Secret technology

Printer tracking dots: the hidden yellow code on colour laser printouts

Many colour laser printers hide a faint grid of yellow dots on every page that can record when it was printed and on which machine. A digital rights group cracked one code in 2005.

DeclassifiedThey admitted it, on paper: official files, admissions or solid evidence. What else is still in the drawer?

Published Oct. 9, 2026Last checked Oct. 18, 2026

What’s claimed

Printer tracking dots, also called yellow dots or a machine identification code, are said to be a secret watermark: a pattern of tiny yellow specks that colour laser printers and copiers add to every page, quietly recording which machine printed it and when. In the usual telling, governments made private deals with printer makers so that any printed page can be traced to its source, and the dots have been used to catch people.

What’s on the record

All of that is documented. On October 16, 2005, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a digital rights group in San Francisco, announced that a research team including its Seth Schoen had broken the code used by Xerox DocuColor printers. The dots, each less than a millimetre across, repeat across the page and are hard to see in ordinary light; a blue light, a magnifying glass or a microscope shows them. On DocuColor machines, the EFF’s decoding guide explains, each page carries a grid of 15 by 8 yellow dots that encodes the printer’s serial number and the year, month, day, hour and minute of printing.

The EFF said the US Secret Service confirmed that the tracking was part of a deal with selected manufacturers, ostensibly to identify counterfeiters, and that Xerox said only the Secret Service could read the code. The group pointed out that no law prevented the government from misusing the information. It later kept a list of printers that did or did not seem to print the dots, then put a warning at the top: documents it obtained under freedom-of-information requests suggested all major makers of colour laser printers had a secret agreement with governments, so it is probably safest to assume every modern colour laser printer leaves some form of tracking information.

The case that made the dots famous came in June 2017. On June 5, The Intercept published a top-secret National Security Agency report on Russian military intelligence attempts to break into US election systems, illustrated with scans of the printed pages. The Justice Department announced the arrest of Reality Winner, a contractor at the NSA, the same day. Robert Graham, head of Errata Security, showed that the scans carried DocuColor dots pointing to a printer with serial number 29535218 and a print time on May 9, 2017, Fortune reported. Winner, an Air Force veteran working for the contractor Pluribus International, pleaded guilty and on August 23, 2018, was sentenced to five years and three months in prison, NPR reported; prosecutors called it the longest sentence served for an unauthorized disclosure to the media.

What doesn’t add up

What is unclear is how much the dots mattered in that case. The FBI’s arrest affidavit did not mention them; it cited creases showing the pages had been printed and folded. The EFF wrote that the dots may have played no role in the investigation. NPR’s 2018 report, by contrast, said investigators ultimately used “microdots” on the printout to identify the exact printer. Either way, the dots were there for anyone who studied the published scans. The EFF also warns that newer printers may track pages by subtly rearranging the dots they print rather than adding visible ones, so a page without obvious dots proves nothing.

Still open

How much the dots mattered in the Winner case is still unclear: the FBI’s affidavit cited creases, not dots; the EFF said they may have played no role; NPR reported that investigators used them. Which makers agreed to what, with which governments, has not been laid out on the record; the EFF’s documents only suggest a secret agreement. Newer printers may hide the code by rearranging the dots, so a page without obvious dots proves nothing.

Where it stands (for now)

Declassified. The dots, what they record and the Secret Service’s involvement were confirmed in 2005, and the EFF still advises assuming every colour laser printer tracks its pages. What hasn’t been shown is how often investigators rely on them.

Sources

  1. Document Secret Code in Color Printers Lets Government Track You · Electronic Frontier Foundation · Oct. 15, 2005
  2. Document DocuColor Tracking Dot Decoding Guide · Electronic Frontier Foundation
    “The DocuColor series prints a rectangular grid of 15 by 8 miniscule yellow dots on every color page.”
  3. Document List of Printers Which Do or Do Not Display Tracking Dots · Electronic Frontier Foundation
  4. News Printer Tracking Dots Back in the News · Electronic Frontier Foundation (Seth Schoen) · June 5, 2017
  5. News Reality Winner: How NSA Contractor Suspected of Leaking Was Found · Fortune · June 5, 2017
  6. News Reality Winner Sentenced To 5 Years, 3 Months For Leaking Classified Info · NPR · Aug. 22, 2018

More: the case files, every source behind every story.

Talk about it

Start a thread on this story Know more? Send a tip