The Enfield poltergeist: the 1977 north London haunting behind The Conjuring 2
From 1977, the Hodgson family of Enfield reported flying toys, moving furniture and a gruff voice. Investigators said some of it was real; caught tricks and admitted fakes say otherwise.
What’s claimed
The Enfield poltergeist, also called the Enfield haunting, is Britain’s most famous modern ghost case. From late August 1977, a single mother, Peggy Hodgson, and her four children reported knocking, moving furniture, flying toys and worse at their council house, 284 Green Street, Enfield, in north London. The disturbances centred on two of the girls, Janet and Margaret, then about 11 and 13. Investigators from the Society for Psychical Research (SPR) came to believe much of it was genuine, and the case inspired the 2016 horror film The Conjuring 2.
What’s on the record
The trouble began on the night of 31 August 1977, according to the SPR’s Psi Encyclopedia. Neighbours called the police, and a policewoman, WPC Heeps, made a statement that she saw a chair wobble and slide three to four feet across the living-room floor and could find no cause. Reporters from the Daily Mirror followed; its photographer, Graham Morris, said a flying piece of Lego hit him on the forehead. The paper contacted the SPR, which sent Maurice Grosse, an inventor who had recently joined; the writer Guy Lyon Playfair joined him on 12 September. Over more than a year they made about 180 visits and recorded more than 180 hours of tape.
In December 1977 a gruff old man’s voice began coming from Janet. It called itself Bill and said it had died in a chair downstairs; the son of a former occupant later confirmed that his father had died in the house. Grosse taped Janet’s mouth, and the voice went on, more subdued. An SPR committee set up in May 1978 found good evidence of paranormal events from credible witnesses, while reserving judgement on incidents no one had seen clearly.
What doesn’t add up
Trickery was part of the record from the start. Playfair himself wrote that the children were sometimes “motivated to add to the activity with some tricks of their own,” and that nothing happened when Janet knew a camera was on. A video camera in a nearby room caught Janet bending spoons and trying to bend an iron bar, and Grosse saw her bang a broom handle on the ceiling. The girls admitted some pranks to reporters, then retracted after talking with the investigators. Janet later said they had faked things once or twice to see whether the investigators would catch them, and put the faked share at about two percent.
Fellow SPR investigators Anita Gregory and John Beloff concluded the girls enjoyed play-acting. Melvin Harris argued that the famous photographs of Janet apparently levitating, taken by a remote camera, showed her bouncing off the bed, and called them gymnastics. The ventriloquist Ray Alan thought the girls produced the voice themselves. Writing in Skeptical Inquirer in 2012, Joe Nickell concluded the case was best explained as children’s pranks. The Conjuring 2 added a demon and put Ed and Lorraine Warren at the centre; the Warrens did visit, but there was no demon in the real case. The Hodgsons have long maintained that not everything was faked.
Still open
The policewoman’s statement from the first night, a chair sliding three to four feet with no cause she could find, is still one of the hardest pieces to set aside. The SPR committee of 1978 reserved judgement on incidents no one saw clearly. How much was faked is still argued: Janet put it at about two percent, while Nickell and others think pranks explain the whole case.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. Police, neighbours and reporters described events they could not explain, and serious investigators have argued both ways for decades. Caught tricks, admitted fakes and a voice that preferred closed doors mean no part of the case has yet been shown to be paranormal, and the Hodgsons maintain not everything was faked.
Sources
-
Source
Enfield Poltergeist
· Psi Encyclopedia (Society for Psychical Research)
“Janet later admitted that they cheated ‘about two percent of the time’.” - Document Enfield Poltergeist (Investigative Files, Joe Nickell) · Skeptical Inquirer, vol. 36, no. 4
- News The Conjuring 2’s Enfield Case: A True Story That Still Haunts Us Today · Den of Geek · Feb. 25, 2021
- Source Enfield poltergeist · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.