Ghosts & the paranormal

Feeling the Future: Daryl Bem’s 2011 precognition study and the replication crisis

In 2011 a top psychology journal published Daryl Bem’s nine experiments suggesting people can sense the future. Careful copies found nothing, and psychology had to face its own methods.

TinfoilFor fun. Nothing solid has surfaced, and the official answer is no. The hat stays on the hook, just in case.

Published Oct. 19, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

“Feeling the Future” is the title of a 2011 paper by Daryl Bem, a well-known social psychologist at Cornell University, published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, one of his field’s leading journals. In nine experiments with more than 1,000 participants, Bem reported evidence for precognition, a form of what is often called ESP or psi: students’ responses seemed to be influenced by events that had not yet happened. Supporters still cite it as laboratory evidence that the future can reach back into the present.

What’s on the record

Bem’s idea was simple: take standard psychology experiments and run them backwards in time. In one, Cornell students guessed which of two on-screen curtains hid a picture, with the answer chosen at random only after they guessed. With erotic pictures they were right 53 percent of the time, Slate reported. In another, students recalled more of the words from a list if they practised those words after the memory test was over. Eight of the nine experiments gave statistically significant results, with a small average effect, The Psychologist reported. Bem shared his materials and urged others to try.

They did. Stuart Ritchie, Richard Wiseman and Christopher French ran three pre-registered copies of the word-recall experiment, the one with the largest effect, at the University of Edinburgh, Goldsmiths in London and the University of Hertfordshire, using Bem’s own software. Their combined 150 participants showed no effect, and the results appeared in PLOS ONE in March 2012 under the title “Failing the Future”. Other failed attempts were posted even before Bem’s paper was in print.

What doesn’t add up

The bigger story was what the paper revealed about psychology itself. The methodologist E. J. Wagenmakers, whose rebuttal ran alongside it, argued that Bem had blurred the line between exploring data and testing a prediction, and that ordinary methods could find almost anything. Within months, Joseph Simmons, Leif Nelson and Uri Simonsohn showed with simulations how common, harmless-looking choices in analysis could push the rate of false positives far above the 5 percent researchers assume. Slate’s Daniel Engber argued in 2017 that the publication of Bem’s paper may be the single moment that set off psychology’s replication crisis, in which even textbook findings came into doubt.

Bem has not conceded. A meta-analysis he led, published in 2016, covered 90 experiments from 33 laboratories in 14 countries and reported a small overall effect. Critics such as Wagenmakers reply that the positive effect disappears if you count only the attempts mainstream researchers made after Bem’s paper.

Still open

Bem has not conceded, and his 2016 meta-analysis of 90 experiments from 33 laboratories reported a small overall effect; critics such as Wagenmakers reply that it disappears when you count only the attempts mainstream researchers made after his paper. A large, pre-registered replication that found the effect would reopen this file; so far the careful copies have found nothing.

Where it stands (for now)

Tinfoil. Careful pre-registered copies found nothing, and critics argue the original results are better explained by flexible analysis than by time running backwards. What is documented is that the paper was real, passed peer review in a leading journal and pushed psychology to re-examine how it tests its own findings.

Sources

  1. Document Failing the Future: Three Unsuccessful Attempts to Replicate Bem’s ‘Retroactive Facilitation of Recall’ Effect · PLOS ONE · March 13, 2012
    “All three replication attempts failed to produce significant effects (combined n = 150; combined p = .83, one-tailed)”
  2. News Daryl Bem Proved ESP Is Real. Which Means Science Is Broken. · Slate · June 6, 2017
  3. News News, January 2011 · The Psychologist (British Psychological Society)
  4. Document Feeling the future: A meta-analysis of 90 experiments on the anomalous anticipation of random future events · F1000Research · Jan. 28, 2016

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip