Apple’s ‘batterygate’: why old iPhones slowed down, and the planned-obsolescence charge
In 2017 Apple admitted iOS updates were slowing older iPhones with worn batteries. It apologized and paid in France, in a US class action and to 34 states. Was it planned obsolescence?
What’s claimed
“Batterygate” is the name given to the discovery, in December 2017, that Apple’s iOS software was slowing down older iPhones. To many owners it looked like proof of a long-held suspicion: that technology companies hobble last year’s devices so that customers will buy new ones, the practice known as planned obsolescence. Apple’s answer was that the slowdown existed to stop phones with worn batteries from shutting down without warning.
What’s on the record
The slowdown itself is not in dispute. In December 2017 Reddit users noticed that old iPhones got much faster after a battery replacement. John Poole, the Toronto-based founder of Primate Labs, then used results from his company’s Geekbench benchmark to show that iPhone 6, 6s and 7 models running iOS 10.2.1 or later were being held to lower speeds as their batteries aged. Apple’s support pages confirm that, on the iPhone 6, 6s, SE and 7 families, iOS manages peak performance when an ageing battery can no longer deliver enough power, to avoid unexpected shutdowns.
On December 28, 2017, Apple published a letter to customers. “We know that some of you feel Apple has let you down. We apologize,” it said. It cut the price of an out-of-warranty battery replacement by $50, to $29, for a year, and promised software showing battery health. A 2018 update let owners check their battery and turn the slowing off. The letter insisted Apple had never done anything “to intentionally shorten the life of any Apple product.”
Regulators and courts followed. In February 2020 France’s consumer and anti-fraud agency, the DGCCRF, found that owners had not been told that the 2017 updates iOS 10.2.1 and 11.2 could slow their phones, called this a misleading commercial practice by omission, and Apple agreed to pay a €25 million fine. In March 2020 Apple agreed to settle a US class action for at least $310 million and up to $500 million, about $25 per eligible phone, while denying wrongdoing. In November 2020 it agreed to pay $113 million to settle an investigation by 34 states and the District of Columbia, led by Arizona, Arkansas and Indiana, whose complaint accused Apple of giving misleading information about its updates.
What doesn’t add up
The record shows concealment, not a proven plan to force upgrades. Apple’s explanation fits how lithium-ion batteries behave: when they are old, cold or nearly flat, they struggle to supply peak power, and a phone may shut down to protect its components. The fix worked by slowing the phone, and a new battery restored its speed, which is not what a scheme to kill old phones would be expected to do. Poole’s own warning was about perception: owners would decide the phone was slow and replace it, rather than its battery. The US settlements contain no admission, and no court has found that Apple set out to drive sales.
Still open
No court has found that Apple set out to drive sales; the US settlements contain no admission, and Apple denies wrongdoing. Why owners weren’t told when iOS 10.2.1 began holding older phones back is a question the settlements answered with money rather than a full account. How many owners replaced a phone when a new battery would have done, Poole’s worry, the record doesn’t say.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. Apple did slow older iPhones without telling their owners, and it apologized and paid in France, in a US class action and to 34 states. The larger charge, that this was planned obsolescence meant to sell new phones, is unproven so far: no court has found it.
Sources
- Document iPhone battery and performance · Apple Support (Canada)
- News Geekbench Data Shows Old Batteries are Slowing Down iPhones · iPhone in Canada · Dec. 17, 2017
-
News
Apple offers a ($29) fix for customers upset over slowed-down iPhones
· NBC News · Dec. 27, 2017
“We know that some of you feel Apple has let you down. We apologize” - News Apple fined 25 million euros in France for slowing down older iPhones with iOS · iMore · Feb. 6, 2020
- News Apple to pay up to $500 million to settle lawsuit over slow iPhones · CNBC (Reuters) · March 1, 2020
- News Apple to pay $113 million to settle state investigation into iPhone ‘batterygate’ · The Philadelphia Inquirer (Washington Post) · Nov. 17, 2020
More: the case files, every source behind every story.