Palomares, 1966: the H-bombs lost over Spain and the airmen sent to clean up
In 1966 a B-52 collided with a tanker over Spain and dropped four hydrogen bombs, one into the sea. Airmen who cleaned up say the Air Force hid the risk; it says no one was harmed.
What’s claimed
Two claims hang over Palomares, a village on Spain’s Mediterranean coast. One concerns the sea: that the United States lost a hydrogen bomb off Spain in 1966 and played down the danger while it searched. The other concerns the men: that the American airmen sent to clean up the spilled plutonium were exposed with little protection, and that the Air Force spent decades insisting nobody had been harmed.
What’s on the record
On January 17, 1966, a Strategic Air Command B-52 collided with a refuelling tanker at 31,000 feet over the Mediterranean off southern Spain. The tanker was destroyed, killing its four crew, and three of the bomber’s seven crew died, according to the Association for Diplomatic Studies and Training. The B-52 carried four hydrogen bombs. None produced a nuclear explosion, but the conventional explosives in two went off when they hit the ground, scattering about three kilograms of plutonium, The Associated Press reported. Three bombs were found on land. The fourth fell into the sea.
The hunt drew in dozens of US Navy ships. A local fisherman, Francisco Simó Orts, had seen the bomb fall and was hired to help. With the submersible Alvin playing a central part, the bomb was raised on April 7, 1966, 80 days after the crash, and shown to the press. Foreign correspondents had been kept away from the area in the early days. On March 8, Spain’s information minister, Manuel Fraga, and the US ambassador, Angier Biddle Duke, swam off the beach in front of photographers to show the water was safe.
US forces shipped roughly 1,750 tons of soil to the United States, but in 2008 Spain’s energy research agency, CIEMAT, found trenches where contaminated earth had been buried in 1966. On October 19, 2015, Secretary of State John Kerry and Spain’s foreign minister signed a statement of intent to negotiate a binding agreement for further clean-up and for removing contaminated soil to the United States.
About 1,600 airmen were ordered to the site. In 2017 Vietnam Veterans of America sued the Defence Department for records of their radiation exposure, alleging that the Air Force had neither protected nor warned them. Victor Skaar, a retired Air Force medic who spent 62 days at Palomares, told the association’s magazine that the men had surgical masks and only a handful of radiation detectors; the magazine quotes a February 1966 memo saying it “would seem preferable to go back to normality as soon as possible.” In December 2019 the US Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims allowed the veterans’ appeal to proceed as a class action.
What doesn’t add up
The Air Force has long maintained that there was no harmful radiation at Palomares and that all safety precautions were followed. Linking any one veteran’s illness to the clean-up is difficult, and Skaar’s own claims were long refused because his exposure records were unavailable and could not be corroborated. The 2015 statement left the details of further clean-up confidential, and it was only a commitment to negotiate.
Still open
Whether the Air Force understated the airmen’s exposure, and whether it made them ill, has not been settled: Skaar’s claims were long refused because his exposure records were unavailable, and the veterans had to sue in 2017 for their own records. The 2015 agreement kept the details of further clean-up confidential and was only a commitment to negotiate. Trenches of buried soil turned up in 2008.
Where it stands (for now)
Redacted. The crash, the lost bomb, the plutonium and the thin protection for the clean-up crews are on the record. The Air Force maintains no one was harmed; whether it understated the airmen’s exposure, and whether that made them ill, has not been settled.
Sources
- Source A Real Life ‘Thunderball’: The Day the U.S. Lost Hydrogen Bombs in Spain · Association for Diplomatic Studies and Training
- News US, Spain agree in principle to joint cleanup of 1966 hydrogen bomb mishap · Fox News (Associated Press) · Oct. 18, 2015
- News Veterans Sickened by Plutonium Sue Pentagon for Records · Yale Law School · Oct. 2, 2017
- News Palomares Nuclear Disaster · The VVA Veteran (Vietnam Veterans of America)
- Source 1966 Palomares B-52 crash · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.