Secret technology

The Avro Arrow: Black Friday 1959, the destroyed jets and the Lake Ontario models

Diefenbaker cancelled the Avro Arrow on February 20, 1959, and every jet was cut up; claims of US pressure and a hidden surviving Arrow persist, while test models waited in Lake Ontario.

Under ReviewSerious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Published Oct. 22, 2026Last checked Oct. 11, 2026

What’s claimed

The Avro Arrow, formally the Avro Canada CF-105 Arrow, is Canada’s great what-if. Built at Malton, Ontario, in the 1950s, it was a supersonic interceptor designed to stop Soviet bombers coming over the Arctic. Its cancellation by Prime Minister John Diefenbaker’s government in February 1959, and the destruction of every aircraft, gave rise to lasting theories: that Washington pressured Ottawa to kill a rival to American industry, that the jets were destroyed to erase what Canada had achieved, and that one Arrow was secretly saved and is hidden somewhere to this day.

What’s on the record

The Royal Canadian Air Force commissioned the Arrow from A.V. Roe Canada in 1953–54. The first was unveiled on October 4, 1957, before 12,000 people, the same day the Soviet Union launched Sputnik. Test pilot Janusz Zurakowski first flew it on March 25, 1958; the five Mark 1 Arrows flew 66 times, and the design could reach nearly twice the speed of sound. The program cost $1.1 billion in all, according to The Canadian Encyclopedia.

On February 20, 1959, the government cancelled it, and more than 14,000 people lost their jobs overnight; the industry still calls it Black Friday. By July 1959 the aircraft had been cut apart with blowtorches, and blueprints, models and tooling destroyed, with scrap sold to a Hamilton junk dealer. The stated reason for the destruction was to protect classified material, a step also attributed to RCMP fears of a Soviet mole. Diefenbaker stood by his choice, telling the CBC years later, "It was right to end it."

Not everything vanished. The nose section of one Arrow, marked by a jagged blowtorch line, is on display at the Canada Aviation and Space Museum in Ottawa. In 2020 the CBC reported that a senior draftsman who had been ordered to destroy documents kept Arrow blueprints hidden at home for decades. And between 1954 and 1957, one-eighth-scale models were fired on rockets over Lake Ontario to test the design. In 2017 the Raise the Arrow team, led by mining executive John Burzynski, searched the lake with an autonomous submarine and that September found an arrow-shaped object off Prince Edward County. Divers raised it in August 2018 and delivered it to the museum; it proved to be a smaller, earlier delta-wing test model rather than one of the nine Arrow models.

What doesn’t add up

The US-pressure theory is weak. The Canadian Encyclopedia calls it "more myth than history", noting 1958 documents suggesting US Air Force officers offered to buy Arrows for the RCAF, an offer Canada refused. Historian Jack Granatstein has said American industry would have been unhappy if the US had bought Canadian jets, but that the claim the Americans killed the Arrow is not true. Sputnik and intercontinental missiles had also changed the threat the Arrow was built for.

Why the destruction was so complete is still argued. Explanations range from security to Granatstein’s suggestion that Diefenbaker acted out of spite toward Avro’s president, Crawford Gordon Jr. As for a surviving Arrow, rumour held that Air Marshal W. A. Curtis had hidden one; in a 1968 interview he neither confirmed nor denied it. No evidence has surfaced.

Still open

Why the destruction was so complete is still argued, from security and RCMP fears of a Soviet mole to Jack Granatstein’s suggestion of spite toward Avro’s president. Air Marshal W. A. Curtis, rumoured to have hidden an Arrow, neither confirmed nor denied it in a 1968 interview, and no evidence has surfaced either way. And the model raised from Lake Ontario in 2018 turned out to be an earlier test model, not one of the nine Arrow models.

Where it stands (for now)

Under Review. The cancellation and the destruction are documented, but why it happened, and why so thoroughly, is still debated by historians. The claim that the United States forced the decision has little support so far, and no evidence has surfaced that a complete Arrow survived.

Sources

  1. Source Avro Arrow · The Canadian Encyclopedia (Historica Canada) · Feb. 6, 2006
    “Notions that the US government pressured Diefenbaker to cancel the Arrow (in an effort to eliminate a competitor of the American industry) appear to be more myth than history.”
  2. News A new hunt for Avro Arrow models in the depths of Lake Ontario: This time the search will be different · CBC News · July 13, 2017
  3. News Sunken Avro Arrow model recovered from Lake Ontario · CBC News · Aug. 21, 2018
  4. News Avro Arrow blueprints on display after sitting in Sask. man’s home for decades · CBC News · Jan. 5, 2020
  5. Source Avro Canada CF-105 Arrow · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip