‘Chemtrails’: contrails, a survey of 77 experts and the real geoengineering debate
Some see secret spraying in the trails behind jets; atmospheric experts surveyed in 2016 found no evidence of it, while real geoengineering remains a matter of open proposals, a cancelled experiment and new state bans.
What’s claimed
The white trails some jets leave across the sky are, according to the "chemtrail" theory, not ice crystals but chemicals or biological agents sprayed in secret at high altitude. Depending on who is telling it, the aim is to change the weather, dim the sun, harm people’s health or control the population. Believers point to trails that linger and spread into haze, and to lab tests of water and soil that show metals.
What’s on the record
Contrails are ordinary physics. The US Environmental Protection Agency explains that they form when water vapour in jet exhaust condenses and freezes in cold, humid air. In dry air they evaporate quickly; when a plane crosses a layer of supersaturated air, they can persist and spread for minutes or for more than a day. The EPA’s page says the federal government is not aware of any contrail ever being formed on purpose over the United States for geoengineering or weather modification.
In August 2016, scientists at the Carnegie Institution for Science and the University of California, Irvine, with a co-author from the website Metabunk.org, published a survey of experts in the peer-reviewed journal Environmental Research Letters. Of 77 scientists, 49 specialists in contrails and 28 geochemists who study how dust and pollution settle out of the air, 76 said they had not encountered evidence of a secret, large-scale spraying program. The one exception reported high levels of atmospheric barium in a remote area with low soil barium. Large majorities said the lab results circulated as proof had more plausible explanations, such as ordinary dust and sediment or poor sampling. The authors noted that in a 2011 international survey, nearly 17 per cent of respondents said a secret spraying program was true or partly true.
Geoengineering itself is real, and argued over in public. In 2021, the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine recommended a research program on solar geoengineering, the idea of reflecting some sunlight to cool the planet, under strict governance that includes a public registry and permits for outdoor experiments. Harvard’s SCoPEx project, announced in 2017, planned to release a few kilograms of calcium carbonate or sulphuric acid from a high-altitude balloon and measure the plume. A 2021 test flight from Sweden was called off on its advisory committee’s recommendation, amid opposition from the Saami Council and environmental groups, and on March 18, 2024, its lead scientist said he was no longer pursuing the experiment.
Governments have weighed in too. On July 10, 2025, the EPA published new pages on contrails and geoengineering; Administrator Lee Zeldin said Americans "deserve straight answers." On June 20, 2025, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed a law, in force from July 1, banning the release of substances intended to affect the weather, temperature or intensity of sunlight, with felony penalties.
What doesn’t add up
What the public record shows about geoengineering is proposals, a planned small experiment that never flew, and arguments over whether to allow such work, not a fleet of airliners spraying in secret. Lingering trails are what contrails do in humid air at cruising altitude, and the specialists best placed to spot unusual chemistry in the air and soil say they have not seen it.
Still open
The open questions are about the real thing, argued in public: whether solar geoengineering should be studied outdoors and under what rules, which the National Academies took up in 2021 and Harvard’s SCoPEx never got to test. Florida has banned it outright. On the secret-spraying claim, nothing is pending: 76 of 77 specialists surveyed had seen no evidence of it, and the EPA says the federal government knows of no contrail ever made on purpose for geoengineering.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. Geoengineering is a real subject of research, regulation and protest, all of it in the open. The claim that routine aircraft trails are a covert spraying program has no supporting evidence: 76 of the 77 experts surveyed in 2016 had found none, and lingering trails are what contrails do in cold, humid air.
Sources
-
Document
Quantifying expert consensus against the existence of a secret, large-scale atmospheric spraying program
· Environmental Research Letters (IOP Publishing) · Aug. 9, 2016
“Results show that 76 of the 77 scientists (98.7%) that took part in this study said they had not encountered evidence of a SLAP” -
Document
Information on Contrails from Aircraft
· U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
“The federal government is not aware of there ever being a contrail intentionally formed over the United States for the purpose of geoengineering or weather modification.” -
Document
EPA Releases New Online Resources Giving Americans Total Transparency on the Issues of Geoengineering and Contrails
· U.S. Environmental Protection Agency · July 9, 2025
“Americans have legitimate questions about contrails and geoengineering, and they deserve straight answers.” - Document Reflecting Sunlight: Recommendations for Solar Geoengineering Research and Research Governance · National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
- News Harvard has halted its long-planned atmospheric geoengineering experiment · MIT Technology Review · March 17, 2024
- News Gov. DeSantis signs bill to prohibit activities ‘intended to affect’ weather, temperature, sunlight intensity · News4JAX · June 19, 2025
More: the case files, every source behind every story.