Government & intelligence

The Business Plot: Smedley Butler’s 1934 testimony of a coup against Roosevelt

In 1934 Gen. Smedley Butler told Congress he was recruited to lead veterans against Franklin Roosevelt. A House committee said the plot was discussed and planned; no one was ever called to account.

Under ReviewSerious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Published Oct. 13, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

The Business Plot, sometimes called the White House putsch, is the story that a group of wealthy American businessmen planned in 1933 and 1934 to raise an army of veterans, march on Washington and force President Franklin D. Roosevelt to hand real power to a man of their choosing. The man they wanted to lead it, the story goes, was Major General Smedley D. Butler, a retired Marine twice decorated by Congress, and he turned them in instead. Retellings often add that some of America’s best-known fortunes were behind it, and that the whole affair was hushed up.

What’s on the record

Butler’s testimony is on the record. In November 1934 he told a special House committee investigating Nazi and other propaganda, led by Representative John McCormack, that Gerald C. MacGuire, an American Legion official, had pressed him to lead a veterans’ organization. In the account of the testimony given by the Straight Dope’s Cecil Adams, the approach began in 1933 with a request that Butler speak at a Legion convention in favour of a return to the gold standard; MacGuire showed him a bank book and at one meeting eighteen thousand-dollar bills, and brought Robert Sterling Clark, a Singer sewing-machine heir, to see him. In 1934, Butler said, MacGuire proposed a force of 500,000 veterans to pressure Roosevelt into accepting a "secretary of general affairs" to run the government, a post Butler was to fill. Paul French, a reporter Butler confided in, met MacGuire and testified that MacGuire spoke of a fascist government backed by soldiers.

The committee’s report to the House, dated February 15, 1935, takes Butler seriously. It says that in its last weeks the committee received evidence of an attempt to set up a fascist organization in the United States, and that these attempts "were discussed, were planned, and might have been placed in execution" if the financial backers saw fit. MacGuire denied Butler’s account under oath. The committee said it verified all the pertinent statements Butler made except the direct suggestion to create the organization, and that this was corroborated in MacGuire’s letters to Clark from Europe, where he had been studying veterans’ movements of a fascist character.

What doesn’t add up

The committee confirmed the talk, not an operation. It found no link to any European fascist movement, and its account of the plot names only MacGuire and his principal, Clark. In a statement released on November 20, 1934, it said it had no evidence that would warrant calling figures such as John W. Davis, Hugh Johnson or Thomas W. Lamont, and that it would not act on hearsay. Clark himself was never called. Much of the press was dismissive; Time headlined its story "Plot Without Plotters." With that, as Adams put it, the matter died, and he concluded that even now it is unclear whether it was a scam, a pipe dream of a few rich men or a genuine conspiracy. In 2007 a BBC Radio 4 documentary revived the case, presenting it as the biggest peacetime threat to American democracy and tying it to famous business families, links the committee’s report does not spell out.

Still open

Robert Sterling Clark, the man the committee named as MacGuire’s principal, was never called to testify. Neither were John W. Davis, Hugh Johnson or Thomas W. Lamont; the committee said it had no evidence to warrant it and would not act on hearsay. So the question of who else knew, if anyone, was never put to anyone under oath. Whether it was a scam, a pipe dream or a genuine conspiracy is still unsettled ninety years on.

Where it stands (for now)

Under Review. A committee of Congress confirmed that a fascist veterans’ force was discussed and planned in some form. Whether it had powerful backers or was the scheme of a few men was never tested, because the people who could have answered were never asked.

Sources

  1. Document Investigation of Nazi and Other Propaganda, House Report No. 153, 74th Congress · US House of Representatives (GovInfo) · Feb. 14, 1935
  2. Source Smedley Butler & the “Business Plot,” Part II · Libertarianism.org (Cato Institute)
  3. News Oh, Smedley: Was there really a fascist plot to overthrow the United States government? · The Straight Dope · Nov. 17, 2005
  4. Source Document: The Whitehouse Coup · BBC Radio 4 · July 22, 2007

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip