The Lusitania, 1915: the munitions in her hold and the claim Churchill set her up
The Lusitania did carry rifle ammunition and shrapnel shells when a U-boat sank her in 1915; the claim that Churchill deliberately exposed her to draw in the US is unproven.
What’s claimed
The Cunard liner RMS Lusitania was torpedoed by the German submarine U-20, under Kapitänleutnant Walther Schwieger, on May 7, 1915, about 11 nautical miles off the Old Head of Kinsale, Ireland. She sank in about 18 minutes, and 1,197 of the 1,960 people aboard died, about 128 of them American. Three claims have followed her for a century: that she secretly carried munitions, making her a legitimate target; that a mysterious second explosion was that cargo going up; and that the British Admiralty, led by Winston Churchill, deliberately left her exposed in the hope of dragging the United States into the war.
What’s on the record
Germany gave notice. A warning from the Imperial German Embassy, dated April 22, 1915, appeared in American newspapers on April 30, the day before she sailed from New York, telling travellers that ships flying the British flag in the war zone were liable to destruction.
The munitions are documented. Her cargo included about 173 tons of war supplies: some 4.2 million rounds of rifle ammunition, nearly 5,000 shrapnel shell casings and 3,240 brass percussion fuses. Researchers at The Lusitania Resource note that the detailed supplementary manifest shows shrapnel shells in her hold, and cite the Royal Artillery Historical Trust’s view that the shells were shipped with their propellant charges. In September 2008, divers working for the wreck’s American owner, Gregg Bemis, under an Irish government licence, brought up Remington .303 rifle cartridges. Fionnbar Moore of Ireland’s Underwater Archaeology Unit said the find "strongly supports the argument that the Lusitania was functioning as more than a passenger liner," while adding that more research was needed.
Churchill’s intentions are partly on paper too. On February 12, 1915, he wrote to his cabinet colleague Walter Runciman that it was "most important to attract neutral shipping to our shores, in the hope especially of embroiling the U.S. with Germany."
The British inquiry under Lord Mersey, held in June and July 1915, cleared Capt. William Turner, Cunard and the Royal Navy and blamed the German government. It noted the ammunition was stored about 50 yards from where the torpedo struck.
What doesn’t add up
The leap from motive to plot has never been documented. The naval intelligence historian Patrick Beesly argued there was a conspiracy to put the ship at risk, and the writer Colin Simpson claimed in 1972 that an escort was deliberately withdrawn. The Churchill Project at Hillsdale College counters that Churchill was away from the Admiralty in the days before the attack and that the "Admiralty War Diary" Simpson cited has never been found by any other historian. The historian David Stafford concluded that Churchill was not the mainspring of a conspiracy "because none existed," and that secret Room 40 code-breaking intelligence was kept from the inquiry to protect the code-breakers, not to hide a plot. Most historians see bad judgment and risk-taking, not a set-up.
The second explosion remains debated. Robert Ballard, who surveyed the wreck in 1993, found the cargo area apparently undamaged and suggested coal dust; critics say the dust would have been too damp. Boilers, a burst steam line and the ammunition all have advocates. In 2012, explosives researchers at Lawrence Livermore concluded the torpedo itself was enough to sink her.
Still open
The “Admiralty War Diary” Colin Simpson cited has never been found by any other historian, so what it says can’t be checked. Room 40’s code-breaking intelligence was kept from the Mersey inquiry, and what it showed about the danger to the ship was never put to that inquiry. The second explosion still has no agreed cause. A document linking Churchill’s stated hope to an order touching the Lusitania would move this file.
Where it stands (for now)
Unconfirmed. The munitions in her hold are documented, and so is Churchill’s written wish to embroil the United States. No document has yet shown that the Admiralty deliberately set her up, and most historians see bad judgment and risk-taking rather than a plot.
Sources
- News Lusitania’s Secret Cargo · Archaeology (Archaeological Institute of America) · Dec. 31, 2008
- Source Sinking the “Lusitania”: A Long-Lived Conspiracy Theory · The Churchill Project, Hillsdale College · Sept. 23, 2020
- Source Contraband · The Lusitania Resource
- Source The Second Explosion · The Lusitania Resource
- Source Sinking of the RMS Lusitania · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.