Operation Sea-Spray: the 1950 germ-warfare test sprayed over San Francisco
In September 1950 the US military released bacteria from a ship off San Francisco to see how a germ attack would spread over the city; the test is documented, but whether it killed anyone has never been proven.
What’s claimed
That in 1950 the US military secretly sprayed bacteria over San Francisco to test the city’s vulnerability to germ warfare, without telling the people who lived there, and that the test made people sick and killed at least one man.
What’s on the record
For six days in late September 1950, a vessel off San Francisco released a huge cloud of Serratia marcescens, a bacterium that forms bright red colonies and is easy to trace. Smithsonian magazine and Discover describe a Navy minesweeper about two miles offshore. PBS’s American Experience places it among the tests run by the Army Chemical Corps’ Special Operations Division at Camp Detrick, which released bacteria from Navy ships off Norfolk, Virginia, in April 1950 and off San Francisco that September. According to The Conversation, a second organism, Bacillus globigii, was also used.
Samples from 43 sites found the bacteria across San Francisco and in Sausalito, Albany, Berkeley, Oakland, San Leandro, Daly City and Colma. PBS says the results showed exposure among almost all of the city’s 800,000 residents. A 1951 military report, quoted by Discover, concluded that "a successful BW attack on this area can be launched from the sea." At the time, officials believed the bacterium did not cause disease.
Soon after the spraying, 11 patients at the old Stanford University Hospital in San Francisco came down with unusual, hard-to-treat Serratia infections, the first recorded outbreak of the organism; the hospital’s doctors wrote it up for a medical journal. One patient, Edward Nevin, 75, recovering from prostate surgery, died after the infection attacked his heart valves. Neither his doctors nor his family learned of the test for nearly 26 years, the San Francisco Chronicle reported, and the Chronicle found no evidence that the Army had alerted health authorities beforehand.
San Francisco was not unique. Discover, citing The Wall Street Journal, says the military ran open-air tests at least 239 times in at least eight cities between 1950 and 1966, and PBS says a 1953 program staged mock anthrax attacks on St. Louis, Minneapolis and Winnipeg. President Richard Nixon’s 1969 order ending the US offensive biological weapons program brought the open-air testing to a close.
What doesn’t add up
The link between the spraying and the hospital cases was never proven. Nevin’s family sued the government; PBS reports that the courts ruled against them, mainly because they could not show that the test bacteria were the ones that killed him. Sources even differ on when he died, from three weeks to six months after the test, and on whether the testing became public in 1976 or 1977. A later idea, that the military’s strain settled permanently in the Bay Area and kept causing infections, remains speculation: a UC Berkeley infectious-disease specialist told the Chronicle in 2004 that proving it would take a DNA fingerprint of the original strain.
Still open
Whether the test caused the Stanford outbreak or Edward Nevin’s death was never proven; the courts ruled that his family could not show the test bacteria were the ones that killed him. Sources still differ on when he died and on whether the testing became public in 1976 or 1977. The idea that the strain settled in the Bay Area for good is untested: a UC Berkeley specialist said proving it would take a DNA fingerprint of the original strain.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The release of bacteria over San Francisco in September 1950, and the reason for it, are on the record. A link to the Stanford outbreak or Nevin’s death is plausible but has never been proven, and the claim that the test permanently changed the region’s microbes remains speculation.
Sources
-
Source
Secret Testing in the United States
· PBS American Experience · May 29, 2019
“The San Francisco experiments showed exposure among almost all of the city’s 800,000 residents.” - News In 1950, the U.S. Released a Bioweapon in San Francisco · Smithsonian Magazine · July 5, 2015
- News Serratia has dark history in region / Army test in 1950 may have changed microbial ecology · San Francisco Chronicle (SFGate) · Oct. 30, 2004
- News Blood & Fog: The Military’s Germ Warfare Tests in San Francisco · Discover Magazine · June 27, 2015
- News The US has a history of testing biological weapons on the public – were infected ticks used too? · The Conversation · July 21, 2019
More: the case files, every source behind every story.