The CIA’s ‘Family Jewels’: the 1973 list of abuses the agency kept secret for 34 years
In 1973 the CIA compiled nearly 700 pages on its own possibly illegal acts, from Castro plots to mail opening and domestic spying; the file stayed secret until June 2007.
What’s claimed
The “Family Jewels”, also called the CIA Family Jewels report, is the name given to a file the Central Intelligence Agency put together in 1973 listing activities its own staff thought might be illegal or improper. For decades it was the stuff of rumour: a secret inventory of assassination plots, domestic spying and mind-control research that the agency was said to be hiding. When it was finally released in June 2007, people asked the obvious questions: was it all true, and what was still blacked out?
What’s on the record
The file began with a directive. On May 9, 1973, Director of Central Intelligence James Schlesinger, after learning that former CIA officers E. Howard Hunt and James McCord, caught up in Watergate, had received agency help, ordered employees to report activities "which might be construed to be outside the legislative charter of this Agency," the National Security Archive records. William Colby drafted the directive and received the replies; he later called them the skeletons in the CIA’s closet.
The answers ran to roughly 700 pages. A December 1974 briefing for the Justice Department boiled them down to 18 items with possible legal problems. They included plots against Fidel Castro, Patrice Lumumba and Rafael Trujillo; the opening of mail to and from the Soviet Union from 1953 to 1973, through an operation at New York’s main airport, and of Chinese mail from 1969 to 1972; Operation CHAOS, which kept files on more than 9,900 Americans linked to the antiwar movement; wiretaps on columnists Robert Allen and Paul Scott in 1963; surveillance of journalist Jack Anderson; the long confinement of Soviet defector Yuri Nosenko; and funding of behaviour-modification research on unwitting US citizens. The Castro section describes how the CIA used a former FBI agent, Robert Maheu, to approach mobster Johnny Roselli, who brought in Sam Giancana and Santo Trafficante Jr. Poison pills were supplied; the attempt failed.
The public learned the outline before it saw the file. On December 22, 1974, Seymour Hersh reported on the front page of The New York Times that the CIA had run a large domestic operation against antiwar and other dissident groups in the Nixon years. Ten days later Colby briefed President Gerald Ford, who set up a commission chaired by Vice-President Nelson Rockefeller. In January 1975 the Senate voted 82–4 to set up its own select committee, chaired by Frank Church, which issued its final report on April 29, 1976; congressional investigators had access to the reports.
The file itself stayed classified. The National Security Archive had filed a freedom-of-information request about 15 years before CIA Director Michael Hayden announced the release in June 2007, calling the file "a glimpse of a very different time and a very different Agency." The 702-page collection went up on the CIA’s website at the end of that month; sources differ on whether it was June 25 or 26.
The other side
The release did not settle everything. Parts are still redacted and some pages were withheld entirely. The Archive noted that one memo first released in 1977 came out in 2007 with more blacked out, not less, and journalist David Corn argued that a key item remained classified. From the opposite direction, CIA lawyer Daniel Pines argued in a 2009 law journal article that most of the activities were legal when they were carried out, except for non-consensual human experimentation. The file is a list of what officers chose to report in 1973, not a complete history of the agency.
Still open
Parts of the file are still redacted and some pages were withheld entirely. One memo first released in 1977 came back in 2007 with more blacked out, not less, and David Corn argued that a key item remained classified. The file is a list of what officers chose to report in 1973, not a complete history, so what they left out is not in it. Fuller release of the withheld pages would show how much is still being kept back.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The Family Jewels exist, were compiled on the director’s order in 1973 and were released by the CIA itself in 2007. Their contents, from the Castro plots to mail opening and CHAOS, are on the record; what remains redacted or withheld, and what officers never wrote down, is still out of sight.
Sources
- Document The CIA’s Family Jewels (Electronic Briefing Book No. 222) · National Security Archive, George Washington University · June 20, 2007
- Document The Family Jewels · CIA Freedom of Information Act Electronic Reading Room
- News CIA Releases ‘Family Jewels’ on Agency Web Site · American Historical Association (Perspectives on History) · June 26, 2007
- Source The CIA’s catalog of covert conundrums · US National Archives (Pieces of History) · Dec. 22, 2010
- Source Senate Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities (Church Committee) · United States Senate
- Source Family Jewels (Central Intelligence Agency) · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.