Ettore Majorana: the physicist who vanished in 1938 and the Venezuela finding
In March 1938 the Italian physicist Ettore Majorana vanished after a night steamer from Palermo to Naples; in 2015 Rome prosecutors said he had been living in Venezuela in the 1950s.
What’s claimed
Ettore Majorana, a theoretical physicist from Catania whom Enrico Fermi reportedly ranked with Galileo and Newton, disappeared in March 1938, aged 31, after boarding a night steamer from Palermo back to Naples. The Majorana case, known in Italy as la scomparsa di Majorana, has been explained as suicide at sea, a retreat into a monastery, flight to Argentina, or a move to Germany to work on Nazi weapons. The best-known version, from the Sicilian writer Leonardo Sciascia, casts it as a moral choice: a man who saw where atomic physics was heading and refused to be part of it.
What’s on the record
Majorana, born in August 1906, had been appointed full professor of theoretical physics at the University of Naples in autumn 1937, at 31. In March 1938 he travelled to Palermo, where investigators later found he had spent two days. On March 25 he wrote to Antonio Carrelli, the director of the Naples physics institute, of a decision that had become unavoidable, and left a letter for his family asking them not to wear black. He then sent Carrelli a telegram and a second letter saying he had changed his mind; the sea, he wrote, had rejected him, and he would return. On the evening of March 26 he boarded the Tirrenia steamer for Naples. No certain trace of him followed. Before leaving he had collected several months of salary he had never claimed, and he is believed to have taken his passport.
A viewer of the television program Chi l’ha visto? said in 2008 that he had met Majorana in Valencia, Venezuela, in 1955, and in 2011 Rome prosecutors reopened the case. On February 4, 2015 they announced that Majorana had been alive between 1955 and 1959, living there voluntarily under the surname Bini. Forensic police compared a 1955 photograph of "Bini" beside an Italian emigrant, Francesco Fasani, and found the features matched those of Majorana’s father. Fasani said he found a 1920 postcard in Bini’s car, written by Majorana’s uncle, also named Ettore. Finding no crime, prosecutors asked for the case to be closed. They called it most likely that Majorana, frightened by his discoveries about the atom, had chosen to disappear.
What doesn’t add up
Sciascia’s 1975 book, La scomparsa di Majorana, proposed that he hid in the Carthusian monastery of Serra San Bruno in Calabria, and questioned whether he had boarded the ship at all. The monastery idea has never been proven. The 2015 finding rests on a photograph, a postcard and one witness’s memories, and it covers only four years: investigators could establish nothing after 1959, blaming slow answers from Venezuelan authorities to requests for records. In 2010 the physicist Giorgio Dragoni said Majorana was the man standing beside Adolf Eichmann in a 1950 photograph on a ship bound for Buenos Aires, and Il Post reported that investigators judged this highly probable. Even so, no concrete evidence has ever tied Majorana to Nazi weapons work.
Still open
The 2015 finding covers only 1955 to 1959; investigators could establish nothing after that, blaming slow answers from Venezuelan authorities to their requests for records. Why he left, whether he really boarded the steamer, and where he ended up are still open. The 1950 photograph beside Eichmann has never been tied to any weapons work, and Sciascia’s monastery theory has never been proven.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. The disappearance, the letters and the Rome prosecutors’ 2015 conclusion are on the record, and that conclusion argues against suicide or murder. But it was reached decades later on a photograph, a postcard and one witness, and why he left, and where he ended up, remain open.
Sources
-
News
1938 disappearance physicist Majorana alive 1955-59
· ANSA · Feb. 3, 2015
“resurfaced in 1955-59 when he was living voluntarily in the Venezuelan town of Valencia” - News La scomparsa di Ettore Majorana · Il Post · March 25, 2013
- Source The Disappearance of Ettore Majorana · Electra (Fundação EDP)
- News Il caso Majorana: intervista al nipote di Leonardo Sciascia · Meer · Nov. 4, 2024
- Document Catalog of the scientific manuscripts left by Ettore Majorana (with a Recollection of E. Majorana, sixty years after his disappearance) · arXiv (Erasmo Recami) · Oct. 12, 1998
More: the case files, every source behind every story.