Ghosts & the paranormal

Houdini vs Margery: the magician, Mina Crandon and the Scientific American prize

In 1924 the Boston medium “Margery”, Mina Crandon, nearly won Scientific American’s $2,500 psychic prize. Harry Houdini called it fraud, and later investigators caught her too.

TinfoilFor fun. Nothing solid has surfaced, and the official answer is no. The hat stays on the hook, just in case.

Published Oct. 8, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

“Margery”, the séance name of Mina Crandon, was the most celebrated medium of the 1920s, remembered as the Witch of Lime Street. In dark rooms at her Boston home, she said, her dead brother Walter rang bells, moved tables and spoke. In 1924 she came close to winning a $2,500 prize from Scientific American for psychic phenomena shown under test conditions, until the magician Harry Houdini, a member of the judging committee, declared her a fraud. Her defenders said Houdini had rigged the tests against her.

What’s on the record

Mina Crandon was born Mina Stinson in 1888 and grew up on a farm near Picton, Ontario, before moving to Boston, where she married the surgeon Le Roi Goddard Crandon. He put her forward for the prize in 1924. The committee was the Harvard psychologist William McDougall, the physicist Daniel Comstock, Walter Franklin Prince of the American Society for Psychical Research, the writer Hereward Carrington and Houdini, with the magazine’s J. Malcolm Bird as secretary. Bird’s articles left many readers thinking she had all but won.

Houdini sat with her on July 23 and 24 and August 25, 26 and 27, 1924. In a pamphlet he published at his own expense that November, he described wearing a tight bandage all day so his leg would be swollen and sensitive, then feeling her ankle inch sideways in the dark until she could press the lid of an electric bell box. He also said she tipped a table with her head. For the August sittings Houdini had her sit in a large cabinet-box that enclosed her with only her head and hands outside. A folding ruler was later found inside; Houdini suggested she could use it to ring the bell, and she accused his assistant, Jim Collins, of planting it. Both men denied it.

By October the committee was split, The New York Times reported. Houdini called everything he had seen “a deliberate and conscious fraud”; Prince found no proof; Comstock wanted more sittings; and Carrington believed some phenomena genuine. In February 1925, after the Crandons declined further tests with Houdini, the committee voted to deny her the prize.

What doesn’t add up

The ruler remains murky. In 1959 the writer William Lindsay Gresham quoted Collins as saying Houdini had told him to plant it; the magic historian Milbourne Christopher dismissed the quotation as fiction from an unreliable source. But Margery’s case never depended on Houdini alone. In 1925 a Harvard investigator saw her draw objects from her lap, and in 1926 J. B. Rhine reported seeing her kick a megaphone. A committee of professors judged a spirit rod to be stuffed animal intestine, and a thumbprint said to be Walter’s turned out to be her dentist’s. Bird himself later wrote that she had once asked him to ring the bell box if the spirits failed. She held séances until her death in 1941.

Still open

The folding ruler in the cabinet-box is still murky. Margery blamed Houdini’s assistant, Jim Collins, and both men denied it; a 1959 quotation of Collins saying Houdini told him to plant it was dismissed by Milbourne Christopher as fiction from an unreliable source. Who put it there may never be known. Nothing she produced has ever been shown to come from Walter or any other spirit.

Where it stands (for now)

Tinfoil. Houdini’s accusations were contested and the ruler may never be explained, but investigator after investigator, from Harvard to J. B. Rhine, reported catching Margery cheating, and the thumbprint said to be Walter’s turned out to be her dentist’s. No sign of a spirit has surfaced.

Sources

  1. Document Margery Pamphlet · American Experience (PBS)
  2. News ‘Margery’ séances divide committee (The New York Times, October 16, 1924) · Interval Magic (reproduction) · Oct. 15, 1924
    “everything which took place at the séances which I attended was a deliberate and conscious fraud”
  3. News Myth, Mystery, and Margery: When Scientific American Put Psychics to the Test · Skeptic
  4. Source Mina Crandon · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip