Secret technology

Carnivore: the FBI’s email-sniffing box inside internet providers, 2000–2005

In 2000 the FBI admitted it plugged a system called Carnivore into internet providers to collect suspects’ email. A Justice Department review found real gaps, and by 2005 it was retired.

DeclassifiedThey admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Published Oct. 22, 2026Last checked Oct. 25, 2026

What’s claimed

In the summer of 2000, Americans learned that the FBI had a computer it could install inside an internet provider’s network to capture email. Its name, Carnivore, did not help. Critics said the box could see everything flowing through a provider, that only the FBI knew what it kept, and that it amounted to tapping every customer at once in order to catch one suspect.

What’s on the record

Carnivore was real, and the FBI defended it in public. The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) says its existence was widely reported on 11 July 2000; EPIC filed a freedom-of-information request the next day and sued when the Justice Department missed the deadline. At a House Judiciary subcommittee hearing on 24 July 2000, officials described it as a tool for minimizing what was collected. Computerworld reported it had been installed at internet providers 25 times, 16 of them that year, and that it came to light after the provider EarthLink complained. On 6 September 2000 Donald Kerr, an FBI assistant director, told the Senate Judiciary Committee it had been used about 25 times in two years, that it filtered traffic so only packets covered by a court order were kept, and that it was "a passive system" isolated from the provider’s network.

The Justice Department commissioned an outside review from IIT Research Institute, dated 8 December 2000. It found that under a full wiretap order Carnivore gave investigators no more than the order allowed, but that under the lower pen-register authority it could collect more than a court permitted, such as the length of messages. It said the system was designed for fine-tuned searches but was "capable of broad sweeps": set up wrongly, it could record any traffic it watched. It found no adequate audit trail to hold individual operators accountable. It also found Carnivore had nowhere near enough power to spy on almost everyone with an email account, since it saw only the network segment it was attached to and had to reject most packets.

The FBI renamed the system DCS1000 in 2001. Its reports to Congress for 2002 and 2003, released to EPIC in January 2005, show it used commercial software for court-ordered internet surveillance instead. An FBI spokesman confirmed the switch, and the documents indicate the bureau by then received wiretap data directly from providers.

What doesn’t add up

The popular fear, that Carnivore read all of a provider’s mail, was not borne out by the review. The real problems were narrower: over-collection under pen-register orders, no reliable record of who configured what, and software built without a formal development process. EPIC’s releases also include an April 2000 FBI memo describing Carnivore causing trouble in an anti-terrorism investigation involving Osama bin Laden. And retiring the box did not end the practice; it moved the collection into the providers’ own systems.

Still open

Because the outside review found no adequate audit trail, there is no reliable record of who configured Carnivore each time, or of exactly what it kept in its roughly 25 installations. The review said it could over-collect under pen-register orders; how often it actually did is not on the record. And once collection moved into the providers’ own systems, there was no FBI box left for an outside reviewer to examine.

Where it stands (for now)

Declassified. The FBI acknowledged Carnivore, testified about it, commissioned a review and later retired it. The official review found no sign it could read everyone’s email, but found it could over-collect when misconfigured and lacked safeguards to show who did what.

Sources

  1. Document Independent Technical Review of the Carnivore System: Final Report · IIT Research Institute for the US Department of Justice · Dec. 7, 2000
  2. Document The “Carnivore” Controversy: Electronic Surveillance and Privacy in the Digital Age (S. Hrg. 106-1057) · US Senate Committee on the Judiciary (GovInfo) · Sept. 5, 2000
  3. News House panel grills FBI over Carnivore · Computerworld (IDG News Service) · July 24, 2000
  4. Source EPIC Carnivore Page · Electronic Privacy Information Center
  5. News FBI puts Carnivore out to pasture · Washington Technology · Jan. 18, 2005

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip