Ships, seas & the deep

Kursk submarine disaster: torpedo fuel or a NATO collision in the Barents Sea?

Russia says a leaking practice torpedo sank the Kursk on August 12, 2000, killing 118. Some admirals still blame a NATO submarine, but none has offered proof.

UnconfirmedThin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Published Oct. 9, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

The Kursk submarine disaster, the loss of the Russian Northern Fleet’s nuclear-powered Oscar II-class submarine Kursk in the Barents Sea on August 12, 2000, killed all 118 men aboard. Russia’s official answer is that a faulty practice torpedo leaked its fuel and exploded. A persistent counter-theory, voiced by senior Russian officers from the first days, holds that a NATO submarine shadowing the exercise collided with the Kursk, and that the truth was buried.

What’s on the record

The Kursk went down during naval exercises after two explosions, both caught by seismic instruments. Writing in the American Geophysical Union’s newsletter Eos in January 2001, researchers from the University of Arizona and Los Alamos National Laboratory found that the second blast came 135 seconds after the first and was about 250 times larger. The first was consistent with roughly 250 kilograms of explosive, the size of a torpedo warhead; the second released energy equal to about five tonnes of TNT. The signals, they concluded, had the features of underwater explosions, not a collision or other impact.

Most of the crew died at once, The Associated Press reported, but about 23 men reached a compartment at the stern; investigators concluded they died within about eight hours. Russia delayed its search, turned down Western help and failed with its own mini-submarines. After a week it accepted Norwegian divers, who opened a hatch within hours, too late. The wreck was raised in October 2001 and 115 bodies were recovered.

Vladimir Putin, who had begun a holiday in Sochi the day the Kursk sank, was asked on CNN by Larry King on September 8, 2000, what had happened to the submarine. He answered, “It sank.” The reply has followed him ever since.

In late 2000, a study for the navy pointed to the 65-76 torpedo, driven by concentrated hydrogen peroxide, while the head of the government commission, Ilya Klebanov, and the navy commander, Admiral Vladimir Kuroyedov, still called an internal accident unlikely, Bellona reported. In 2002 Prosecutor-General Vladimir Ustinov delivered a 133-volume report, of which only a four-page summary was published, on August 29 in Rossiiskaya gazeta. It blamed a torpedo that leaked highly explosive hydrogen peroxide fuel, linked the leak to corroded parts and faulty gaskets, and found no one to blame, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty reported.

What doesn’t add up

The collision theory has never produced its submarine. Top naval officers blamed a foreign submarine early on, and RFE/RL noted that the navy’s leadership preferred a story in which a US torpedo was at fault. In November 2021 Admiral Vyacheslav Popov, who commanded the Northern Fleet in 2000 and was dismissed after the sinking, told RIA Novosti that a NATO submarine had bumped the Kursk while shadowing it at close range and was itself damaged. He did not name it and, the AP reported, lacked proof. The Kremlin’s spokesman, Dmitry Peskov, declined to comment and pointed to the official investigation. Against the theory stand the seismic record of two explosions and the absence of any damaged foreign submarine in public evidence. In its favour stands only distrust, fed by a report the public has seen four pages of.

Still open

Prosecutor-General Ustinov’s 2002 report runs to 133 volumes, and only a four-page summary has been published. Admiral Popov said in 2021 that a NATO submarine bumped the Kursk, but he did not name it and, the AP reported, lacked proof. Publication of the full report, or any record of a damaged foreign submarine, would settle more than another admiral’s word.

Where it stands (for now)

Unconfirmed. The two explosions, the leaking-torpedo finding and the seismic analysis all point to an accident inside the Kursk. The collision story rests so far on officers’ assertions that no one has backed with evidence, though Russia’s secrecy, 133 volumes with four pages published, keeps suspicion alive.

Sources

  1. News Russian admiral: Kursk disaster caused by NATO sub · Navy Times (The Associated Press) · Nov. 21, 2021
  2. News Seismic analysis of the Kursk explosions (Eos, American Geophysical Union) · ScienceDaily · Jan. 22, 2001
  3. News Russia: Kursk report published · Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty · Sept. 1, 2002
    “no one was to blame for the explosion”
  4. News ‘We couldn’t tell the relatives’ · Meduza · Oct. 5, 2020
  5. News Leaking torpedo could cause Kursk disaster · Bellona · Dec. 4, 2000

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip