Creatures & cryptids

The chupacabra: Puerto Rico’s 1995 ‘goat-sucker’ and the mangy coyotes of Texas

The chupacabra, or goat-sucker, burst out of Puerto Rico in 1995 with spines and big eyes. Texas later produced hairless ‘chupacabras’ that turned out to be coyotes and dogs with mange.

TinfoilFor fun. Nothing solid has surfaced, and the official answer is no. The hat stays on the hook, just in case.

Published Oct. 2, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

The chupacabra, or chupacabras (Spanish for "goat-sucker"), is said to be a creature that kills livestock and drains their blood. It first made headlines in Puerto Rico in 1995, when goats, sheep and other farm animals were reported dead with puncture wounds, their carcasses said to be bloodless. The early descriptions were of an upright, reptile-like creature three to four feet tall, with large eyes and spines down its back. Later reports, mostly from Mexico and the southern United States, describe something quite different: a hairless, dog-like animal on four legs. Suspects named at the time ranged from Satanic cults to aliens.

What’s on the record

The name is credited to the Puerto Rican comedian Silverio Pérez. The first reports came from the towns of Orocovis and Morovis. The description that defined the creature came from Madelyne Tolentino, who said she saw it in the second week of August 1995 outside her home in Canóvanas, at the eastern edge of the San Juan area.

The investigator Benjamin Radford spent five years on the case, reported in the Skeptical Inquirer in 2011 and in his book Tracking the Chupacabra. He interviewed Tolentino and found her account riddled with contradictions. He also found that the science-fiction film Species, released in Puerto Rico shortly before her sighting, features an alien creature, Sil, that matches her description in more than a dozen details, and that she had seen the film. Radford found too that very few of the "bloodless" animals were ever properly examined; a forensic pathologist told him blood loss cannot be confirmed without a necropsy, and ordinary decay and predators can mimic it.

The four-legged chupacabras are the ones people have actually caught. In 2004 a rancher near San Antonio, Texas, killed the "Elmendorf Beast"; DNA testing at the University of California, Davis, showed a coyote with sarcoptic mange. In 2010 an animal shot in Hood County, Texas, was identified by Texas A&M scientists as a coyote and dog hybrid with mange and parasites. That year the University of Michigan biologist Barry O’Connor concluded that the American reports were coyotes infected with the mite Sarcoptes scabiei, which leaves them nearly hairless, thick-skinned and weak. In 2014 Radford judged a "baby chupacabra" captured in Ratcliff, Texas, most likely a raccoon with mange.

What doesn’t add up

Two different animals share one name. The upright, spiny creature has never produced a body. The four-legged kind has, and every specimen examined by biologists has been a coyote, a dog or a hybrid, its strange look explained by mange. Radford also points out how suddenly it arrived: the chupacabra burst into being in 1995, whereas Bigfoot and the Loch Ness monster are said to have been around for ages.

Still open

The upright, spiny chupacabra of 1995 has never produced a body, so there is nothing to test, and very few of the “bloodless” animals were ever given the necropsy needed to confirm blood loss. Every four-legged specimen biologists have examined so far has been a familiar animal with mange. A carcass of the 1995 kind, examined properly, is what would reopen this file.

Where it stands (for now)

Tinfoil. Radford traced the original creature to one eyewitness whose description matches a film monster she had seen, and every chupacabra carcass examined has been a coyote, a dog, a hybrid or, in one case, most likely a raccoon, all with mange. Nothing else has surfaced so far.

Sources

  1. News Slaying the Vampire: Solving the Chupacabra Mystery · Skeptical Inquirer (Vol. 35 No. 3, May/June 2011)
  2. Source On the Trail of the Chupacabra · Skeptoid · Jan. 17, 2022
  3. News Texas ‘Chupacabra’ Turns Out to Be Imposter · Live Science · April 3, 2014
  4. Source Chupacabra · Encyclopaedia Britannica
  5. Source Chupacabra · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip