Ancient Egypt & the pyramids

The curse of Tutankhamun: Lord Carnarvon’s 1923 death and the legend the press built

Lord Carnarvon died in Cairo in April 1923, months after Tutankhamun’s tomb was found; a 2002 BMJ study found those present at its opening lived about as long as anyone else.

TinfoilFor fun. Nothing solid has surfaced, and the official answer is no. The hat stays on the hook, just in case.

Published Oct. 9, 2026Last checked Oct. 11, 2026

What’s claimed

The curse of Tutankhamun, also called the curse of the pharaohs or the mummy’s curse, holds that anyone who disturbed the boy king’s tomb in Egypt’s Valley of the Kings was marked for death. The tomb was found in November 1922 by Howard Carter, whose sponsor was George Herbert, the 5th Earl of Carnarvon. Within months Carnarvon was dead, and the legend has attached itself to nearly every later death connected with the dig. A newer version swaps magic for biology: spores of moulds such as Aspergillus, sealed in the tomb for thousands of years, are said to have done the killing.

What’s on the record

Carnarvon was bitten by a mosquito in the Valley of the Kings in March 1923, according to the Tutankhamun archive of Oxford’s Griffith Institute. The bite became infected; in Cairo he developed erysipelas and blood poisoning, then pneumonia, and after several brief recoveries he died there on 5 April 1923. He was buried on Beacon Hill, on his Highclere estate in England.

The curse came from the newspapers. The University of Manchester Egyptologist Joyce Tyldesley has explained that an exclusive deal gave The Times sole access to the tomb, leaving other reporters with nothing to see and turning them toward non-expert commentators. On 24 March 1923, with Carnarvon ill in Cairo, the novelist Marie Corelli wrote in The Express that breaking into a sealed royal tomb carried risks, and wondered whether a mosquito bite had infected him. When he died days later she was hailed as a clairvoyant. Her line that death comes on wings to anyone who enters a pharaoh’s tomb was repeated as if it were an ancient inscription; none has been found. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was the first to suggest the tomb might hold poisonous spores. Later deaths were folded in: an Egyptian prince who had visited the tomb and was shot by his wife in 1923, the Louvre’s Georges Bénédite in 1926, the Metropolitan Museum’s Albert Lythgoe in 1934.

In 2002 Mark Nelson of Monash University tested the idea in the BMJ. He identified 44 Westerners whom Carter recorded as being in Egypt during the openings of 1923 to 1926, 25 of whom were potentially exposed to the curse. The exposed group died at an average age of 70, against 75 for the others, and the difference in survival was not statistically significant. Nelson concluded there was no evidence for a mummy’s curse. Carter himself died in London on 2 March 1939.

What doesn’t add up

The mould theory has fared little better. Experts interviewed by National Geographic in 2005 agreed that tombs can hold moulds, bacteria and noxious gases, but noted that Carnarvon was chronically ill before he ever entered, and that he died months after his first exposure, when an infection from the tomb would likely have shown itself sooner. An epidemiologist told the magazine he knew of no archaeologist or tourist harmed by tomb moulds or bacteria. In June 2025, University of Pennsylvania engineers reported in Nature Chemical Biology that Aspergillus flavus, the fungus most often blamed, produces compounds that killed leukaemia cells in the laboratory. Headlines called it the curse fungus, but the study tested a possible medicine, not a cause of death; Penn’s own release describes the tomb connection only as a theory doctors put forward decades later.

Still open

No ancient inscription carrying the famous curse has ever been found; the line about death on wings came from Marie Corelli’s pen. The 2002 BMJ study covered a small group, 44 Westerners Carter recorded, and found no significant difference in survival. The tomb-mould theory has not been tied to any death at the dig, and the 2025 Aspergillus study tested a possible medicine, not a cause of death. A tomb toxin shown to have harmed someone there would reopen this file.

Where it stands (for now)

Tinfoil. Carnarvon’s death from an infected mosquito bite is well documented, and the curse began as a newspaper story. The only systematic study so far found that the people present at the openings lived about as long as anyone else, and no inscription carrying the curse has surfaced.

Sources

  1. Document Lord Carnarvon · Griffith Institute, University of Oxford (Tutankhamun Spatial Archive)
  2. Document Howard Carter · Griffith Institute, University of Oxford (Tutankhamun Spatial Archive)
  3. Document The mummy’s curse: historical cohort study (Mark R. Nelson) · BMJ, via PubMed · Dec. 20, 2002
  4. News 90th anniversary of the curse of Tutankhamen – how a modern myth was born · The University of Manchester · April 3, 2013
  5. News Egypt’s ‘King Tut Curse’ Caused by Tomb Toxins? · National Geographic · May 5, 2005
  6. News Penn Engineers Turn Toxic Fungus into Anti-Cancer Compound · Penn Engineering, University of Pennsylvania · June 22, 2025

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip