The Clipper chip: the 1993 US plan to hold a spare key to encrypted phone calls
In 1993 the White House unveiled the Clipper chip, a phone scrambler whose keys the government would keep in escrow. A Bell Labs researcher found a flaw, and by 1996 the plan was dead.
What’s claimed
In 1993, the story goes, Washington asked Americans to adopt a government-designed scrambler for their phones, with one catch: the government would keep copies of the keys. Critics called it a back door built into the hardware, and said the real aim was to keep strong encryption out of private hands.
What’s on the record
This one was announced from the White House. A statement from the press secretary on 16 April 1993 described the Clipper chip, a microcircuit developed by government engineers to encrypt voice calls, programmed and sold to device makers by Mykotronx of Torrance, California. Each chip would carry unique keys split between two separate escrow databases, to be released only to officials with legal authority for a wiretap. The White House called it "a voluntary program to improve the security and privacy of telephone communications."
On 9 February 1994 the Commerce Department published the Escrowed Encryption Standard, FIPS 185. NIST notes that both its cipher and its Law Enforcement Access Field, or LEAF, were classified, so the standard referred to them without spelling them out. That month Attorney General Janet Reno named NIST and the Treasury Department as the two key holders. The cipher, called Skipjack, was designed by the NSA, used 80-bit keys and was available only inside tamper-resistant chips; among the first products was AT&T’s Model 3600 Telephone Security Device.
In August 1994 Matt Blaze, then at AT&T Bell Laboratories, published a paper showing that the LEAF was checked using a field of only 16 bits. With about 65,000 tries, a rogue program could produce a bogus LEAF the chips would accept, and so use the government’s cipher without giving the government a usable key. The Register wrote in 2020 that the finding "sealed its fate." The Electronic Frontier Foundation says the proposal was dead by 1996. NIST formally withdrew FIPS 185 on 19 October 2015.
The other side
The government’s case was that strong encryption would let criminals and hostile spies escape lawful wiretaps, and that Clipper offered ordinary callers better protection than they had, with a door that opened only under court supervision. The programme was voluntary and did not ban other encryption. Its failure was partly technical and partly practical: chips in hardware were costly and awkward next to encryption software, which spread quickly in the 1990s. The idea outlived the chip. The EFF points to later proposals for guaranteed government access, including a 2015 push by the FBI for new back doors that a so-called golden key would unlock.
Still open
The standard pointed at a cipher and an access field that were classified, so the public was asked to trust a design it could not read; it took an outside researcher to find the 16-bit flaw. How widely the chips were used, and whether the two escrow databases ever released a key, we could not confirm. And the idea itself never closed: in 2015 the FBI pushed for new back doors that a so-called golden key would unlock.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The White House announced the plan, the standard was published, and the government said openly that it would hold the keys. The back door was never hidden; it was the stated design, formally withdrawn in 2015 while the argument over government access carries on.
Sources
- Document White House Clipper Statement (4/16/93) · The White House, Office of the Press Secretary (via EPIC) · April 15, 1993
- Source The Clipper Chip · Electronic Privacy Information Center
- Document FIPS 185: Escrowed Encryption Standard (EES) · National Institute of Standards and Technology · Feb. 8, 1994
- Document Protocol Failure in the Escrowed Encryption Standard · Matt Blaze, AT&T Bell Laboratories · Aug. 19, 1994
- News On the Clipper Chip’s Birthday, Looking Back on Decades of Key Escrow Failures · Electronic Frontier Foundation · April 15, 2015
- News Remember the Clipper chip? NSA’s botched backdoor-for-Feds from 1993 still influences today’s encryption debates · The Register · Jan. 26, 2020
More: the case files, every source behind every story.