Jekyll Island, 1910: the secret meeting that drafted the Federal Reserve’s blueprint
In November 1910 Senator Nelson Aldrich and five others met in secret on Georgia’s Jekyll Island and drafted the plan behind the Federal Reserve; the Fed’s own historians confirm it.
What’s claimed
The Jekyll Island meeting, sometimes called the Jekyll Island conference or the First Name Club, was a secret gathering held in November 1910 at the Jekyll Island Club, off the coast of Georgia. The claim is that a handful of Wall Street bankers met in disguise to write the plan that created the Federal Reserve, the US central bank, and, in its larger form, that the Fed has been a private bankers’ cabal ever since.
What’s on the record
The secret meeting is confirmed on the Federal Reserve’s own history website. According to an essay by Gary Richardson and Jessie Romero, six men met at the club from about November 20 to 30, 1910: Senator Nelson Aldrich, who chaired the National Monetary Commission set up after the Panic of 1907; A. Piatt Andrew, a Harvard economist who became an assistant Treasury secretary; Henry Davison, a partner at J.P. Morgan; Frank Vanderlip, president of National City Bank; Paul Warburg of Kuhn, Loeb and Co.; and Arthur Shelton, Aldrich’s private secretary. Benjamin Strong of Bankers Trust is often listed too, but the essay says most scholars conclude he did not attend, though his ideas were represented.
The secrecy was deliberate. Aldrich passed the trip off as a duck hunt. The men came one at a time to a New Jersey rail terminal, boarded his private car and used only first names so the staff would not learn who they were. Aldrich feared that the group’s Wall Street ties would sink the plan in Congress. Participants denied the meeting for about 20 years. The journalist B.C. Forbes first reported it in 1916, and participants began to admit it around 1930. Vanderlip later wrote that none of them felt like conspirators and that they believed they were doing patriotic work.
The group drafted what became the Aldrich plan: a Reserve Association of America, a central bank with 15 branches. Aldrich presented it in January 1911, but Democrats attacked it as giving bankers too much power and shelved it after winning Congress and the White House. Representative Carter Glass and Senator Robert Owen then brought forward the bills that became the Federal Reserve Act, which President Woodrow Wilson signed on December 23, 1913. The Fed’s historians say the law’s technical details closely resembled the Aldrich plan, while its political structure, with up to 12 regional Reserve Banks, was a compromise.
The other side
The broader claim, that the Fed is a privately owned cabal, does not match its structure. The Federal Reserve says the system "is not owned by anyone." The Board of Governors in Washington is a federal agency whose members are appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Member banks must hold stock in their regional Reserve Bank, but it is not like ordinary shares, and earnings beyond costs, legally required dividends and a limited surplus go to the US Treasury. Reason’s review of the history notes that Fed conspiracy theories nearly always lean on Jekyll Island. Some versions also invoke the Rothschild family; the American Jewish Committee identifies Rothschild banking-control stories as an antisemitic myth and points out false claims that the family belongs to the New York Fed.
Still open
The meeting is no longer a secret, but parts of it are still hazy. Whether Benjamin Strong was there is unsettled, though most scholars conclude he was not. What we know of those ten days comes largely from participants who denied the trip for about 20 years before writing about it. The separate claim that the Fed is a private cabal finds no support in its public structure, and the Rothschild version is an antisemitic myth.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. A secret 1910 meeting of a senator and leading bankers drafted the blueprint for the Federal Reserve, and the Fed’s own historians say so. The claim that the Fed is a private cabal is a separate one, and its public structure, a federal board with earnings going to the Treasury, does not support it.
Sources
- Document The Meeting at Jekyll Island · Federal Reserve History (Federal Reserve System) · Dec. 3, 2015
- Document Federal Reserve Act Signed into Law · Federal Reserve History (Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City)
- Document Who owns the Federal Reserve? · Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
- News How the Fed Was Born · Reason · March 24, 2016
- Source Rothschild (#TranslateHate glossary) · American Jewish Committee
More: the case files, every source behind every story.