Mothman and the Silver Bridge: Point Pleasant’s 1966 sightings and the 1967 collapse
Point Pleasant’s Mothman sightings began in November 1966; 13 months later the Silver Bridge fell, killing 46. Investigators traced the collapse to a cracked eyebar, not an omen.
What’s claimed
Mothman is a winged, man-sized creature with glowing red eyes said to have haunted Point Pleasant, West Virginia, in 1966 and 1967. The legend holds that it was a warning, or even a cause, of the town’s worst disaster: the collapse of the Silver Bridge over the Ohio River on December 15, 1967. Over the years the story has gathered UFOs, “men in black” and a supposed curse of the Shawnee chief Cornstalk.
What’s on the record
Late on November 15, 1966, two young couples, Roger and Linda Scarberry and Steve and Mary Mallette, were driving through the “TNT area” north of town, the former West Virginia Ordnance Works where explosives were made during the Second World War. They told the Point Pleasant Register they saw a figure six or seven feet tall with glowing red eyes near an old power plant, and that it followed their car toward town. Linda Scarberry later said they were doing 100 to 105 miles an hour while the thing glided over the back of the car, NPR reported in 2025. The Register’s headline the next day read “Couples See Man-Sized Bird...Creature...Something,” and Mary Hyre of the Athens Messenger in Ohio covered it on November 16.
The West Virginia Encyclopedia counts 26 reported sightings over about a year, most near the TNT plant. Skeptics had answers at the time: some argued it was a stray sandhill crane, and a young Breece D’J Pancake, later a celebrated writer, wrote to a Huntington paper in 1966 suggesting a California condor. Hunting parties went out looking.
The Silver Bridge was real steel. Opened in 1928 between Point Pleasant and Kanauga, Ohio, it hung from chains of paired eyebars rather than wire cables. At about 5 p.m. on December 15, 1967, during rush hour, the suspended span fell into the river. The West Virginia Department of Transportation records 32 vehicles and 46 victims, two of whose bodies were never found.
The National Transportation Safety Board issued its finding on April 6, 1971. It traced the collapse to a cleavage fracture in eyebar 330 at joint C13N of the north chain, caused by a flaw that grew to critical size over the bridge’s 40-year life through stress corrosion and corrosion fatigue. The board found the crack was hidden from visual inspection and that, in 1927, such corrosion was not known to occur in those materials in rural conditions. NPR notes the disaster led Congress to pass the first National Bridge Inspection Standards.
The Mothman link came from writer John Keel, who wove the sightings, the men in black and the bridge into The Mothman Prophecies, published in 1975 and made into a 2002 film with Richard Gere. Sightings faded after the collapse.
What doesn’t add up
The bridge’s failure has a physical cause, found in the wreckage and set out in a federal report. The omen idea was assembled after the fact, in a book published eight years later; Smithsonian notes that many people saw no connection in an alleged sighting just before the collapse. Meg Nicholas of the Library of Congress’s American Folklife Center told NPR the warning story gives people a feeling of power over the unthinkable. That explains why it endures, not that it is true. What the witnesses saw in 1966 remains unidentified.
Still open
What the witnesses saw in 1966 has never been identified: a stray sandhill crane and a California condor were both suggested at the time, and neither was confirmed. Two of the 46 victims’ bodies were never found. The bridge itself is not an open question: the NTSB traced its fall to a hidden crack in eyebar 330, and nothing in the record ties the sightings to it.
Where it stands (for now)
Tinfoil. The 1966 sightings were reported and the 1967 collapse killed 46 people, but nothing links a creature to the bridge. The NTSB traced the disaster to a cracked eyebar; the omen story was assembled eight years later, in a book.
Sources
- News Mothman Festival draws visitors to Point Pleasant West Virginia · NPR · Sept. 30, 2025
- News West Virginia’s Mothman Leads Cryptid Renaissance · Smithsonian Magazine (Smithsonian Center for Folklife and Cultural Heritage) · Oct. 20, 2021
- Source Mothman · e-WV: The West Virginia Encyclopedia
- Document Silver Bridge · West Virginia Department of Transportation
- News Earlier Disaster Led to Focus on Bridge Safety · NPR · Aug. 1, 2007
More: the case files, every source behind every story.