Leaded gasoline: how GM, Standard Oil and DuPont kept a known poison in our fuel
Leaded gas went on sale in 1923 though its makers knew it was poisonous; workers died making it and industry-funded science defended it for decades. The last country to sell it stopped in 2021.
What’s claimed
Leaded gasoline, sold under the brand name Ethyl, is often called the original corporate cover-up: General Motors, Standard Oil of New Jersey (the company later known as Exxon) and DuPont put tetraethyl lead into fuel in the 1920s knowing it was a poison, and kept it there for half a century with the help of research they paid for.
What’s on the record
In December 1921 Thomas Midgley Jr., working in Charles Kettering’s research lab at General Motors, found that tetraethyl lead stopped engine “knock.” Its danger was understood: Smithsonian Magazine reports that a DuPont executive described it in 1922 as “very poisonous if absorbed through the skin.” That December the US Surgeon General, H.S. Cumming, wrote to Pierre du Pont asking whether lead in exhaust could be a health hazard; Midgley replied that no experimental data had been taken. The first tank of leaded gasoline was sold in Dayton, Ohio, in February 1923, while Midgley was recovering from lead poisoning.
Workers paid first. Two GM employees making the additive in Dayton died in April 1924. On October 26, 1924, the first of five workers died in quick succession at Standard Oil’s tetraethyl lead works at its Bayway refinery in Elizabeth, New Jersey; dozens more suffered tremors and hallucinations, and workers called the product “loony gas.” New York City, Philadelphia and New Jersey banned leaded fuel. A US Bureau of Mines study released weeks later cleared it, under a contract that let the companies’ new joint venture, the Ethyl Gasoline Corporation, review its findings before publication. After a 1925 conference called by the Surgeon General, a committee reported in January 1926 that it saw no good grounds for a ban.
For the next 40 years, Jamie Lincoln Kitman reported in The Nation, research on the additive’s health effects was paid for by the companies and their trade groups. The leading voice was Robert Kehoe, hired for GM in 1924, Ethyl’s chief medical consultant from 1925 to 1958 and director of a University of Cincinnati laboratory founded with money from GM, DuPont and Ethyl. Kehoe held that lead occurs naturally in the body, and he told Congress that he and his colleagues had looked for 30 years for evidence of harm from leaded gasoline in the general population and found none.
The challenge came from a geochemist. Clair Patterson, who had dated the Earth at about 4.5 billion years using meteorite lead in 1953, argued in a 1965 paper that industrial lead had raised levels in many Americans to more than 100 times natural, and later showed that modern Greenland snow held over 100 times its preindustrial lead. Kehoe called him “more of a zealot than a scientist,” according to Patterson’s National Academy of Sciences memoir. Patterson testified to Senator Muskie’s subcommittee on June 15, 1966, and was left off a 1971 National Research Council panel on airborne lead.
The US Environmental Protection Agency issued its first reduction standards in 1973 and in January 1996 announced the last steps of a 25-year phase-out. Canada has prohibited leaded gasoline in motor vehicles since 1990 under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act. Algeria, the last country selling it for cars, stopped in July 2021; the UN Environment Programme estimates the global ban prevents more than 1.2 million premature deaths a year.
The other side
The industry’s case in the 1920s was that the deaths happened in manufacturing and blending, not on the road, and the 1926 committee agreed. In 1924 no one had measured what exhaust did to the public. That gap was the problem: for decades, the people filling it were paid by the sellers.
Still open
Lead’s harm is not in doubt, and leaded fuel for cars has been gone worldwide since Algeria stopped in 2021. What remains is a paperwork question. The 1924 Bureau of Mines study cleared the additive under a contract that let the companies’ joint venture review its findings before publication, and for about 40 years the research on its health effects was paid for by the sellers. How much that arrangement shaped the 1926 committee’s view, the record shows only in part.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The early warnings, the Bayway deaths, the industry-funded research and the long fight to remove lead from fuel are all on the record. The UN Environment Programme credits the global ban with preventing more than 1.2 million premature deaths a year.
Sources
- News Leaded Gas Was a Known Poison the Day It Was Invented · Smithsonian Magazine · Dec. 8, 2016
- News The Secret History of Lead · The Nation (Jamie Lincoln Kitman) · March 1, 2000
- Document Clair Cameron Patterson, by George R. Tilton (Biographical Memoirs, Volume 74) · National Academy of Sciences (National Academies Press)
- Document EPA Takes Final Step in Phaseout of Leaded Gasoline · US Environmental Protection Agency · Jan. 28, 1996
- Document Lead Information Package: Some Commonly Asked Questions About Lead and Human Health · Health Canada
- Document Era of leaded petrol over, eliminating a major threat to human and planetary health · UN Environment Programme · Aug. 29, 2021
More: the case files, every source behind every story.