Ghosts & the paranormal

Gef the talking mongoose: the Isle of Man’s “Dalby Spook” of the 1930s

From 1931 an Isle of Man family said a talking mongoose named Gef lived in their walls. Harry Price investigated, the hairs were a dog’s, and the case ended in a famous slander trial.

TinfoilFor fun. Nothing solid has surfaced, and the official answer is no. The hat stays on the hook, just in case.

Published Oct. 7, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

Gef the talking mongoose, also known as the Dalby Spook, was said to live in the walls of a remote farmhouse at Cashen’s Gap, near the hamlet of Dalby on the Isle of Man. From 1931 the Irving family, James and Margaret and their daughter Voirrey, said a small animal behind the wooden panelling had learned to talk, sing nursery rhymes and drop the odd word of a foreign language. Gef said he was a mongoose born in India and called himself an “extra extra clever mongoose”. He became a sensation in the British press and drew some of the best-known ghost hunters of the day.

What’s on the record

The noises began in September 1931, according to the family: barking, growling, spitting and blowing behind the panels, which kept them awake at night. James Irving, a former Liverpool businessman who had bought the farm to raise sheep, said he tried a gun, traps and poison before the creature began copying animal calls and then words. Voirrey, about 13 when it began, was said to have taught it nursery rhymes. Gef was rarely seen; Mrs Irving and Voirrey said they had seen him, and Voirrey tried to photograph him.

In 1935 Harry Price, Britain’s best-known ghost hunter, travelled to the farm with R. S. Lambert, editor of the BBC’s magazine The Listener, and they told the story in a 1936 book, The Haunting of Cashen’s Gap. Gef did not perform while they were there; he later told the Irvings that Lambert was a doubter. Hairs said to come from Gef went, through Julian Huxley, to the hair expert F. Martin Duncan, who reported that they had never grown on a mongoose and were probably from a long-haired dog. Price noted that the family kept a collie called Mona, and that the panelled rooms made the house “one great speaking-tube, with walls like sounding-boards.” Paw prints sent to London later were judged not to be a mongoose’s.

Then the mongoose went to court. Sir Cecil Levita suggested to Lambert’s BBC line manager that Lambert was unfit to sit on the board of the British Film Institute, arguing, the BBC’s own history says, that he was off his head for publishing an article about a house haunted by a talking mongoose. Lambert sued for slander, pressed on despite pressure from the BBC to drop it, and won damages of £7,500, by one 1941 history’s count. The affair led to a government inquiry into how the BBC treated its staff.

What doesn’t add up

All the physical evidence pointed back to the farm. The hair matched a dog, the prints were not a mongoose’s, and the hollow-walled house could carry a voice from room to room. A reporter for the Isle of Man Examiner said he caught Voirrey making the noises. Many sceptics since have concluded that Voirrey produced the voice, with her family going along or coming to believe in it; Price and Lambert themselves floated the idea of a family legend that the family had come to believe. Voirrey, who died in 2005, maintained late in life that Gef was not her creation.

Still open

No one outside the family ever produced evidence of a talking animal. A reporter said he caught Voirrey making the noises, but she maintained late in life that Gef was not her creation, so how the voice was made, and who in the family believed what, rests on conclusions rather than an admission. Gef never performed for Price and Lambert, so no outside investigator heard him.

Where it stands (for now)

Tinfoil. No one outside the family ever produced evidence of a talking animal, the hairs were judged to be a dog’s and the paw prints not a mongoose’s. The simplest explanation, a voice carried through a house built like a speaking tube, has never been ruled out.

Sources

  1. Document Confessions of a Ghost-Hunter (Harry Price, 1936), chapter VI: The Talking Mongoose · Internet Archive
  2. Document The Long Week End: A Social History of Great Britain 1918–1939 (Robert Graves and Alan Hodge, 1941) · Internet Archive
  3. Document The Mongoose Case · History of the BBC
  4. Source Gef · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip