Operation Snow White: how Scientology infiltrated US government offices in the 1970s
Members of the Church of Scientology’s Guardian’s Office took jobs in US agencies, forged identity cards and copied government files about the church; the FBI raided the church in 1977 and senior officials, including L. Ron Hubbard’s wife, were convicted.
What’s claimed
It reads like a spy novel turned inside out. Instead of a government agency infiltrating a church, a church infiltrated the government. The story told about Operation Snow White is that, in the 1970s, the Church of Scientology placed its own people inside the Internal Revenue Service and the US Justice Department, forged identity cards, bugged a meeting and walked out with copies of the government’s files on Scientology.
What’s on the record
The core of it is in federal court records. Wikipedia traces the operation’s name to Guardian Order 732, issued by L. Ron Hubbard on April 20, 1973, which called for inaccurate government files about Scientology to be removed and corrected. Wikipedia notes that the order specified legal means. The work fell to the church’s Guardian’s Office.
According to the 1981 appeals-court ruling that upheld the convictions, a church member had a job as a clerk-typist at the IRS by November 1974. In March 1975, false identification cards in invented names were made with IRS equipment in the building’s identification-card room. Documents were copied, including on photocopiers in the US Attorney’s office after hours. On June 11, 1976, FBI agents confronted two of the participants in a law library at the courthouse; they had been using forged credentials to get at a prosecutor’s files. One of them later changed sides: on June 20, 1977, he telephoned the US Attorney’s office, offered to co-operate and surrendered that evening.
On July 8, 1977, more than 200 agents executed search warrants at Scientology offices in Washington and at two sites in Hollywood, in searches lasting more than 20 hours. In a related ruling, the same court said the government seized approximately 50,000 documents in Los Angeles.
Nine defendants, among them Mary Sue Hubbard, the founder’s wife and a senior officer of the Guardian’s Office, agreed to be judged on a stipulated record of about 200 documents, and in 1979 each was found guilty of one count: seven of conspiracy to obstruct justice, one of conspiracy to obtain government documents illegally and one of theft of government property. Wikipedia reports that Mary Sue Hubbard was sentenced on December 6, 1979, to five years in prison. On October 2, 1981, the US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit affirmed the convictions and rejected every argument on appeal, including the challenge to the FBI searches. UPI later counted eleven top Scientologists convicted in all. L. Ron Hubbard was named an unindicted co-conspirator and was never prosecuted.
The other side
The church’s legal fight centred on the searches, which it argued were unconstitutional; the courts disagreed. It did win one point: in 1980 the appeals court stopped the trial judge from releasing the seized papers to the public and sent the question back, noting that the church kept a property interest in its documents.
The church later distanced itself from the operation. In September 1981, UPI reported that Bill Franks, then its executive director international, told members the England-based Guardian’s Office had gone "adrift," citing the criminal cases as an example. The church disbanded the Guardian’s Office in 1983 and replaced it with the Office of Special Affairs.
The full international reach of the operation is harder to pin down. Secondary accounts, Wikipedia’s among them, count 136 agencies, embassies and organizations in more than 30 countries; the court records we checked deal only with the US case.
Still open
The operation’s full reach abroad is hard to pin down: secondary accounts count 136 agencies, embassies and organizations in more than 30 countries, but the court records checked deal only with the US case. In 1980 the appeals court stopped the trial judge from releasing the seized papers and sent the question back; how much of the roughly 50,000 documents ever became public isn’t clear from the public record. L. Ron Hubbard was named an unindicted co-conspirator, so his part was never tested in court.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The infiltration, the forged credentials, the FBI searches and the convictions are set out in federal court rulings, and the church itself later said the office responsible had gone adrift. How far the operation reached beyond the United States rests so far on secondary accounts.
Sources
-
Document
United States v. Heldt, 668 F.2d 1238 (D.C. Cir. 1981)
· US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit (via Public.Resource.Org) · Oct. 1, 1981
“Members of the Church of Scientology were indicted for completed conspiracies and substantive offenses involving their plan to identify, locate and obtain by various illegal means certain documents” -
Document
United States v. Hubbard, 650 F.2d 293 (D.C. Cir. 1980)
· US Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit (via Public.Resource.Org) · July 23, 1980
“Close to three years ago the government seized approximately 50,000 documents from two Los Angeles sites of the Church of Scientology of California.” - News The Church of Scientology, reacting to a host of... · UPI Archives · Sept. 12, 1981
- News Scientology’s Battle for Religious Tax Exemption · Scripps News · March 7, 2018
- Source Operation Snow White · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.