Atlantis: Plato’s sunken island, the search for its location and the case for allegory
Plato described a drowned island empire around 360 BCE. Searchers have placed it everywhere from Santorini to the Sahara, but his two dialogues remain the only source.
What’s claimed
Atlantis, the story goes, was a rich and powerful island beyond the Pillars of Heracles, the strait now called Gibraltar, that sank into the sea in a single day and night. Many people believe it was a real place, and proposed locations have included the Aegean island of Santorini, southern Spain, the Azores and, more recently, the Richat Structure in Mauritania.
What’s on the record
Every account traces back to Plato. In two dialogues written around 360 BCE, Timaeus and Critias, the character Critias tells a story he says he heard as a boy of about ten from his grandfather, who had it from the Athenian statesman Solon, who in turn heard it from priests at Sais in Egypt. In Benjamin Jowett’s translation, the island was “larger than Libya and Asia put together.” Its empire tried to conquer the Mediterranean world and was defeated by an idealized early Athens, about 9,000 years before Solon’s time. Then came earthquakes and floods, and the island disappeared beneath the sea.
Critias adds detail: Poseidon surrounded the hill where his mortal wife Cleito lived with alternating zones of sea and land, and ten kings ruled. The people were virtuous until “the divine portion began to fade away” and greed set in, and Zeus gathered the gods to punish them. The text then ends abruptly, just as Zeus begins to speak.
National Geographic notes that Plato’s writings are the only known record of Atlantis. Classicist James Romm of Bard College told the magazine that Plato used the story as a vehicle for themes that run through his work: divine versus human nature, ideal societies and the gradual corruption of human society.
The other side
The strongest real-world candidate is Santorini, ancient Thera. A huge eruption there about 3,600 years ago destroyed the Bronze Age town of Akrotiri and affected Minoan settlements on Crete, and since the early 20th century scholars have argued that Plato’s story may preserve a memory of it. Even the eruption’s date is debated; a 2018 study in Scientific Reports noted decades of argument and questioned a key olive-branch sample used to date it. Ocean explorer Robert Ballard told National Geographic he does not think Santorini was Atlantis because the eruption’s timing does not match Plato’s.
The Richat Structure, a ring formation about 50 kilometres across in the Sahara, attracts comparisons with Plato’s rings of land and water. NASA describes it as an eroded dome of layered sedimentary rock that was once mistaken for an impact crater. Archaeological mapping of the area has found no man-made structures or midden deposits. Older proposals include southern Spain, linked to the lost city of Tartessos since the 16th century, and the Azores, promoted by American congressman Ignatius Donnelly in his 1882 book Atlantis: The Antediluvian World.
Still open
Plato’s two dialogues are still the only known record of Atlantis, and Critias breaks off just as Zeus begins to speak, so even the source is unfinished. The date of the Thera eruption, the strongest real-world candidate, is itself still debated. No proposed site, from Santorini to the Richat Structure, has produced remains that match the account. A second, independent ancient source would change this file overnight.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. Real disasters such as the Thera eruption may have coloured Plato’s story, but his dialogues are still the only evidence Atlantis existed, scholars read them largely as a vehicle for his ideas, and no proposed site has produced remains that match his account.
Sources
-
Document
The Internet Classics Archive | Timaeus by Plato
· MIT Internet Classics Archive (trans. Benjamin Jowett)
“the island was larger than Libya and Asia put together” - Document The Internet Classics Archive | Critias by Plato · MIT Internet Classics Archive (trans. Benjamin Jowett)
- News Did these real-life events inspire the myth of Atlantis? · National Geographic · Jan. 20, 2017
- Document Richat Structure, Mauritania - NASA Science · NASA Earth Observatory · June 28, 2004
- Document Radiocarbon analysis of modern olive wood raises doubts concerning a crucial piece of evidence in dating the Santorini eruption · Scientific Reports (Nature) · Aug. 8, 2018
- Source Location hypotheses of Atlantis · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.