Government & intelligence

The ‘Five Eyes loophole’: do allies spy on each other’s citizens to get round the law?

The claim: Five Eyes allies spy on each other’s citizens so no agency has to spy on its own. A former Canadian spy says so, a court in Ottawa found something close, and Britain denies it.

Under ReviewSerious people argue both sides; the evidence cuts both ways, and the file stays open.

Published Oct. 14, 2026Last checked Oct. 25, 2026

What’s claimed

Most democracies limit how their spy agencies can watch their own people. The claim is that the Five Eyes partners, the United States, Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, get round those limits by doing it for one another: the British watch Americans, the Americans watch Britons, Canada takes requests, and the results are swapped, so that every agency can truthfully say it never spied on its own citizens.

What’s on the record

The partnership is documented. GCHQ says the UKUSA Agreement was signed on 5 March 1946; Canada joined in 1949 and Australia and New Zealand in 1956, and the files were released in 2010.

The loophole claim has a named source. In February 2000 Mike Frost, a former officer of Canada’s Communications Security Establishment, told CBS’s 60 Minutes that Margaret Thatcher had two cabinet ministers she believed "weren’t on side," and that his Canadian boss had their communications intercepted from London, leaving British officials able to deny it. Frost said members could ask a partner to spy for them to get round restrictions at home. That is his account; no government has confirmed it.

In November 2013 the Guardian and Channel 4 reported a 2005 draft NSA directive from the Snowden archive. As Crikey summarized it, the document said the arrangement with Britain had come to include an understanding that the two governments "will not target each other’s citizens/persons," while reserving each side’s right to act alone when it judged that in its interest, and it considered cases where a partner refused a request.

In Canada, a court found something close to the loophole. In a decision known as X (Re), Justice Mosley of the Federal Court ruled that CSIS had breached its duty of candour by not telling the court, when it sought warrants in 2009, that CSEC would get Five Eyes partners to intercept the communications of Canadians abroad. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld him on 31 July 2014, holding that intrusive methods, even carried out through a foreign agency, need a warrant under Canadian law.

The other side

Where the claim has been tested in public, officials have denied it, and some reviews have backed them. In July 2013 Britain’s Intelligence and Security Committee examined allegations that GCHQ had used the NSA’s PRISM programme to get round UK law. After reviewing GCHQ’s lists of targets, selectors and warrants, it found the allegation had no foundation, noting that a minister-signed interception warrant was already in place in each case. In March 2017, after a Fox News commentator claimed Barack Obama had used GCHQ to spy on Donald Trump and the White House press secretary repeated it, GCHQ called the claim nonsense and said it should be ignored. The documents show the partners anticipated both cooperating on and acting against one another’s citizens; they do not show a standing arrangement to swap surveillance of each other’s people.

Still open

No government has confirmed Mike Frost’s account of the two Thatcher ministers. The 2005 NSA directive the public has seen is a draft, and what any final version says is not known. The public tests so far have been narrow: Britain’s committee looked at the PRISM allegations, Canada’s courts at CSIS warrants. A document showing a standing arrangement, or ruling one out, would move this file.

Where it stands (for now)

Under Review. A former Canadian spy described it, an NSA draft reserved the right to target a partner’s citizens, and a Canadian court found CSIS used allies to intercept Canadians abroad without telling the judge. Britain’s oversight committee found no such evasion in the PRISM case, and no document has surfaced showing a routine swap.

Sources

  1. News Ex-Snoop Confirms Echelon Network · CBS News · Feb. 23, 2000
  2. Document A brief history of UKUSA · GCHQ
  3. News Spy versus spy, gatekeeper versus gatekeeper · Crikey · Nov. 21, 2013
  4. Source X(Re): A Check on CSIS Powers or a Roadmap for Expanding Them? · TheCourt.ca, Osgoode Hall Law School · Nov. 5, 2014
  5. Document Statement on GCHQ’s Alleged Interception of Communications under the US PRISM Programme · Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament (UK) · July 16, 2013
  6. News Britain’s GCHQ Denies ‘Ridiculous’ Claim It Helped Wiretap Trump · NBC News · March 16, 2017

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip