Cecil Rhodes’s secret society: Milner’s Kindergarten, the Round Table and Quigley
Historian Carroll Quigley wrote that Cecil Rhodes founded a secret society in 1891 that grew into Milner’s Kindergarten and the Round Table; the network was real, its power is the question.
What’s claimed
Cecil Rhodes, the empire-builder behind the Rhodes Scholarships at Oxford, is said to have founded a secret society to preserve and spread British power around the world. The claim, often called the Rhodes secret society or the Milner Group, comes mainly from the Georgetown University historian Carroll Quigley. In Tragedy and Hope (1966), and in The Anglo-American Establishment, a manuscript whose story ends in 1949 but which was not published until 1981, he traced a network running from Rhodes in 1891 through Milner’s Kindergarten and the Round Table groups to Chatham House, The Times and All Souls College, Oxford. Writers on the American right later took his work as proof of a hidden Anglo-American elite steering world events.
What’s on the record
Quigley opens with a meeting in London in February 1891 between Rhodes, the journalist W. T. Stead and Reginald Brett, later Lord Esher. He writes that they drew up a plan with an inner circle, the Society of the Elect, and an outer circle, the Association of Helpers, and that Alfred Milner was added soon after. He also points out that Rhodes had left his fortune to form such a society in five wills before the seventh, which created the scholarships. After Rhodes died in 1902, Milner, in Quigley’s account, became the chief controller of his estate and the group’s leader. Quigley wrote in Tragedy and Hope that he had studied this network for twenty years and had been allowed, for two years in the early 1960s, to examine its papers and secret records.
The Round Table itself was never hidden. The young administrators Milner gathered in South Africa, known as his Kindergarten, returned to London after the Union of South Africa in 1910 and, with Sir Abe Bailey’s money, founded the journal The Round Table, edited by Philip Kerr, later Lord Lothian. It first appeared in 1910 as a quarterly review of the politics of the British Empire, and many of its founders backed imperial federation: one parliament for all the Empire’s self-governing parts. The journal still publishes. The Rhodes Trust, for its part, now says its scholarships rest on wealth "extracted and commercialised by Cecil Rhodes."
What doesn’t add up
Quigley’s group was real in the sense that these men knew one another, met, funded one another’s projects and held powerful posts. But Quigley conceded that membership was informal, that he could not always tell who belonged, and that the society probably had no oaths or formal initiation. Its central goal, federating the Empire, failed; by his own account the Round Table groups gave it up between 1910 and 1916 and turned toward a looser Commonwealth. He also objected to how his work was used. He told The Washington Post in 1975 that "any conspiracy theory of history is nonsense," and he disputed claims drawn from his book, such as that Milner had helped finance the Bolsheviks, which appeared in John Birch Society-backed literature.
Still open
Quigley said he examined the network’s papers and secret records for two years in the early 1960s, but by his own account membership was informal and he could not always tell who belonged. So the full membership, and how far the group steered policy rather than simply knowing the right people, rests largely on one historian’s reading of papers few others have described.
Where it stands (for now)
Redacted. A Rhodes-inspired circle of imperialists, from Milner’s Kindergarten to the Round Table, is well documented, and Quigley’s access to its papers gives his account weight. That it secretly ran British or world affairs goes beyond his own evidence, and Quigley said so himself.
Sources
-
Document
The Anglo-American Establishment (Books in Focus, 1981)
· Carroll Quigley (carrollquigley.net) · Dec. 31, 1980
“this Group is, as I shall show, one of the most important historical facts of the twentieth century” - Document Tragedy and Hope: A History of the World in Our Time (Macmillan, 1966) · Carroll Quigley (carrollquigley.net) · Dec. 31, 1965
-
News
The Professor Who Knew Too Much (Washington Post Sunday Magazine, March 23, 1975)
· The Washington Post, reprinted at carrollquigley.net · March 22, 1975
“I generally think that any conspiracy theory of history is nonsense” - Source History of The Round Table · The Round Table: The Commonwealth Journal of International Affairs
- Source Legacy, Equity & Inclusion · Rhodes Trust
More: the case files, every source behind every story.