Historical mysteries

Oak Island’s Money Pit: two centuries of digging for a treasure no one has found

Treasure hunters have dug, drilled and died on a small Nova Scotia island since the 1790s, and the province now licenses the search, but the engineered vault at its heart rests on accounts written down decades later.

UnconfirmedThin or second-hand evidence so far. Nobody has proven it, and nobody has closed it.

Published Oct. 10, 2026Last checked Oct. 5, 2026

What’s claimed

Oak Island is a small wooded island in Mahone Bay, on Nova Scotia’s South Shore. Since the late 1700s, people have believed that a shaft on its eastern end, the "Money Pit," is an engineered vault guarding something of enormous value. Suggested contents include the gold of Captain Kidd, Henry Morgan or Blackbeard, riches carried north by Inca refugees, the Holy Grail hidden by the Knights Templar, or Shakespearean manuscripts. The legend comes with its own engineering: log platforms every 10 feet, a stone carved with symbols, and flood tunnels built to drown anyone who digs too deep.

What’s on the record

The standard account begins in 1795, when a 16-year-old named Daniel McGinnis noticed a depression in the ground near an oak and, with two friends, dug into what looked like a filled-in shaft. That account was written down long after the fact. The first known mention in print came in 1857, when the Liverpool Transcript reported a group digging for Kidd’s treasure; one of the original diggers, Anthony Vaughan, had his recollections recorded by the same paper in 1862. The earliest accounts speak of "marks" at 10-foot intervals; the oak platforms belong to later tellings.

In the early 1800s, a group known as the Onslow Company dug to somewhere between 27 and 30 metres before seawater flooded the shaft. The inscribed stone said to have come out of the pit has its own problem: when Henry Bowdoin of the Old Gold Salvage group examined a stone in Halifax in 1909, he found a piece of basalt with no symbols on it. One member of his group was a young Franklin D. Roosevelt.

In 1965, four men, Robert Restall, his son, Karl Graeser and Cyril Hiltz, died in a shaft at Smith’s Cove after being overcome by fumes, reported as hydrogen sulphide. In 1971, the Triton Alliance lowered a camera into a deep steel-cased shaft known as Borehole 10-X, and its partners said the pictures showed possible chests, tools and human remains. The images were never independently confirmed, and divers sent to the bottom of the shaft in 2016 found no artifacts.

Nova Scotia treats the search as a licensed activity. The Oak Island Treasure Act received royal assent on December 10, 2010, and took effect on January 1, 2011. It lets the Minister of Natural Resources license searches on the island and charge a royalty on finds, and it defines treasure as "precious stones or metals in a state other than their natural state." The province introduced it alongside the repeal of the 1954 Treasure Trove Act, which had been written for Oak Island and later used to license shipwreck hunting.

What doesn’t add up

No treasure has come out of the pit, and after generations of shafts and bore holes, the original shaft’s location is no longer known. Geology offers a plainer account. Steven Aitken, a retired geologist from the oil industry, told CBC in 2020 that the bedrock under the east side of the island is Windsor Group limestone and gypsum, minerals prone to dissolving into caves. Drawing on two engineering consultants’ reports and a 1995 Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution report, he concluded that the Money Pit is a sinkhole over a collapsed cave and that the so-called flood tunnels are natural features. "There is no treasure at the money pit," he said. The investigator Joe Nickell reached a similar view in Skeptical Inquirer in 2000, arguing that the pit began as a sinkhole and that much of the legend’s symbolism echoes Masonic ritual.

Still open

After generations of shafts and bore holes, nobody knows where the original Money Pit was, so the first diggers’ find can’t be checked on the ground. The earliest written accounts date from 1857 and 1862, more than 60 years after 1795. The 1971 Borehole 10-X pictures of possible chests and remains were never independently confirmed, and divers in 2016 found no artifacts. A find that meets the Treasure Act’s definition, confirmed by someone with no stake in it, would reopen everything.

Where it stands (for now)

Unconfirmed. The digging, the deaths and the provincial licence are all on the record. The engineered vault rests on accounts first printed decades after the supposed discovery and on finds never independently confirmed, and geologists who have studied the island describe a natural sinkhole that would explain both the pit and its water.

Sources

  1. Source Oak Island · The Canadian Encyclopedia · Feb. 6, 2006
  2. Document Oak Island Treasure Act (Bill 81, Chapter 39 of the Acts of 2010) · Nova Scotia Legislature · Dec. 9, 2010
    “"treasure" means precious stones or metals in a state other than their natural state.”
  3. Document Changes to Treasure Hunting Regulations Introduced · Government of Nova Scotia · Nov. 1, 2010
  4. News Money pit or sinkhole? Retired geologist digs up Oak Island’s history · CBC News · May 15, 2020
    “"There is no treasure at the money pit," Aitken told CBC's Maritime Noon on Friday.”
  5. Source Secrets at Oak Island · Center for Inquiry (Joe Nickell) · Sept. 23, 2018
  6. Source Oak Island mystery · Wikipedia

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip