The Lincoln assassination conspiracy: Booth’s 1865 plot, the trial and the myths
John Wilkes Booth led a real plot in April 1865 to kill Lincoln, Seward and Johnson; eight were convicted and four hanged, while later claims that Booth escaped have no support.
What’s claimed
The assassination of Abraham Lincoln is one conspiracy theory that is simply history: it was a conspiracy. On the night of April 14, 1865, John Wilkes Booth shot the president at Ford’s Theatre in Washington while his accomplices went after Secretary of State William Seward and Vice-President Andrew Johnson. Around that core grew wilder claims: that the Confederate government ordered it, that Johnson or War Secretary Edwin Stanton was secretly behind it, and that Booth himself escaped and lived for decades under another name.
What’s on the record
Booth, a famous actor and Confederate sympathizer, began assembling a ring in 1864 to kidnap Lincoln and carry him to Richmond, according to the National Park Service, which runs Ford’s Theatre as a historic site. The kidnap plans came to nothing, including a failed attempt in March 1865. Days after Robert E. Lee surrendered on April 9, Booth heard Lincoln speak of giving the vote to Black men who had served in Union armies. On the morning of April 14 he learned the president would attend Our American Cousin that evening, and he turned the plot to murder. He would kill Lincoln; George Atzerodt would kill Johnson at the Kirkwood House hotel; Lewis Powell, guided by David Herold, would kill Seward.
Booth shot Lincoln at about 10:15 p.m. and escaped. Powell forced his way into Seward’s home and stabbed him and others in the house. Atzerodt lost his nerve and spent the night drinking. Booth and Herold fled into Maryland, where Dr. Samuel Mudd treated Booth’s broken leg. Federal troops cornered them at Richard Garrett’s farm in Virginia on April 26; Booth refused to surrender and was shot dead. An autopsy aboard the USS Montauk confirmed the body was his.
Eight accused were tried by a military commission rather than a civilian court, in a trial of seven weeks with 366 witnesses. Atzerodt, Herold, Powell and Mary Surratt, whose Washington boarding house had served as the plotters’ meeting place, were hanged on July 7, 1865. Surratt was the first woman executed by the federal government; five members of the tribunal had asked Johnson for clemency, and he refused. Mudd, Samuel Arnold and Michael O’Laughlen were sentenced to life and the stagehand Ned Spangler to six years. O’Laughlen died of yellow fever in prison in 1867, and Johnson pardoned the other three in 1869. Surratt’s son John, a Confederate courier central to the kidnap plot, fled abroad, was caught in Egypt and tried in a civilian court in 1867; the jury could not agree, and he went free.
What doesn’t add up
The grand theories. Stanton was convinced Confederate president Jefferson Davis was behind the murder and accepted questionable testimony in trying to prove it, but the Park Service says no hard evidence of Davis’s involvement has been found. Booth did meet Confederate agents in Montreal while planning the kidnapping, so the question is open, not closed. Later theories naming Johnson, Stanton or the Catholic Church as the real culprits have no factual basis.
Then there is the escaped Booth. In 1907 Finis L. Bates published The Escape and Suicide of John Wilkes Booth, claiming a look-alike died at the Garrett farm while Booth lived on as "John St. Helen" in Texas and killed himself in Enid, Oklahoma, in 1903 under the name David E. George. Bates showed the mummified body in carnival sideshows. Against this stands the autopsy, and the body was identified again before it was released to the Booth family in 1869 and buried in Baltimore.
Still open
Whether the Confederate government had a hand in it is still open. Booth met Confederate agents in Montreal while planning the kidnapping, but the Park Service says no hard evidence of Jefferson Davis’s involvement has been found, and Stanton leaned on questionable testimony trying to prove it. John Surratt, central to the kidnap plot, went free in 1867 when his civilian jury could not agree, so his part was never settled by a verdict.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. Booth’s plot to kill Lincoln, Seward and Johnson, the trial and the executions are thoroughly recorded. No hard evidence of a Confederate order has surfaced so far; theories naming Johnson, Stanton or the Catholic Church have no factual basis, and the autopsy and a second identification stand against the tale of Booth’s escape.
Sources
- Document The Lincoln Conspirators · Ford’s Theatre National Historic Site (US National Park Service)
-
Document
FAQ: The Assassin
· Ford’s Theatre National Historic Site (US National Park Service) · Nov. 23, 2024
“As of 2024, no hard evidence exists to confirm theories of Davis’s involvement.” - Document The Assassin’s Escape · Ford’s Theatre National Historic Site (US National Park Service)
- Document The escape and suicide of John Wilkes Booth (Finis L. Bates, 1907) · Internet Archive (University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign)
- Source John Wilkes Booth · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.