The Great American Streetcar Scandal: GM, National City Lines and the 1949 verdict
GM, Firestone and Standard Oil of California were convicted in 1949 of conspiring to monopolize bus sales to National City Lines. Whether they killed the American streetcar is another matter.
What’s claimed
The Great American Streetcar Scandal, also called the General Motors streetcar conspiracy, holds that General Motors and its industrial partners deliberately destroyed the electric streetcar in American cities from the late 1930s on. Through a holding company, National City Lines, they are said to have bought up transit systems, torn out the tracks and put in GM buses running on their own tires and fuel, pushing riders into cars. The story reached its widest audience through testimony to the US Senate in 1974 and, in 1988, through the plot of Who Framed Roger Rabbit.
What’s on the record
There was a conspiracy, and a court said so. National City Lines began in 1920 with two second-hand buses in Minnesota. With money from suppliers including General Motors, Firestone Tire, Phillips Petroleum, Mack and Federal Engineering, a subsidiary of Standard Oil of California, it grew to control 46 transit systems in 45 cities in 16 states by 1947. Its companies took over streetcar operations including the Bay Area’s Key System and parts of Los Angeles’s Pacific Electric, and converted many lines to buses.
On April 9, 1947, nine corporations and seven individuals were indicted. In 1949, after the case moved to federal court in northern Illinois, a jury convicted them of conspiring to monopolize the sale of buses, tires, tubes and petroleum products to the companies National City Lines controlled, which were barred from buying from rival suppliers. The jury acquitted them of conspiring to monopolize the transit companies themselves. The Seventh Circuit upheld the verdict in January 1951. GM was fined $5,000, and its treasurer, H.C. Grossman, $1.
Bradford Snell, a lawyer who had joined the staff of the Senate antitrust subcommittee, wrote a study called American Ground Transport that was circulated in February 1974 for the subcommittee’s hearings on the Industrial Reorganization Act. It called GM “a sovereign economic state” and blamed it for much of the displacement of rail transit. GM published a rebuttal, which the subcommittee printed beside Snell’s paper.
What doesn’t add up
Most transit historians say the streetcar was failing before National City Lines arrived. Peter Norton, a historian at the University of Virginia, told Vox that by the time the company was buying streetcar firms, they were already in bankruptcy. Fares were held at five cents for decades while costs rose, so operators cut maintenance; cars crowded onto the tracks; governments poured money into roads. Some streetcar companies went bankrupt as early as the 1920s. Streetcar systems were dismantled in nearly every American metropolitan area, and Vox estimated that National City Lines was involved in only about 10 percent of cases. A 1997 Transportation Quarterly article by Cliff Slater argued that buses won on economics, though a rebuttal in the same journal a year later argued the companies’ campaign did hasten the end. The UCLA economist George Hilton rejected Snell’s reading, arguing that a change on that scale could come only from public preference and technology, not from a single monopolist.
Still open
The court tested one question: whether the companies conspired to monopolize sales of buses, tires and fuel to the systems they controlled. The jury acquitted them of conspiring to monopolize the transit companies themselves, and no court has ever ruled on whether they killed the streetcar. How much the campaign hastened the end, in the roughly 10 percent of cases Vox estimated National City Lines touched, is still argued in the journals.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. The 1949 conviction is on the record: GM and its partners conspired to lock in sales of their buses, tires and fuel to the systems they financed. Whether that killed the American streetcar, or only hurried a decline already under way, is still argued by serious historians on both sides.
Sources
- Document United States v. National City Lines, Inc., 186 F.2d 562 (7th Cir. 1951) · US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit (via Public.Resource.Org) · Jan. 2, 1951
- Document The Industrial Reorganization Act, Part 4: Ground Transportation Industries (Senate hearings, 1974) · US Government Publishing Office
- News The real story behind the demise of America’s once-mighty streetcars · Vox · May 6, 2015
- Source GM Conspiracy to Kill Streetcars? Not By Itself · Market Street Railway · May 17, 2015
- News The GM Trolley Conspiracy: What Really Happened · CBS News (MoneyWatch) · Sept. 2, 2010
- Source General Motors streetcar conspiracy · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.