The Hellfire Club: Sir Francis Dashwood’s Medmenham ‘monks’ and the West Wycombe caves
In the 1750s Sir Francis Dashwood’s ‘monks’ met at Medmenham Abbey under Rabelais’s motto; Benjamin Franklin visited West Wycombe, and the black-mass rumours have outlived the evidence.
What’s claimed
The Hellfire Club, more properly the Order of the Friars of St Francis of Wycombe or the Monks of Medmenham, was a private brotherhood founded by Sir Francis Dashwood, a Buckinghamshire landowner and politician, in mid-18th-century England. The legend says its members, drawn from the top of Georgian society, held black masses, orgies and Satanic rites at Medmenham Abbey on the Thames and in the chalk caves under West Wycombe hill, and that Benjamin Franklin joined in.
What’s on the record
The Victoria County History of Buckinghamshire, published in 1925, dates the brotherhood to about 1745. It says membership was limited to 24 men of rank who met in the summer months at Medmenham Abbey, a ruined house on the site of a Cistercian abbey that Dashwood rented and had restored; Robin Simon, editor of The British Art Journal, in a 2008 Gresham College lecture, dates the lease to 1751. Over the entrance was a motto from Rabelais, Fay ce que voudras: do what you will. The county history adds that the group was often confused with an earlier Hell Fire Club founded by the Duke of Wharton under George I. Members included the poet Paul Whitehead, who served as its steward, John Wilkes and the Earl of Sandwich. Dashwood himself became Chancellor of the Exchequer in 1762.
The caves are real too. Dashwood had them dug between 1748 and 1754, partly to give work to local people after poor harvests and partly to supply chalk for a new road to High Wycombe. Whitehead, who died in 1774, left his heart to Dashwood; it was placed in an urn in the West Wycombe mausoleum and stolen in 1829. Franklin did stay at West Wycombe: in August 1773 he wrote to his son William that the gardens were a paradise. That same year he and Dashwood published an abridged Book of Common Prayer, with Franklin generally credited with the preface and Dashwood with the shortened services.
What doesn’t add up
The black-mass stories trace mostly to gossip and satire. The county history says the members’ amusements included mock religious ceremonies, for which they were "justly censured," but that by 1762 the brotherhood had shrunk to about six and fallen into disrepute. Wilkes, expelled after a practical joke, helped publish a satirical print in 1763 that led to the abbey’s closure, and sensational legends appeared in periodicals from 1769. Simon argues that the club’s defenders understate it: William Hogarth’s portrait of Dashwood as St Francis, with an erotic book where the Bible should be and a nude in place of a crucifix, shows what contemporaries thought. That the club met in the caves at all is, by the caves’ own account, a matter of tradition. And nothing places Franklin at a Medmenham ritual. The record shows a house guest at West Wycombe and a co-author of a prayer book.
Still open
What actually happened at Medmenham rests largely on gossip, satire and sensational legends printed from 1769, after the abbey had closed. That the club met in the caves at all is, by the caves’ own account, a matter of tradition. Whitehead’s heart, left to Dashwood and placed in an urn, was stolen in 1829. A members’ own account of their meetings, if one ever surfaced, would tell us more than any satire.
Where it stands (for now)
Redacted. A real club of powerful men met in private at Medmenham, staged mock religious ceremonies and earned a scandalous name. That they worshipped the devil, or that Franklin took part in their rites, goes beyond any evidence that has surfaced so far.
Sources
-
Document
Parishes: Medmenham (A History of the County of Buckingham, Volume 3)
· Victoria County History, via British History Online · Dec. 31, 1924
“Fay ce que voudras” - Video High Politics and Hellfire: William Hogarth · Gresham College (Robin Simon) · Nov. 2, 2008
- Source History · The Hellfire Caves, West Wycombe
- Document The Franklin–Le Despencer Abridgement of the Book of Common Prayer (1773) · Society of Archbishop Justus
More: the case files, every source behind every story.