Government & intelligence

CSEC’s airport Wi-Fi test: the 2014 Snowden document on following travellers’ devices

A 2012 Canadian spy agency slide deck, leaked by Snowden, showed CSEC using two weeks of airport Wi-Fi identifiers to follow devices elsewhere. Its watchdog said that was not spying.

DeclassifiedThey admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Published Oct. 24, 2026Last checked Oct. 25, 2026

What’s claimed

On 30 January 2014 CBC News, working with Glenn Greenwald and Ryan Gallagher, reported that a top-secret document from Edward Snowden showed Canada’s signals intelligence agency, then called Communications Security Establishment Canada (CSEC, now CSE), had used information from the free Wi-Fi at a major Canadian airport to track the wireless devices of thousands of ordinary passengers for days after they left the terminal. CSEC is barred from targeting Canadians or anyone in Canada, so the report suggested the agency had turned its tools on the people it is meant to leave alone.

What’s on the record

The document is real and public. Titled IP Profiling Analytics & Mission Impacts, it is a 27-page CSEC presentation dated 10 May 2012 from the agency’s Network Analysis Centre, marked top secret; the ACLU hosts a copy. Its stated objectives were to build new analytics giving richer context about a network address and to develop a way of chaining contacts across gaps in the data.

As read by the security writer Bruce Schneier and the Electrospaces blog, the test took about two weeks of user IDs seen on an airport’s network addresses, then followed those IDs backward and forward in time to the other places they appeared, sorting networks into types such as airports, hotels and offices. The data came from what the slides call a Canadian special source, its name blacked out. A second test aimed to pick out one person seen in a given area at known times, and a tool cut the processing time from more than two hours to seconds.

CSEC told reporters it had collected metadata, not the content of calls or emails, that no Canadian or foreign travellers were tracked, and that a 2011 review by its commissioner had found its metadata work lawful. Ron Deibert, director of the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto, told CBC he could not see how it would be anything other than unlawful under Canadian law, the Charter or CSEC’s mandate. On 14 February 2014 the CSE commissioner, Jean-Pierre Plouffe, ruled that the agency had not been spying on Canadians and was using the data to understand global communications networks.

What doesn’t add up

The headline and the slides do not match neatly. Schneier wrote that the airport-tracking reports were not really accurate and that the presentation describes a proof of concept for mapping networks. Electrospaces argued it showed no interest in the identities of Canadians at the airport, while agreeing that following the IDs was a form of tracking. Critics answered that gathering identifiers from devices in Canada and following them across other hotspots is tracking, whatever the purpose. The airport has never been named, and neither has the special source.

Still open

The airport has never been named, and neither has the Canadian special source that supplied the data; its name is blacked out on the slides. Whether the proof of concept, and the tool that cut hours of processing to seconds, was ever put to regular use after May 2012, the slides don’t say. Whether following travellers’ identifiers across hotspots counts as tracking Canadians, and was lawful, is still argued.

Where it stands (for now)

Declassified. CSEC’s own 2012 presentation shows it used about two weeks of airport Wi-Fi identifiers to follow devices to other locations as a test. Whether that counts as tracking Canadians, and whether it was lawful, is still argued; the agency’s watchdog ruled in 2014 that it was not spying.

Sources

  1. Document CSEC Airport WiFi Tracking (CSEC presentation “IP Profiling Analytics & Mission Impacts,” 10 May 2012) · ACLU (Snowden document archive) · May 9, 2012
  2. News Snowden documents reveal CSEC used airport Wi-fi to track Canadians (updated) · Citizen Lab, University of Toronto · Jan. 30, 2014
  3. News Alleged Wi-Fi tracking is out of Canadians’ control: privacy experts · Global News · Jan. 30, 2014
  4. Source CSEC Surveillance Analysis of IP and User Data · Schneier on Security · Feb. 2, 2014
  5. Source Did CSEC really track Canadian airport travellers? · Electrospaces.net · Feb. 3, 2014
  6. News CSEC watchdog says collecting metadata isn’t spying; judge for yourself · Georgia Straight · Feb. 16, 2014

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip