The Morgan affair, 1826: the vanished anti-Mason who sparked a third party
In September 1826 William Morgan, who planned to publish Masonic rituals, was taken from a New York jail and never seen again; the outcry built America’s first major third party.
What’s claimed
The Morgan affair, also called the William Morgan abduction, began in Batavia, in western New York, in 1826. William Morgan, a stonemason, announced that he would publish the secret rituals of Freemasonry. Weeks later he vanished. The story told ever since is that Freemasons kidnapped and murdered him to protect their secrets, and that the order’s grip on local courts and offices let them escape justice.
What’s on the record
Morgan had settled in Batavia and, Smithsonian reports, had been active in Masonry before turning against it, angered in part by its grip on local politics. An EBSCO research summary notes that it was never conclusively established that he had been initiated, though his descriptions of the rites are generally regarded as accurate. In 1826 he lined up a publisher, the newspaperman David C. Miller. Members of the local lodge answered with harassment: lawsuits against Miller, a short jailing of Morgan in August on a charge involving a borrowed shirt and tie, and, on September 10, an attempt to set fire to Miller’s printing office.
The next day Morgan was arrested again over a debt of about two dollars and taken some 70 kilometres east to the jail in Canandaigua. The following evening a stranger paid the debt. As Morgan was led out he was pushed into a waiting carriage, crying "Murder!" That was the last confirmed sighting of him. Men involved later hinted that they had taken him through Rochester and on to the empty Fort Niagara, at the mouth of the Niagara River.
No body was ever identified and no one was tried for murder. In 1827 Loton Lawson, Nicholas Chesebro and Edward Sawyer were among the men convicted of kidnapping him; History reports sentences ranging from one month to two years, and EBSCO says about 54 Masons were indicted in connection with the conspiracy. Miller published Morgan’s exposé, Illustrations of Masonry, and it became a bestseller.
The light sentences, and officials who were themselves Masons blocking the citizens’ Morgan Committees, turned outrage into politics. On July 4, 1828, citizens of Le Roy, New York, issued a Declaration of Independence From the Masonic Institution. The Anti-Masonic Party followed. In September 1831, in Baltimore, it held what History calls the first presidential nominating convention in US history and adopted the first formal party platform. Its candidate, the former attorney general William Wirt, carried only Vermont in 1832, and the party soon faded, many members moving to the Whigs. Smithsonian reports that Masonic membership was cut nearly in half.
The other side
The abduction is documented; the murder is not proven. With no body and no confession, there could be no murder trial. A Masonic history published by the Grand Lodge of British Columbia and Yukon says it is generally agreed that Morgan was taken to Canada and paid $500 to stay away, and other stories place him farther abroad. Against that, the former Batavia Mason Samuel D. Greene wrote in an 1870 memoir that lodge members treated Morgan’s death as understood. Historians Ronald Formisano and Kathleen Smith Kutolowski have called the affair the Watergate of its era, Smithsonian notes.
Still open
What happened to William Morgan after he was pushed into the carriage at Canandaigua is still unknown. No body was ever identified, no one was tried for murder, and the men involved only ever hinted at Fort Niagara. A Masonic account says he was paid $500 to go to Canada; an 1870 memoir by a former Batavia Mason says lodge members treated his death as understood. Even whether Morgan was ever initiated was never conclusively established.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. Morgan’s abduction, the kidnapping convictions and the political movement that followed are all on the record. Where he went after Canandaigua has never been established, and murder, though widely believed, was never proven in court.
Sources
- News The Masonic Murder That Inspired the First Third Party in American Politics · Smithsonian Magazine · July 10, 2023
- News One Man Exposed the Secrets of the Freemasons. His Disappearance Led to Their Downfall · HISTORY (A&E Television Networks) · Dec. 18, 2018
- News 5 Things You May Not Know About U.S. Political Conventions · HISTORY (A&E Television Networks) · Aug. 29, 2012
- Source Masonry and censorship · EBSCO Research Starters
- Source The Morgan Affair (a Masonic account) · Grand Lodge of British Columbia and Yukon
More: the case files, every source behind every story.