De Beers and ‘A Diamond Is Forever’: the cartel, the stockpile and the engagement ring
From 1938 De Beers paid N.W. Ayer to make a diamond a must for every engagement while the company held supply in check. A guilty plea, a $295-million settlement and a change of strategy followed.
What’s claimed
The claim is that the diamond engagement ring is less a tradition than a product launch. De Beers, the South African mining company that for most of the 20th century controlled the world’s rough diamonds, is said to have taught the public that love requires a diamond, kept the stones scarce by holding them back, and discouraged anyone from reselling so prices would never be tested. The journalist Edward Jay Epstein made the case most famously in The Atlantic in February 1982, in an article titled “Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond?”
What’s on the record
Much of the story comes from the files of De Beers’s own advertising agency. Epstein reported that in September 1938 Harry Oppenheimer, son of De Beers’s chairman, travelled to New York to meet Gerold Lauck, president of N.W. Ayer, after diamond prices had fallen worldwide. Ayer’s research found that diamond sales in the United States had fallen by half, by weight, since 1919. Its campaign lent diamonds to film stars, placed stories and photos in newspapers and magazines, ran painted magazine advertisements that sold no brand, only the stone, and sent lecturers into high schools. By 1941 Ayer reported that US diamond sales had risen 55 percent since 1938. In its 1947 strategy it described the work as “a problem in mass psychology.” In the late 1940s an Ayer copywriter, Frances Gerety, came up with “A Diamond Is Forever”; Advertising Age later named it the slogan of the 20th century.
Supply ran through De Beers’s selling arm in London, the Central Selling Organization. Epstein argued that the cartel existed to control production and keep up what he called the illusion of scarcity, and he described a deal under which De Beers marketed Soviet diamonds after mines opened in Siberia.
The United States tested the arrangement in court. In 1994 a federal grand jury in Columbus, Ohio, indicted De Beers for conspiring to fix prices of industrial diamonds. On July 13, 2004, De Beers Centenary AG pleaded guilty and agreed to pay a $10 million criminal fine. A class action filed the same year accused De Beers of fixing prices and monopolizing the diamond market. It ended in a $295 million settlement that included an injunction limiting De Beers’s ability to restrict world supply; the full Third Circuit upheld it in December 2011, and the US Supreme Court declined to hear objectors in May 2012.
The other side
De Beers changed course on its own account. In April 2000 its chairman, Nicky Oppenheimer, wrote that the stockpile, then valued at about US$4 billion, had become “the burden of swollen inventories,” and the company moved from managing supply to promoting demand. By 2007 its managing director, Gareth Penny, said it held only about two months’ stock, and it produced about 40 percent of the world’s rough diamonds. The 2004 plea covered industrial diamonds, not gems, and the class action ended in a settlement, not a verdict. Epstein’s article is an argument as well as a report.
Still open
Much of what we know comes from Ayer’s own files as Epstein reported them, and from De Beers’s own statements. The 2004 guilty plea covered industrial diamonds, not gems, and the gem-market case ended in a settlement, not a verdict, so no court has ruled on the gem cartel itself. How far the old supply controls still shape prices, after the change of strategy in 2000, the public record doesn’t settle.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The advertising campaign, the stockpile and the 2004 guilty plea are on the record, much of it in the words of De Beers and its agency. The company itself acknowledged in 2000 that its old way of controlling the market had stopped working.
Sources
- News Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond? (Edward Jay Epstein) · The Atlantic · Jan. 31, 1982
- Document De Beers Centenary AG Pleads Guilty to Price-Fixing Indictment · US Department of Justice · July 12, 2004
- News De Beers to review its diamond inventories · Mail & Guardian · April 17, 2000
- Source How to Succeed in the Multi-faceted Diamond Business: The Gospel According to De Beers · Knowledge at Wharton · April 17, 2007
- Source Diamond Antitrust Case Is Concluded · Berman Tabacco (plaintiffs’ counsel)
- News The Ad-Woman Who Made Diamonds ‘Forever’ · WWNO (NPR, Here & Now) · July 25, 2013
More: the case files, every source behind every story.