Government & intelligence

The US human radiation experiments: the plutonium injections and the 1995 apology

From 1945 to 1947, 18 hospital patients were injected with plutonium, most likely without their knowledge. Eileen Welsome named them in 1993; a presidential committee and an apology followed.

DeclassifiedThey admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Published Oct. 3, 2026Last checked Oct. 25, 2026

What’s claimed

It is one of the oldest charges of the Cold War: that the American government used its own citizens as test subjects for radiation without telling them, then buried the records. For years it sounded like the plot of a thriller. In the 1990s the government investigated itself, in what became known as the human radiation experiments inquiry, and found that a good deal of it was true.

What’s on the record

In November 1993 The Albuquerque Tribune ran a series by reporter Eileen Welsome, “The Plutonium Experiment,” which for the first time publicly named Americans who had been injected with plutonium as the Second World War was ending. Energy Secretary Hazel O’Leary said she was shocked, and in December 1993 her department began releasing records. Welsome won the 1994 Pulitzer Prize for national reporting.

On January 15, 1994, President Bill Clinton appointed the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments, chaired by Ruth Faden, to examine government-funded experiments from 1944 to 1974. It identified nearly 4,000 of them. Its chapter on the Manhattan Project describes 18 plutonium injection subjects. The first was Ebb Cade, 53, in the Army hospital at Oak Ridge, Tennessee, after a car accident, who received about 4.7 micrograms on April 10, 1945. Albert Stevens, 58, was injected in California on May 14, 1945, because doctors expected advanced stomach cancer; a biopsy showed a benign ulcer. Eleven people were injected at the University of Rochester, three cancer patients in Chicago, and in 1946 a four-year-old with bone cancer, Simeon Shaw. The aim was to learn how plutonium behaves in the body in order to set safety standards for bomb workers. The committee found no expectation of medical benefit and little sign of consent: a 1946 letter about the California work said injections would probably happen without the patient’s knowledge.

Clinton accepted the report on October 3, 1995. “The United States of America offers a sincere apology to those of our citizens who were subjected to these experiments,” he said, and he asked his Cabinet to devise a system of relief, including compensation. His administration later reported that it had settled with the 16 families of plutonium subjects who came forward, and that more than a million pages had gone to the National Archives.

What doesn’t add up

The committee did not find one vast, sinister programme. It judged that most of the experiments advanced medical science and were unlikely to have caused harm, and it reserved its sharpest criticism for research that could offer subjects no possible benefit. It also found that using patients without their awareness was commonplace among physicians of the period, which explains a great deal but excuses less. Records for most experiments were fragmentary, and some subjects could never be identified. The committee concluded that secrecy may have been the greatest harm of all: it bred lasting distrust and denied people the chance to seek redress.

Still open

Records for most of the experiments were fragmentary, the committee found, and some subjects could never be identified. Of the plutonium subjects, the administration settled with the 16 families who came forward. More than a million pages went to the National Archives, but with records that thin, some questions, about who was used and what they were told, may never be answered.

Where it stands (for now)

Declassified. A presidential committee confirmed the plutonium injections and other unethical experiments, and the president formally apologized for them. The committee judged most of the experiments unlikely to have caused harm, and concluded that secrecy may have been the greatest harm of all.

Sources

  1. Document Final Report of the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments: Preface · US Department of Energy (Office of Human Radiation Experiments)
  2. Document Chapter 5: The Manhattan District Experiments · Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments (US Department of Energy)
  3. Document Final Report of the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments: Executive Summary · Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments (US Department of Energy)
  4. Document Remarks on Receiving the Report of the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments · Public Papers of the Presidents (GovInfo) · Oct. 2, 1995
  5. News 1994 Pulitzers Honor Journalists, Artists · The Christian Science Monitor · April 13, 1994
  6. Document Building Public Trust: Executive Summary · Federation of American Scientists (copy of the Clinton administration report)

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip