Operation Mincemeat: the dead man, the fake plans and the 1943 Sicily deception
In 1943 British intelligence floated a corpse dressed as “Major William Martin” off Spain with fake invasion plans; decades later the body was identified as Welshman Glyndwr Michael.
What’s claimed
Operation Mincemeat, the story of "the man who never was", sounds like spy fiction. In the spring of 1943, British intelligence dressed a dead man as an officer, chained a briefcase of fake secret letters to him and let him drift ashore in Spain, so that the Germans would believe the Allies were about to invade Greece rather than Sicily. It became the 1956 film The Man Who Never Was and, in 2022, a feature film. For decades the identity of the dead man was itself kept secret.
What’s on the record
The body was that of Glyndwr Michael, a homeless man from Aberbargoed in south Wales, found in a disused warehouse near King’s Cross in London in January 1943 after swallowing rat poison containing phosphorus. The St Pancras coroner, Bentley Purchase, helped the planners obtain the body. Two intelligence officers, Ewen Montagu and Charles Cholmondeley, built a full identity for Captain (Acting Major) William Martin of the Royal Marines: theatre ticket stubs, a letter from his father, an overdraft notice from Lloyd’s Bank, and love letters from a fiancée called Pam. The idea of using a corpse to plant false papers drew on a scheme first sketched by Ian Fleming, later the creator of James Bond.
The body was kept in a mortuary refrigerator in Hackney, then packed in dry ice, driven to Scotland and carried by the submarine HMS Seraph to the Spanish coast, where it was released. A sardine fisherman found it near Huelva on April 30, 1943. Spain was officially neutral but full of German agents, and the letters, which pointed to Greece, reached German intelligence; copies reached Hitler, the BBC has reported. Codebreakers at Bletchley Park, reading German messages, could follow the deception as it took hold. Montagu’s team cabled Churchill: "Mincemeat swallowed rod, line and sinker." The Allies landed in Sicily on July 10, 1943, and took the island within 38 days.
Michael was buried in Huelva with military honours under the name William Martin. In 1996 amateur historian Roger Morgan found evidence of his identity in the Public Record Office, and in 1998, after the government confirmed it, a line was added to the headstone saying that Glyndwr Michael had served as Major William Martin.
What doesn’t add up
Even with the files open, questions remain. Historian Ben Macintyre has suggested Michael may not have meant to die at all, but was so hungry he ate bread laid out as rat poison. The coroner’s paperwork was bent to fit the plan: the BBC reported that Purchase falsified documents suggesting Michael’s family had agreed, when his parents were already dead.
Some writers dispute whose body it was. In 2003 Colin Gribbons argued it was Able Seaman Thomas Martin, and in 2004 John and Noreen Steele argued it was John Melville, both sailors lost when the carrier HMS Dasher blew up in the Firth of Clyde in March 1943. In 2022 Admiral Lord West said there was circumstantial evidence for Melville. The British government’s identification of Glyndwr Michael still stands.
Still open
Whether Glyndwr Michael meant to die is still unknown; Ben Macintyre has suggested he may simply have eaten bread laid out as rat poison because he was hungry. Rival identifications from 2003 and 2004 name two sailors lost on HMS Dasher, and in 2022 Admiral Lord West spoke of circumstantial evidence for John Melville. The government’s identification still stands, though the same story shows the coroner falsified paperwork to suggest a family’s consent.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The deception, the fake papers and the landing in Sicily are on the record, and the British government has identified the body as Glyndwr Michael. Rival identifications have been proposed, but none has displaced the official one so far.
Sources
- News Operation Mincemeat: How a dead tramp fooled Hitler · BBC News · Dec. 2, 2010
- News Operation Mincemeat: The Welsh drifter who helped end WW2 · BBC News · April 13, 2022
- News Operation Mincemeat by Ben Macintyre (review) · The Observer (The Guardian) · Jan. 23, 2010
- News Operation Mincemeat: Role of Hackney mortuary marked in Colin Firth film · Hackney Gazette · Dec. 2, 2021
- Source Glyndwr Michael · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.