The Loch Ness Monster: a 1934 hoax photo, sonar sweeps and a loch full of eel DNA
Nessie has been hunted since 1933, but its most famous photo was a toy-submarine hoax, the 1987 sonar sweep proved nothing and a DNA survey of the loch found eels, not reptiles.
What’s claimed
The Loch Ness Monster, better known as Nessie, is said to be a large unknown animal living in Loch Ness, the long, deep freshwater loch near Inverness in the Scottish Highlands. Believers describe humps, a long neck and a small head, and many picture a plesiosaur, a marine reptile from the age of the dinosaurs. The legend claims an old pedigree: a biography of St Columba says that in AD 565 he ordered a beast in the loch to leave a swimmer alone. Since 1933, sightings, photographs and sonar contacts have been offered as proof that something big still lives in the water.
What’s on the record
The modern story starts with a road. NOVA notes that a new road along the loch’s northern shore was finished in 1933, giving drivers their first clear view of the water from that side. That April a local couple driving home reported an enormous animal on the surface, and the Inverness Courier wrote it up. In December 1933 the Daily Mail hired big-game hunter Marmaduke Wetherell, who reported huge four-toed footprints on the shore. In early January 1934, zoologists at the Natural History Museum said the prints had been made with a stuffed hippopotamus foot.
In 1934 the Daily Mail published the “Surgeon’s Photograph,” bought from London physician R. Kenneth Wilson, showing what looked like a head and neck rising from the loch. It became the defining image of Nessie. In 1994, researcher Alastair Boyd and his friend David Martin made public a confession from Christian Spurling, then 93 and Ian Wetherell’s stepbrother. Spurling said the Wetherells staged the picture to get back at the Daily Mail after the hippo-foot embarrassment, using a head and neck fixed to a toy submarine, and had Wilson sell it as his own.
The biggest sonar search came in October 1987. Operation Deepscan, led by Adrian Shine, swept the length of the loch with 24 boats fitted with echo sounders. It logged three deep-water contacts that could not be identified or found again; palaeontologist Darren Naish, writing for BBC Science Focus, says they were probably debris or thermal effects, possibly a seal, and that no sweep since has found anything that can be read with confidence as a giant animal.
In September 2019, a team led by geneticist Neil Gemmell of New Zealand’s University of Otago reported on 250 water samples taken around the loch at different depths. Sequencing the environmental DNA shed by living things found no trace of reptiles, and none of shark, catfish or sturgeon, but a large amount of eel DNA at nearly every site. Gemmell said the data could not show how big the eels are, though he called a giant eel “plausible.”
The watch goes on. On August 26, 2023, the Loch Ness Centre at Drumnadrochit launched a two-day search, billed as the biggest in 50 years, with volunteers on boats and the shore, thermal-imaging drones, infrared cameras and a hydrophone, the Associated Press reported.
What doesn’t add up
The two most famous pieces of evidence came from the same hunter and the same newspaper, and both were fakes. Not everyone accepts every detail of the confession: NOVA notes that journalist Richard Smith questioned whether a 1930s toy submarine could do what Spurling described. Boyd, who exposed the photo, still believes he saw a large animal himself. The Loch Ness Centre’s Alan McKenna told BBC radio that while not every ripple is a beast, a handful cannot be explained. But unexplained is not unknown species: decades of sonar have produced no repeatable target, and the DNA in the water points to eels.
Still open
Three deep-water sonar contacts from Operation Deepscan in 1987 were never identified or found again. Gemmell’s DNA survey could not show how big the loch’s eels are, and he called a giant eel plausible. The Loch Ness Centre says a handful of sightings cannot be explained. A repeatable sonar target, a body or reptile DNA in the water would reopen the question; none has turned up so far.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The famous 1934 photo was staged, according to a confession made public in 1994, the 1987 sonar contacts were never repeated, and the loch’s DNA showed no reptile. A big eel is the most anyone has made a scientific case for.
Sources
- Source The Beast of Loch Ness: Birth of a Legend · NOVA (PBS)
- Source The Beast of Loch Ness: Birth of a Legend (3), the Surgeon’s Photograph · NOVA (PBS)
- News Operation Deepscan: The hunt for the Loch Ness Monster · BBC Science Focus · Dec. 8, 2020
- News Could the Loch Ness monster be a giant eel? · Phys.org · Sept. 4, 2019
- News Loch Ness monster enthusiasts launch new search effort for mythical lake beast · PBS NewsHour (Associated Press) · Aug. 25, 2023
More: the case files, every source behind every story.