Gunung Padang: Indonesia’s ‘25,000-year-old pyramid’ and the paper that was retracted
A 2023 paper said Gunung Padang in West Java hides a pyramid built up to 25,000 years ago. Its journal retracted it in 2024: the dates came from soil, not from anything people made.
What’s claimed
Gunung Padang is a megalithic site in the Cianjur district of West Java, Indonesia: terraces of stone laid across the top of a hill that formed from an extinct volcano. In October 2023 the journal Archaeological Prospection published a paper by a team led by Danny Hilman Natawidjaja, a geologist at Indonesia’s National Research and Innovation Agency, titled "Geo-archaeological prospecting of Gunung Padang buried prehistoric pyramid in West Java, Indonesia." It argued that the whole hill, not just the terraces on top, is a structure shaped by people in stages, the oldest going back 25,000 years or more. That would make the Gunung Padang pyramid far older than Egypt’s pyramids and older than Göbekli Tepe, and it fitted neatly into the lost Ice Age civilization that Graham Hancock had promoted on his Netflix series Ancient Apocalypse, which visited the site.
What’s on the record
The team used ground-penetrating radar, electrical resistivity and drill cores. They described four layers: at the centre, a natural lava hill they said had been sculpted into shape; then coarse sand and pillar-like stones; then a layer of columnar rock; then the megalithic terraces on the surface. They radiocarbon dated organic soil from the cores and read the oldest dates as the age of the earliest building work.
Archaeologists objected at once. Nature reported on 28 November 2023 that the paper had prompted an investigation by the journal. Flint Dibble of Cardiff University said that a core drilled under the Palace of Westminster might bring up 40,000-year-old carbon, which would not make the palace 40,000 years old. Bill Farley of Southern Connecticut State University said the paper was not worthy of publication, the Smithsonian reported.
On 19 March 2024 the publisher, Wiley, and the journal’s editors retracted the paper. The notice said the radiocarbon dates came from soil samples not associated with any artefacts or features that could reliably be read as man-made, an error missed in peer review, and that the interpretation of a pyramid built 9,000 or more years ago "is incorrect." All the authors disagreed. Natawidjaja called it an unjust retraction of groundbreaking research and told Retraction Watch the team was baffled. Hancock, it emerged, had been thanked in the paper for proofreading.
What doesn’t add up
The weak link is between the date and the builder. Soil deep inside a hill can be very old whether or not anyone ever built on it, and the dated samples held nothing shown to be human work. Indonesian archaeologists who have excavated the site, among them Lutfi Yondri, report charcoal from contexts tied directly to the stone architecture that dates the monument to about 2,100 years ago. Most specialists see Gunung Padang as stone terraces built onto a natural hill, not a pyramid hiding inside one. The deep layers in the 2023 study were known mainly from instruments and drill cores, and the claim of Ice Age construction has not been backed by anything people demonstrably made.
Still open
The deep layers inside the hill are known mainly from instruments and drill cores rather than excavation. No tool, hearth or other human work has been found with the old soil dates, and the authors still dispute the retraction. Something people demonstrably made, found in those deep layers and dated, would reopen the Ice Age question; until then the dates tied to the stonework say about 2,100 years.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. Gunung Padang is a real and impressive megalithic site, and the 2023 study is real. Its Ice Age pyramid rests on soil dates its own journal ruled could not show human building, while the dates tied to the stonework point to about 2,100 years ago.
Sources
- News A 27,000-year-old pyramid? Controversy hits an extraordinary archaeological claim · Nature · Nov. 27, 2023
- News Archaeologists Criticize Alleged Discovery of the ‘Oldest Pyramid in the World’ · Smithsonian Magazine · Dec. 20, 2023
- News Is the World’s Oldest Pyramid Not in Egypt or the Americas, But in Indonesia? · Atlas Obscura · Nov. 7, 2023
- News Controversial pyramid paper retracted when authors turn out to have radiocarbon-dated nearby dirt · Retraction Watch · March 19, 2024
- News Paper claiming ‘world’s oldest pyramid’ retracted over ‘error’ · Times Higher Education · March 19, 2024
More: the case files, every source behind every story.