PROFUNC: the RCMP’s secret Cold War plan to intern Canadian communists
From 1950 into the 1980s the RCMP kept secret lists of suspected communists to round up in a national emergency; The Canadian Press exposed PROFUNC in 2000 and the CBC dug deeper in 2010.
What’s claimed
PROFUNC (also written Profunc or Operation Profunc, short for PROminent FUNCtionaries of the Communist Party) was, according to the reporters who uncovered it, a secret Royal Canadian Mounted Police plan to arrest thousands of Canadians and hold them in camps if the Cold War turned hot. It sounds like the plot of a paranoid novel: sealed envelopes in Mountie detachments, children on the lists, escape routes from each target’s home worked out in advance. The question is how much of it was real.
What’s on the record
Nearly all of it, on paper. The plan was first reported by Dean Beeby of The Canadian Press on January 24, 2000, from records released under the Access to Information Act. A 1970 RCMP memo counted "588 males and 174 females" to be arrested as subversives in a national emergency, 762 people in all, including 13 children under 11. Three federal prisons were to be emptied for them: Drumheller in Alberta and Warkworth in Ontario for men, and Joyceville, near Kingston, for women. A camp manual from the 1960s set out punishment diets of bread and water.
In October 2010 a joint investigation by CBC’s The Fifth Estate and Radio-Canada’s Enquête added much more. It reported that RCMP Commissioner Stuart Taylor Wood devised the plan in 1950, listing some 16,000 suspected communists and 50,000 sympathizers to be watched and possibly interned. Files held each target’s age, description, photographs, vehicle and housing details, even the doors they might use to escape, and were kept up to date until the early 1980s. Under the plan, detainees could be held indefinitely and shot if they tried to escape. A 1951 document listed reception centres and camps across the country, among them the Port Arthur Country Club in Ontario, a women’s facility in Kelowna and a men’s camp in Chilliwack, B.C.; one Toronto family on the lists would have been taken first to Casa Loma. In Ontario alone, more than 2,000 people were approved or awaiting approval for internment in 1953. Roland Penner, later Manitoba’s attorney general, was among those monitored.
The emergency the plan was built for never came. Documents show it was abandoned on the justice minister’s order in 1983; no reason was given, though the creation of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service in 1984 may have played a part. The CBC reported that administrative changes made by Solicitor General Robert Kaplan brought it to an end.
What doesn’t add up
The open question is whether PROFUNC was ever put to use. CBC and Radio-Canada found evidence that its blacklist may have been used to add names to the roundup during the October Crisis of 1970, when as many as 500 people were arrested after the War Measures Act was invoked, many with no link to the FLQ. One Montreal Communist bookstore manager arrested then was on the PROFUNC list, though his RCMP file showed no FLQ activity. That link rests on reporting and interviews, not an official admission, and files people have obtained, such as Penner’s, are mostly redacted.
Still open
Whether the PROFUNC lists were used to add names to the October Crisis arrests of 1970 rests on CBC and Radio-Canada reporting and interviews, not an official admission. The files people have obtained, such as Roland Penner’s, are mostly redacted. The plan was abandoned in 1983 on the justice minister’s order with no reason given. Unredacted files, or an RCMP record tying the lists to 1970, would settle the open part.
Where it stands (for now)
Declassified. The RCMP’s internment lists, camps and procedures are in its own records, released under access-to-information law. The suggestion that PROFUNC fed the 1970 arrests is reported and plausible, but it rests on journalism rather than an official admission, and the files that might settle it are mostly redacted.
Sources
- News RCMP had plan to intern ‘subversives’ · The Globe and Mail (The Canadian Press) · Jan. 23, 2000
- News Secret Cold War plan included mass detentions · CBC News · Oct. 13, 2010
- News Former Manitoba AG on secret internment list · CBC News · Oct. 14, 2010
- News Secret internment plan included Toronto landmark · CBC News · Oct. 14, 2010
- Source PROFUNC · Wikipedia
More: the case files, every source behind every story.