Carroll A. Deering: the Outer Banks ghost ship found with no crew in 1921
The schooner Carroll A. Deering ran aground off Cape Hatteras in January 1921 with sails set and her crew of 11 gone. Pirates, mutiny and Red agents were all blamed; nothing was proved.
What’s claimed
The Carroll A. Deering, often called the ghost ship of the Outer Banks or the ghost ship of Diamond Shoals, was a five-masted schooner found aground off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, on January 31, 1921, with her crew gone. Theories have filled the empty decks ever since: pirates, rum-runners, a mutiny, Communist agents seizing ships for Soviet Russia and, inevitably, the Bermuda Triangle.
What’s on the record
The Deering was built in 1919 by the G. G. Deering Company of Bath, Maine. In 1920 she carried coal to Rio de Janeiro under Captain Willis B. Wormell, a 66-year-old retired master who had replaced her ailing captain, and on the way home she stopped at Barbados for supplies. During the voyage the first mate, Charles B. McLellan, complained that the captain interfered with his work and was reported to have threatened him.
On January 29, 1921, the schooner passed the Cape Lookout lightship. Its keeper later said the crew were milling about on deck and that a man who did not seem to be an officer called out that the ship had lost her anchors. The next evening a passing steamer, the Lake Elon, saw her steering what the National Park Service calls a peculiar course. At 6:30 a.m. on January 31, C. P. Brady of the Cape Hatteras Coast Guard station spotted her aground on Diamond Shoals. Heavy seas kept boats away until February 4.
Boarders found the sails set and the lifeboats gone, along with personal belongings, key navigation equipment, papers and the anchors. Food appeared to have been laid out for a meal. A cat was still aboard; the Graveyard of the Atlantic Museum has said it had six toes. The 11 crewmen were never seen again. The hull broke up and was dynamited that March.
In May 1921 the captain’s wife and others persuaded the Commerce Secretary, Herbert Hoover, to investigate. His aide Lawrence Richey gathered material from five government agencies, including the young Bureau of Investigation, forerunner of the FBI, whose agent visited Dare County that July. In April a Buxton man, Christopher Columbus Gray, had produced a message in a bottle claiming the Deering was captured by an “oil burning boat”. Handwriting experts first linked it to the ship’s engineer, but federal experts showed Gray had written it himself. The inquiry closed in late 1922 without an official finding.
What doesn’t add up
Each theory has a hole. Pirates and Red agents fitted the anxieties of 1921, and the steamer Hewitt, which was near Diamond Shoals at the time and was itself among the vessels that vanished, kept the hijacking idea alive, but no trace of a seizure ever surfaced. The rum-running idea is generally judged doubtful. Mutiny fits the mate’s threats and the missing boats, yet no survivor or body was ever found to confirm it. Captain Ballance of the Cape Hatteras station believed the crew took everything of value and ran her onto the shoals on purpose. The Bermuda Triangle link comes from later popular books about the Triangle.
Still open
The 11 crewmen were never seen again, and no survivor or body ever turned up to confirm mutiny or anything else. Hoover’s inquiry gathered material from five agencies and closed in late 1922 without an official finding. Who took the lifeboats, the navigation equipment and the papers, and why food was laid out for a meal, is still unanswered. The hull was dynamited that March, so the ship itself can never be examined again.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. The abandonment is documented in detail, and a federal inquiry ran for a year and a half without a finding. Every explanation so far, from pirates to mutiny to Soviet agents, rests on guesswork, and the one piece of “evidence” for piracy, the bottle message, federal experts showed to be a forgery.
Sources
- Document The Ghost Ship of the Outer Banks · National Park Service (Cape Hatteras National Seashore)
-
Document
Carroll Deering ghost ship
· North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources · Jan. 30, 2016
“The cause remains a mystery.” - Source The ghost ship and the President · A Blast From the Past (Mike Dash) · April 7, 2010
- News ‘Vanished like ghosts’: Mystery surrounds Outer Banks shipwreck 102 years later · Stars and Stripes (The Charlotte Observer) · Jan. 30, 2023
- Source Carroll A. Deering · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.