Canada’s tainted-blood scandal: HIV, hepatitis C, the Krever inquiry and the aftermath
In the 1980s thousands of Canadians got HIV or hepatitis C from blood products; the Krever inquiry found it preventable, the Red Cross pleaded guilty in 2005, and compensation came in pieces.
What’s claimed
Canada’s tainted-blood scandal, also called the tainted blood tragedy, is the infection of thousands of Canadians with HIV and hepatitis C through blood and blood products in the 1980s and early 1990s. Victims and their families have long said it was not bad luck but the result of decisions: delays in testing, risky products kept in use, warnings ignored to save money, and institutions that then tried to dodge the blame. Some have called it a cover-up.
What’s on the record
The scale is not in dispute, though counts vary. The Globe and Mail puts it at about 2,400 people with hemophilia and transfusion recipients infected with HIV and some 25,000 with hepatitis C, calling it the worst public health disaster in Canadian history. Bleeding Disorders Canada counts more than 1,100 HIV infections among transfused Canadians, about 700 of them people with hemophilia and other bleeding disorders, of whom 700 to 800 have died, and up to 20,000 hepatitis C infections before testing was introduced in 1990.
In 1993 Justice Horace Krever was appointed to lead the Commission of Inquiry on the Blood System in Canada. Over almost four years it heard 247 witnesses, half of them victims, and the final report, issued in November 1997, ran to 1,138 pages. Krever was sued after he said he would name individuals, not just institutions, who had failed. Media coverage before and during the inquiry described delays in testing, the distribution of blood products known to be tainted and the destruction of evidence. The inquiry found the infections could have been prevented by better screening and called efforts to deal with the problem "ineffective and half-hearted."
The Canadian Red Cross, which ran the blood system, restructured under bankruptcy protection and handed its blood operations to the new Canadian Blood Services in 1998. In 2002, after a five-year investigation, the RCMP laid criminal charges. On May 30, 2005, the Red Cross pleaded guilty to distributing a contaminated drug under the Food and Drugs Act, paid the maximum $5,000 fine plus $1.5 million for research and scholarships, and apologized in court, saying it was "deeply sorry for the injury and death caused" by the products it distributed. The criminal-negligence charges against it were withdrawn. In 2006 Dr. Roger Perrault, the former director of its blood program, went on trial in Toronto on four counts of criminal negligence causing bodily harm and one of common nuisance; the trial ended in acquittal.
Compensation came in pieces. In 1998 governments agreed to a settlement worth about $1.118 billion for people infected with hepatitis C through the blood system between January 1, 1986, and July 1, 1990. Those infected before and after that window were left out until July 25, 2006, when Prime Minister Stephen Harper announced a fund of nearly $1 billion for them.
What doesn’t add up
Was it a cover-up? The inquiry documented failures and delays, and the Red Cross accepted responsibility through its plea. But the criminal trial of its former blood chief ended without a conviction, so no court has found that individuals knowingly put patients at risk. For many families, the long fight over who qualified for compensation became a second injustice.
Still open
The Krever inquiry found the infections could have been prevented, and coverage at the time described the destruction of evidence. What the criminal courts never established is that any individual knowingly put patients at risk: the trial of the former head of the Red Cross blood program ended in acquittal in 2006, and the criminal-negligence charges against the Red Cross were withdrawn. Even the counts of people infected still vary from source to source. None of that changes what happened to them.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The infections, the inquiry’s finding that they could have been prevented, the Red Cross’s guilty plea and apology, and the compensation programs are all on the record. A deliberate criminal cover-up by individuals was tested in court and not proven.
Sources
- News Justice Horace Krever, known for his unwavering principles, headed two high-profile public inquires · The Globe and Mail · May 6, 2023
- Source Commemoration of the Tainted Blood Tragedy · Bleeding Disorders Canada · Oct. 16, 2017
- News Red Cross pleads guilty, offers apology in blood scandal · The Globe and Mail · May 30, 2005
- News Tainted blood trial set to start · CBC News · Feb. 5, 2006
- Document Prime Minister Harper announces agreement to compensate pre-1986/post-1990 hepatitis C victims · Prime Minister’s Office, Government of Canada · July 24, 2006
- Source Canadian Red Cross · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.