Creatures & cryptids

Cadborosaurus: ‘Caddy’, British Columbia’s sea serpent, and the 1937 Naden Harbour photos

Since 1933, people on BC’s coast have reported Caddy, a horse-headed sea serpent. Two scientists named it in 1995 from 1937 whaling-station photos; critics see a shark, a sturgeon or a fetal whale.

UnconfirmedThin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Published Oct. 7, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

Cadborosaurus willsi, better known as Caddy, is said to be a long, serpentine animal living off the Pacific coast of North America, and especially around Vancouver Island and the Saanich Peninsula. Witnesses describe a horse- or camel-like head on a long neck, humps or coils behind it, and flippers. Believers say it is a real but unclassified animal, perhaps even a surviving marine reptile, and some count roughly 300 sightings over two centuries.

What’s on the record

The modern legend dates from October 1933, when two prominent Victoria residents, the lawyer W.H. Langley and the yachtsman R.C. Ross, reported a huge serpent in the waters off Vancouver Island. Another witness then described a similar sighting a year earlier, and Archie Wills of the Victoria Daily Times named the creature Cadborosaurus, after Cadboro Bay at the island’s southeastern tip. The name was soon shortened to Caddy.

The best-known evidence comes from 1937. In mid-July that year, workers at the Naden Harbour whaling station on Haida Gwaii, then called the Queen Charlotte Islands, found a carcass about 3.8 metres long in the stomach of a sperm whale caught off Langara Island. The station supervisor, F.S. Huband, had it photographed, and G.V. Boorman took two sharper pictures; one ran on the front page of the Victoria Daily Colonist on October 31, 1937. Francis Kermode, director of the provincial museum, identified the remains as a fetal baleen whale. Where the carcass went after that is unknown.

In 1995 two senior scientists, Edward Bousfield, retired chief zoologist of the Canadian Museum of Nature, and Paul LeBlond, an oceanographer at the University of British Columbia, formally named the animal Cadborosaurus willsi in the journal Amphipacifica, honouring Wills. With no body to examine, they made one of Boorman’s photographs the type specimen. They argued that no known creature matched the more than 200 sightings they had gathered.

What doesn’t add up

Other zoologists have not been persuaded. The zoologist and writer Darren Naish notes that two of the journal’s three editors opposed publishing it as a formal species description, and argues that photographs make a poor type specimen for a disputed animal. Suggested identities for the Naden Harbour carcass include Kermode’s fetal whale; a basking shark, since their remains have been found in sperm whale stomachs before; and, Naish suggests, a decomposed white sturgeon. Naish has also argued that a 1930s “Caddy carcass” at Camp Fircom was a montage of beach debris, a sign that fakes were circulating at the time. In 2011 he, Michael Woodley and Cameron McCormick published an analysis concluding that the “baby Caddy” William Hagelund said he caught in 1968 was most likely a bay pipefish. Naish’s wider point is that the sightings describe such different animals that they probably do not share a single cause, though he allows that this does not rule out an unknown species.

Still open

The Naden Harbour carcass, the only physical evidence, went somewhere after 1937 and no one knows where. With no body, the 1995 naming rests on a photograph, and the photographs fit a fetal whale, a basking shark or a decomposed sturgeon. Naish allows that the mixed sightings don’t rule out an unknown species. A body, or those 1937 remains if they ever surfaced, would settle more than another sighting.

Where it stands (for now)

Unconfirmed. The sightings, the 1937 photographs and the 1995 naming are all real, but the only physical evidence has been lost and zoologists have offered more ordinary explanations for the photographs. So far, that falls well short of a new animal.

Sources

  1. Source The Case of the Cadborosaurus Carcass: a Review (Darren Naish) · Tetrapod Zoology · Nov. 16, 2020
  2. Source A baby sea-serpent no more: reinterpreting Hagelund’s juvenile Cadborosaurus · Scientific American (Tetrapod Zoology blog) · Sept. 25, 2011
  3. Document Bousfield & LeBlond (1995): An account of Cadborosaurus willsi, new genus, new species · IMIS (Flanders Marine Institute)
  4. News Cadborosaurus: North America’s Legendary Sea Serpent · Discovery UK
  5. Source Cadborosaurus · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip