Erebus, 1979: Flight 901, a changed flight path and Justice Mahon’s ‘litany of lies’
An Air New Zealand sightseeing DC-10 flew into Mount Erebus, killing all 257 aboard; a royal commission blamed a route change the crew was never told about and accused the airline of lying, a finding the Privy Council later ruled unfair.
What’s claimed
For years after the crash, families of the dead said the official explanation, that the pilots took the jet too low into poor visibility, hid the airline’s own mistakes. The claim was that Air New Zealand, then wholly owned by the state, covered up a navigation error and let the dead captain carry the blame.
What’s on the record
On November 28, 1979, a DC-10 registered ZK-NZP, flying Air New Zealand Flight TE 901, a sightseeing flight from Auckland over Antarctica due to land at Christchurch, crashed on the slopes of Mount Erebus on Ross Island. All 257 people aboard were killed. It remains New Zealand’s worst peacetime disaster.
The government’s chief inspector of air accidents, Ron Chippindale, gave his report’s probable cause as the captain’s decision to keep flying low toward an area of poor surface and horizon definition while the crew was unsure of its position. The minister of transport released that report on June 12, 1980.
A royal commission under Justice Peter Mahon reported in April 1981. It found that the single dominant cause was a mistake by airline officials who programmed the aircraft to fly directly at Mount Erebus and did not tell the crew. The crew believed they were heading down McMurdo Sound, over ice and water. A whiteout, an illusion in polar light, hid the rising slope ahead. Mahon found that neither Captain Collins nor First Officer Cassin nor the flight engineers made any error that contributed. He also said some airline evidence was so plainly false it must have come from a pre-determined plan of deception, writing that he had to listen to "an orchestrated litany of lies."
The other side
Air New Zealand went to court. New Zealand’s Court of Appeal set aside Mahon’s order that the airline pay more than half of the inquiry’s costs, but by a majority left his conspiracy finding in place, and Mahon appealed. On October 20, 1983, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London ruled that Mahon’s finding of a conspiracy was a breach of natural justice and was not supported by the evidence. The Law Lords accepted that several executive pilots had given false evidence, but did not accept that it was a concerted plan. Mahon’s findings on the cause of the crash were not challenged and still stand.
Mahon also noted that the chief inspector had found breaches of duty by the airline and civil aviation officials, though not as causes, and that his report gave the false impression that pilot error alone was to blame. In 2009 Air New Zealand apologized for how it treated families after the crash. On November 28, 2019, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern apologized for the actions of the state-owned airline, and its chair, Therese Walsh, said the airline had "failed in its duty of care to its passengers and staff."
Still open
The Privy Council accepted that several executive pilots gave false evidence but ruled the finding of a planned deception unsupported, so why that false evidence was given has never been answered in a finding that stands. Mahon also noted that the chief inspector had found breaches of duty by the airline and civil aviation officials, yet did not count any of them as causes; how they fit into the crash was left to the royal commission alone.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The changed flight path, the crew who were never told, the royal commission’s findings on the cause and the official apologies are all on the record. The one part not upheld is the word “orchestrated”: the Privy Council accepted that false evidence was given but ruled the finding of a planned deception unfair and unsupported.
Sources
-
Document
Report of the Royal Commission to Inquire into the Crash on Mount Erebus, Antarctica, of a DC10 Aircraft Operated by Air New Zealand Limited
· Royal Commission report (NZ Governor-General’s website) · April 15, 1981
“I am forced reluctantly to say that I had to listen to an orchestrated litany of lies.” - Document Judgments of the Court of Appeal of New Zealand on Proceedings to Review Aspects of the Report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the Mount Erebus Aircraft Disaster · Project Gutenberg
- News ‘The time has come’: Ardern apologises for New Zealand’s worst air disaster · The Guardian · Nov. 27, 2019
- News Mount Erebus disaster: The plane crash that changed New Zealand · BBC News · Nov. 26, 2019
- Source Air New Zealand Flight 901 · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.