Klüver’s ‘form constants’: the tunnels and lattices people see, and the cave-art theory
Tunnels, spirals, honeycombs and cobwebs: people everywhere see the same shapes at the edge of altered states. Why the brain makes them, and the disputed idea that Stone Age artists painted them.
What’s claimed
If any part of the “other realm” really is shared, it is the entrance: tunnels, funnels, spirals, honeycombs, chequerboards and cobwebs that people describe on the edge of sleep, in flickering light, near death and in drug states. Some writers go further. They say Stone Age artists saw the same patterns in trance and painted them on cave walls, and that this shared geometry shows humans have always passed into the same otherworld.
What’s on the record
The patterns have a name. The psychologist Heinrich Klüver sorted these images into four “form constants”: gratings and lattices (including honeycombs and chequerboards), cobwebs, tunnels and funnels, and spirals. In 2001, Bressloff, Cowan and three colleagues showed in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B that the form constants follow from the wiring of the brain’s primary visual cortex: when activity there settles into simple waves, the way the eye maps onto the cortex turns them into tunnels, spirals and lattices in what a person sees.
A 2002 summary by the same team in Neural Computation listed the triggers: flickering lights, waking or falling asleep, near-death experiences, several drugs and many other conditions. It noted that the images are usually seen in both eyes and move with them, which the authors took to mean they are made in the brain. In 2007, Billock and Tsou reported in PNAS that hallucinations produced by plain flickering light behave by the same rules as ordinary vision.
The cave-art idea is on the record too. In 1988, J. D. Lewis-Williams and T. A. Dowson argued in Current Anthropology, in “The Signs of All Times,” that geometric signs in Upper Palaeolithic art echo these “entoptic” images. Their “three stages of trance” model holds that geometric patterns come first, followed by deeper stages in which people see full scenes and beings.
What doesn’t add up
The neuroscience explains the geometry; it says nothing about beings, rooms or messages, which are what claims of another realm are really about. The cave theory is contested. In 2003 Patricia Helvenston and Paul Bahn published a critique of the three-stage model in the Cambridge Archaeological Journal, alongside comments from a neuropsychologist and a rock-art specialist. A zigzag on a cave wall can be read many ways, and the artists left no account of why they made it.
What believers can fairly say is that the geometry really is shared: the same few shapes, across cultures and triggers, because human visual systems are built alike.
Still open
Why the brain, past the geometric stage, so often goes on to build rooms and figures is not explained by the form-constant models. Whether any particular cave sign was painted from trance imagery cannot be tested directly. How the geometry gives way to the full scenes people describe is still not modelled.
Where it stands (for now)
Under Review. That people everywhere see the same geometry is documented and has a strong explanation in the visual cortex. That cave artists recorded this geometry from trance is argued both ways by archaeologists, and the step from shared patterns to a shared place is not supported so far.
Sources
- Document Geometric visual hallucinations, Euclidean symmetry and the functional architecture of striate cortex · Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B (PubMed) · Feb. 28, 2001
- Document What geometric visual hallucinations tell us about the visual cortex · Neural Computation (PubMed) · Feb. 28, 2002
- Document Neural interactions between flicker-induced self-organized visual hallucinations and physical stimuli · PNAS (PubMed) · April 29, 2007
- Document The Signs of All Times: Entoptic Phenomena in Upper Palaeolithic Art · Current Anthropology
- Document Testing the ‘Three Stages of Trance’ Model · Cambridge Archaeological Journal · Nov. 27, 2003
More: the case files, every source behind every story.