flew from Chile to Union Glacier Camp in West Antarctica, at about 79 degrees south, landed on an ice runway, and livestreamed the midnight sun. The trip cost about US$35,000 a person, and Duffy paid travel costs for four participants.
The sun did not set. Campanella, who has close to 200,000 followers, said on camera that he had honestly believed there was no 24-hour sun and now believed there was, adding: “Sometimes, you are wrong in life.” He said the most popular flat-earth map no longer made sense to him, though he stopped short of accepting a globe. Whitsitt admitted he had been wrong about the sun but said he remained open to a flat earth. Much of the wider flat-earth community rejected the result, saying the footage was faked or that the travellers were part of a conspiracy to promote the globe; Duffy said the community was “imploding.”
The ice itself is well mapped. Ice shelves, thick extensions of land ice that flow out over the cold coastal ocean, fringe the Antarctic coast, which has 15 major ice-shelf areas; they range from about 50 to 600 metres thick, and the largest are the size of France. The continent has also been sailed around: from December 2016 to March 2017 the Swiss Polar Institute’s Antarctic Circumnavigation Expedition took the Russian research ship Akademik Tryoshnikov all the way round, a voyage of 33,565 kilometres with scientists from 23 countries aboard.
What doesn’t add up
A 24-hour summer sun at both poles is what a spinning, tilted globe predicts, and it is what the flat-earth map rules out, which is why this test was chosen. The flat-earth believers who went agreed about what they saw. The ice wall, for its part, is a coastline, and ships have circled it. The remaining objection, that the sky and the footage were faked, cannot be settled by any experiment, which is why the trip changed some minds and not others.
Still open
The trip settled the one question it was built for: the sun stayed up for 24 hours at Union Glacier in December. What no experiment can settle is the claim that the sky and the footage were faked, which is why the trip changed some minds and not others. Jeran Campanella said the popular flat-earth map no longer made sense to him but stopped short of accepting a globe; where he lands next is his to say.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. Antarctica is a continent that ships have sailed around, and flat-earth believers who went there in December 2024 saw the 24-hour sun their own model says cannot exist. No ice wall at the edge of the world has turned up, from the ice, the air or the sea.
Sources
- News Flat Earther Expedition to Antartica Bolsters Case That Our Planet Is Round · Gizmodo · Dec. 18, 2024
-
News
Flat Earther visits Antarctica to see if the 24-hour sun is real and has an emotional reaction
· Upworthy · Dec. 17, 2024
“Sometimes, you are wrong in life.” - Source The Final Experiment (expedition) · Wikipedia
- Source Ice Shelves · National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC)
- Source Antarctic Circumnavigation Expedition (ACE) · Swiss Polar Institute
More: the case files, every source behind every story.