Majestic 12 documents: the 1984 film roll, the Truman memo and the FBI’s ‘bogus’
In 1984 a roll of film said to prove a secret Truman-era UFO panel, Majestic 12, reached a TV producer’s home. The National Archives, the FBI and document experts found the papers to be fakes.
What’s claimed
Majestic 12, also written MJ-12 or Majic-12, is said to be a top-secret panel of scientists, generals and intelligence chiefs that President Harry Truman set up on September 24, 1947, to deal with a crashed flying saucer and alien bodies recovered in New Mexico that summer, the case known as Roswell. The proof, believers say, is a set of documents: a one-page Truman order to Defense Secretary James Forrestal, a seven-page briefing for President-elect Dwight Eisenhower dated November 18, 1952, and a 1954 memo that mentions the group.
What’s on the record
According to William Moore, co-author of the 1980 book The Roswell Incident, the first two documents reached his friend Jaime Shandera, a Los Angeles television writer-producer, in mid-December 1984 on an undeveloped roll of 35-millimetre film, in layers of wrapping with no return address. Moore, Shandera and the UFO researcher Stanton Friedman made them public on May 29, 1987. The third paper, a July 14, 1954 memo from Eisenhower aide Robert Cutler to Air Force chief of staff General Nathan Twining about an "NSC/MJ-12 Special Studies Project", was found by Moore and Shandera among Air Force records at the National Archives in 1985.
The National Archives says its staff searched Air Force, Joint Chiefs of Staff and National Security Council records, and the Truman and Eisenhower libraries searched theirs, without finding the briefing papers or any MJ-12 committee. Of the Cutler memo, the Archives notes that it lacks the top-secret register number used for documents in its series, carries a marking the NSC did not use until the Nixon administration, bears no official letterhead or watermark, and that no NSC meeting is recorded for the briefing date it gives. Klass reported that the Archives also found Cutler was out of the country on the day the memo is dated.
The FBI looked too. In September 1988 the Air Force Office of Special Investigations contacted the FBI’s Dallas office about a copy someone had received in the mail. After the Air Force said on November 30 that no such committee had ever been authorized, the FBI declared the document "completely bogus" and closed its inquiry.
What doesn’t add up
The papers fail on their own details. Philip Klass of the Skeptical Inquirer found that Truman’s signature on the 1947 order matches, down to a small skid of the pen on the "H", the signature on a genuine October 1, 1947 letter to Vannevar Bush held at the Library of Congress, the mark of a photocopied transplant. A document examiner told Klass the order was typed on a Smith-Corona model that first appeared in 1963. Researchers also noticed that the documents’ unusual date style matched the one in Moore’s own notes. In 1989 Moore told a Mutual UFO Network conference that he had deliberately fed fake evidence to other UFO researchers, after being approached by men who presented themselves as Air Force intelligence officers.
Still open
Whoever sent that roll of film to Shandera in 1984 has never been identified; it came with no return address. Moore said men presenting themselves as Air Force intelligence officers approached him, and who they really were has never been established on the record. Searches of the National Archives and the Truman and Eisenhower libraries found no MJ-12 committee. A genuine record of one, with a register number, would change this file.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The National Archives, the presidential libraries, the Air Force and the FBI all looked and found no such committee; the FBI called the papers “completely bogus,” and the forensic details point to forgery. What is documented is that the papers were made and spread, and that one man who released them admitted feeding researchers fake evidence.
Sources
- Document Project BLUE BOOK – Unidentified Flying Objects (including the Majestic 12 reference report) · U.S. National Archives
- News The MJ-12 Crashed-Saucer Documents · Skeptical Inquirer · Dec. 31, 1987
- News New Evidence of MJ-12 Hoax · Skeptical Inquirer · Dec. 31, 1989
- Source Majestic 12 · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.